TL;DR
The BABAR experiment searched for two rare B meson decays, B+ → D+K⁰ and B+ → D+K*⁰, which are theoretically predicted to proceed through "weak annihilation" mechanisms. No significant evidence for these decays was found, leading to the establishment of new upper limits on their branching fractions, providing valuable constraints for theoretical models of B meson physics.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
B mesons are composed of a bottom quark and a lighter antiquark. Their decays are crucial for understanding the fundamental forces of nature, particularly the weak force and the CKM mechanism that governs quark mixing. The decays B+ → D+K⁰ and B+ → D+K*⁰ are particularly interesting because they are expected to be dominated by a process called "weak annihilation." In this process, the constituent quarks of the B meson (a 'b' quark and an 'anti-u' quark in the B+) annihilate into a W boson, which then decays. This "annihilation" process is theoretically challenging to calculate precisely, unlike more common "spectator" decays where one quark decays while the other acts as a spectator. Therefore, experimental measurements of these annihilation-dominated decays are vital for testing and refining theoretical models of B meson physics, especially concerning the overlap of quark wave functions within the meson and the CKM matrix elements. Previous searches had not observed these specific decay modes, leaving a gap in our understanding.
Methods
The BABAR experiment utilized a large dataset of B meson decays collected at the PEP-II collider. The core of the analysis involved reconstructing candidate B+ mesons by identifying a D+ meson and either a K⁰ or K*⁰ meson.
- D+ Reconstruction: D+ mesons were reconstructed in several decay channels, including D+ → K⁻π⁺π⁺, D+ → K⁰π⁺, D+ → K⁻π⁺π⁺π⁰, and D+ → K⁰π⁺π⁰. Kaon identification was crucial and was achieved using Cherenkov light information from the DIRC detector and ionization energy loss measurements.
- K⁰ and K*⁰ Reconstruction: K⁰ mesons were reconstructed from pairs of oppositely charged pions, with their invariant mass constrained to the known K⁰ mass. K⁰ mesons were reconstructed from a charged kaon and a charged pion, with their invariant mass constrained to the known K⁰ mass.
- B+ Reconstruction: Candidate B+ mesons were formed by combining a reconstructed D+ meson with a K⁰ or K*⁰ meson. These combinations were then subjected to kinematic cuts based on the invariant mass of the B candidate (MES) and the difference between its energy and the beam energy (ΔE).
- Background Suppression: A significant challenge was distinguishing signal events from background. The primary background sources were continuum e⁺e⁻ → q q̄ events and other B meson decays (combinatorial and peaking BB background). A Fisher discriminant was employed to exploit the jet-like nature of continuum events, using variables related to the event shape. Additionally, flavor tagging of the other B meson in the event was used to further reduce continuum contamination.
- Statistical Analysis: The number of signal and background events was determined by performing a maximum likelihood fit to the reconstructed MES and Fisher discriminant distributions. This fit utilized probability density functions (PDFs) modeled using Monte Carlo simulations and validated with data.
Datasets
The analysis used data collected by the BABAR detector at the PEP-II asymmetric-energy e⁺e⁻ collider.
- On-resonance data: Approximately 465 million BB pairs collected at the Y(4S) resonance.
- Off-resonance data: An additional 44.4 fb⁻¹ of data collected at a center-of-mass energy 40 MeV below the Y(4S) resonance, used for studying continuum background.
- Monte Carlo (MC) simulations: Used extensively to model signal and background processes, and to optimize selection criteria and determine efficiencies.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Probing Weak Annihilation: The search directly probes the poorly understood weak annihilation mechanism in B meson decays, offering a unique window into the internal dynamics of these particles.
- Constraining Theoretical Models: The lack of observed signal and the resulting upper limits provide crucial data points for theorists to refine their models of B meson decays and the CKM matrix.
- Methodological Rigor: The analysis demonstrates a sophisticated approach to background rejection and signal extraction, employing advanced techniques like Fisher discriminants and detailed PDF modeling for the likelihood fit.
- Complementary Information: The results for B+ → D+K⁰ and B+ → D+K*⁰ decays are complementary to other B decay measurements, contributing to a more complete picture of B physics.
Key Results
The BABAR experiment found no significant evidence for either of the searched-for decay modes.
- Upper Limits: The 90% probability upper limits on the branching fractions were set at:
- B(B+ → D+K⁰) < 2.9 × 10⁻⁶
- B(B+ → D+K*⁰) < 3.0 × 10⁻⁶
- Improvement: The result for B+ → D+K⁰ supersedes previous measurements, providing a tighter constraint.
- First for K*⁰: The result for B+ → D+K*⁰ is the first experimental measurement for this decay channel.
Limitations and Future Work
- Statistical Significance: The primary limitation is the lack of statistical significance in the observed signal, which is expected given the predicted rarity of these decays. This necessitates setting upper limits rather than reporting observed branching fractions.
- Systematic Uncertainties: The analysis acknowledges various sources of systematic uncertainty, including uncertainties in PDF parameterizations, detector efficiencies, and background estimations. These uncertainties are carefully evaluated and contribute to the overall error on the branching fractions and limits.
- Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests that future, higher-luminosity experiments could potentially improve the sensitivity to these rare decays, possibly leading to their observation. Further theoretical work is also encouraged to provide more precise predictions for these annihilation-dominated processes.
Summary updated