Search for microscopic evidence for molecular level negative thermal expansion in fullerenes

S. Brown, Jiannong Cao, J. L. Musfeldt, Nita Dragoe, Fanica Cimpoesu, Seiya Ito, H. Takagi, R. J. CrossPhysical 2006 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We report the high-resolution far infrared vibrational properties of C$_{60}$ and endohedral Kr@C$_{60}$ fullerene as a function of temperature. Anomalous softening of the F$_{1u}$(1) mode (526 cm$^{-1}$) is observed throughout the temperature range of investigation (300–10 K) suggesting that the fullerene cage may expand at low temperature in these molecular solids. To test this idea, we combine these results with temperature and pressure-dependent Raman, infrared, and Kr extended x-ray absorption fine structure data from the literature to provide a comprehensive view of local cage size effects. The results are consistent with a recent molecular dynamics study that predicts negative thermal expansion in carbon fullerenes.

Introduction

Negative Thermal Expansion (NTE)—the phenomenon where a material expands upon cooling—is typically observed as a bulk property of complex crystal lattices. However, recent molecular dynamics simulations have suggested that C$_{60}$ fullerenes might exhibit NTE at the individual molecular level. This microscopic expansion is often masked in macroscopic measurements by the standard contraction of the bulk crystal lattice. This study seeks to identify microscopic signatures of this predicted cage expansion using vibrational spectroscopy and structural analysis.

Experimental Methodology

The researchers employed high-resolution variable-temperature far-infrared (IR) spectroscopy to probe the vibrational modes of pristine C$_{60}$ and endohedral Kr@C$_{60}$ from 300 K down to 10 K. By focusing on specific radial vibrational modes, they aimed to decouple the behavior of the individual carbon cages from the surrounding lattice. Additionally, the study integrated pressure-dependent Raman and IR data from existing literature to calculate mode Grüneisen parameters, which relate frequency shifts to volume changes.

Infrared transmittance spectra of C60 and Kr@C60, with an inset showing Kr-edge EXAFS radial distribution functions.

Results and Discussion

Anomalous Vibrational Softening

A key finding of this work is the "softening" of the F$_{1u}$(1) radial vibrational mode. In most materials, cooling leads to bond stiffening and a corresponding increase in vibrational frequency (hardening). Here, the F$_{1u}$(1) mode frequency decreased by approximately 0.5 cm$^{-1}$ as the temperature was lowered from 300 K to 10 K. This softening is a strong indicator of bond relaxation and physical expansion of the carbon cage.

Temperature dependence of the F1u(1) peak position for C60 and Kr@C60, demonstrating anomalous softening as temperature decreases.

Grüneisen Parameters and Expansion Coefficients

To quantify this effect, the authors calculated mode Grüneisen parameters ($\gamma_i$). For the observed modes, these parameters were found to be negative (ranging from -0.10 to -0.19), confirming that the frequency shifts are consistent with volume expansion. The estimated vibrational thermal expansion coefficient ($\alpha_{vib}$) for the C$_{60}$ molecule is approximately $-10^{-5}$ K$^{-1}$, a magnitude comparable to established bulk NTE materials like ZrW$_2$O$_8$.

Structural Validation via EXAFS

The study also re-examined Kr-edge Extended X-ray Absorption Fine Structure (EXAFS) data for Kr@C$_{60}$. The analysis revealed that the Kr-C path distance increases from 3.537 Å at 300 K to 3.540 Å at 77 K. This provides direct, independent geometric evidence that the cage size increases at lower temperatures, even when containing a guest atom.

Conclusion

This investigation provides compelling microscopic evidence for molecular-level negative thermal expansion in C$_{60}$ and Kr@C$_{60}$. The persistence of this effect in endohedral fullerenes suggests that the expansion is an intrinsic property of the carbon cage. These findings validate theoretical predictions and offer a new framework for understanding the thermal properties of curved carbon nanostructures, with potential implications for the design of future molecular-scale devices.

Summary updated

Abstract

We report the high-resolution far infrared vibrational properties of ${\mathrm{C}}_{60}$ and endohedral $\mathrm{Kr}@{\mathrm{C}}_{60}$ fullerene as a function of temperature. Anomalous softening of the ${F}_{1u}(1)$ mode $(526\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}{\mathrm{cm}}^{\ensuremath{-}1})$ is observed throughout the temperature range of investigation $(300--10\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\mathrm{K})$ suggesting that the fullerene cage may expand at low temperature in these molecular solids. To test this idea, we combine these results with temperature and pressure-dependent Raman, infrared, and Kr extended x-ray absorption fine structure data from the literature to provide a comprehensive view of local cage size effects. The results are consistent with a recent molecular dynamics study [Kwon et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 15901 (2004)] that predicts negative thermal expansion in carbon fullerenes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{brown2006search,
  author = {S. Brown and Jiannong Cao and J. L. Musfeldt and Nita Dragoe and Fanica Cimpoesu and Seiya Ito and H. Takagi and R. J. Cross},
  title = {{Search for microscopic evidence for molecular level negative thermal expansion in fullerenes}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.73.125446},
}
Figure