Search for Majoron-emitting modes of $^{136}$Xe double beta decay with the complete EXO-200 dataset

S. Al Kharusi, G. Anton, I. Badhrees, Ps Barbeau, Diane M. Beck, Belov, Trilochan Bhatta, M. Breidenbach, T. Brunner, G. F. Cao, Wr Cen, C. Chambers, B. T. Cleveland, Minor J. Coon, A. Craycraft, T. Daniels, L. Darroch, Sj Daugherty, J. Davis, S. Delaquis, A. Der Mesrobian-Kabakian, R. DeVoe, J. Dilling, A. Dolgolenko, Mj Dolinski, J. Echevers, W. M. Fairbank, D. Fairbank, J. Farine, Soheyla Feyzbakhsh, P. Fierlinger, D. Fudenberg, P. Gautam, R. Gornea, G. Gratta, C. Hall, E. V. Hansen, J. Hoessl, P. Hufschmidt, M. Hughes, A. Iverson, A. Jamil, C. E. Jessiman, Mj Jewell, A. S. Johnson, A. Karelin, L. Kaufman, T. Koffas, R. Kr ucken, A. Kuchenkov, K.n.p. Kumar, Y. Lan, A. C. Larson, B.g Lenardo, D. S. Leonard, Gs Li, S Li, Z. Li, C. Licciardi, Yh Lin, R. MacLellan, Thomas McElroy, Thilo Michel, B. Mong, D.r. Moore, K. Murray, O. Njoya, O. Nusair, A. Odian, I. Ostrovskiy, Andréa Perna, A. Piepke, A. Pocar, F. Retière, A. C. Robinson, P. C. Rowson, D Rudde, J. Runge, Susann Schmidt, D. Sinclair, K. Skarpaas, Ak Soma, Stekhanov, M. Tarka, S. Thibado, J. Todd, T. Tolba, T.i. Totev, R. Tsang, B. Veenstra, Veeraraghavan, P. Vogel, J-l Vuilleumier, M. Wagenpfeil, J. Watkins, M. Weber, Lj Wen, U. Wichoski, Gerrit Wrede, S.w. Wu2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reports on a search for rare decay modes of Xenon-136 involving the emission of Majorons, hypothetical particles associated with lepton number violation. By analyzing a significantly expanded dataset from the EXO-200 experiment with improved detector sensitivity, the researchers have set the most stringent limits to date on the half-lives of these Majoron-emitting decays, providing crucial constraints on fundamental physics beyond the Standard Model.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Standard Model of particle physics predicts that lepton number is conserved. However, the observation of neutrino oscillations suggests that neutrinos have mass, which can be explained by extensions to the Standard Model. One such extension involves the possibility of neutrinoless double-beta (0νββ) decay, a process that would violate lepton number conservation and imply that neutrinos are Majorana fermions (their own antiparticles).

Beyond the simplest 0νββ decay (where two electrons are emitted), there are theoretical models that propose the emission of additional, weakly interacting particles, such as Majorons. These Majoron-emitting decay modes, characterized by different spectral shapes of the emitted electrons (indexed by 'n'), offer alternative pathways for lepton number violation. Detecting these decays would provide direct evidence for physics beyond the Standard Model and shed light on the nature of neutrinos and their interactions. The challenge lies in their extreme rarity, requiring highly sensitive detectors and large exposures to search for these faint signals amidst background noise.

Methods

The EXO-200 experiment utilizes a large, cylindrical time projection chamber (TPC) filled with liquid xenon (LXe) enriched in the isotope $^{136}$Xe. This isotope is a prime candidate for double-beta decay studies. The experiment has undergone upgrades, particularly in Phase-II, which lowered the energy threshold and improved energy resolution.

The analysis employs a maximum-likelihood (ML) fit to simultaneously analyze single-site (SS) and multi-site (MS) events. The key observables for the fit are the total energy of the event and its "standoff distance" (SD), which measures how close the event is to the detector walls. This approach leverages the distinct spatial distributions of signal events and background events.

The detector response and background interactions are modeled using a detailed Monte Carlo (MC) simulation based on GEANT4. Calibration sources are used to validate the MC simulation and determine the energy scale and resolution. Systematic errors are carefully accounted for by introducing nuisance parameters into the ML fit, constrained by dedicated studies and comparisons between data and MC. The sensitivity of the search is estimated using toy datasets generated from the background model.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this analysis is the complete EXO-200 dataset, comprising a total $^{136}$Xe exposure of 234.1 kg·yr. This dataset includes data from both Phase-I and Phase-II operations, with Phase-II data benefiting from detector upgrades that improved the energy threshold.

The analysis also utilizes data from radioactive calibration sources (e.g., $^{228}$Th, $^{226}$Ra, $^{60}$Co) to model detector response and background processes. These calibration datasets are crucial for validating the MC simulations and understanding systematic uncertainties.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Improved Sensitivity through Lower Threshold: The reduction in the energy threshold to 600 keV (compared to 1000 keV in previous analyses) significantly enhances the sensitivity to Majoron-emitting modes, particularly those with spectral shapes peaking at lower energies (like the n=7 mode). This highlights the importance of optimizing detector performance for specific decay signatures.
  • Comprehensive Dataset for Robust Limits: The utilization of the full EXO-200 dataset, representing a substantial increase in exposure, allows for the setting of the most stringent limits to date on Majoron-emitting decays. This underscores the power of accumulating large datasets in rare event searches.
  • Constraining Fundamental Physics: The derived limits on Majoron-neutrino coupling constants provide crucial constraints on theoretical models that extend the Standard Model, offering insights into the fundamental nature of neutrinos and the possibility of lepton number violation.
  • Synergy of Data and Simulation: The meticulous comparison and validation of experimental data with detailed MC simulations are fundamental to accurately modeling detector response and background, which is essential for extracting weak signals from rare processes.

Key Results

  • Stringent Limits on Majoron Decay Modes: The search yielded no statistically significant evidence for Majoron-emitting double-beta decay modes of $^{136}$Xe.
  • Record Half-Life Limits: The most stringent 90% confidence level (C.L.) lower limits on the half-lives of Majoron-emitting decays were established. For the spectral index n=1, the limit is $T_{1/2} > 4.3 \times 10^{24}$ yr, a factor of 3.6 improvement over the previous EXO-200 limit.
  • Constrained Coupling Constants: These half-life limits translate into constraints on the Majoron-neutrino coupling constant, $|g^M_{ee}| < (0.4-0.9) \times 10^{-5}$ for the n=1 mode. This is a significant improvement over previous experimental results.
  • Improved Sensitivity for Higher-Order Modes: The lower threshold and additional data led to an 8.4-fold improvement for the n=7 mode compared to the previous EXO-200 search.
  • Most Stringent Limits to Date: This search provides the most stringent limits to date on Majoron-emitting decays of $^{136}$Xe for spectral indices n=1, 2, 3, and 7.

Limitations and Future Work

  • No Discovery: The primary limitation is the lack of a positive detection of Majoron-emitting decays, meaning these rare processes remain unobserved.
  • Model Dependence: The interpretation of the results in terms of coupling constants is dependent on the specific theoretical models used for calculating nuclear matrix elements and phase space factors. The paper acknowledges the spread in limits due to ambiguities in these matrix elements.
  • Future Directions: The paper implicitly suggests that continued operation of EXO-200 or future, even more sensitive experiments (like nEXO), could further probe these decay modes and potentially reach even lower coupling constants or discover these rare processes. The success in improving sensitivity through detector upgrades and increased exposure points towards the continued importance of technological advancements in rare event searches.

Summary updated

Abstract

A search for Majoron-emitting modes of the neutrinoless double-beta decay of ¹³⁶Xe is performed with the full EXO-200 dataset. This dataset consists of a total ¹³⁶Xe exposure of 234.1 kg⋅yr, and includes data with detector upgrades that have improved the energy threshold relative to previous searches. A lower limit of T^(¹³⁶Xe)_(1/2) &gt; 4.3 x 10²⁴ yr at 90% C.L. on the half-life of the spectral index n = 1 Majoron decay was obtained, a factor of 3.6 more stringent than the previous limit from EXO-200, corresponding to a constraint on the Majoron-neutrino coupling constant of |⟨g^M_(ee)⟩|&lt;(0.4-0.9) x 10⁻⁵. The lower threshold and the additional data taken resulted in a factor 8.4 improvement for the n = 7 mode compared to the previous EXO search. This search provides the most stringent limits to-date on the Majoron-emitting decays of 136Xe with spectral indices n = 1,2,3, and 7.
BibTeX
@misc{kharusi2021search,
  author = {S. Al Kharusi and G. Anton and I. Badhrees and PS Barbeau and Diane M. Beck and Belov and Trilochan Bhatta and M. Breidenbach and T. Brunner and G. F. Cao and WR Cen and C. Chambers and B. T. Cleveland and Minor J. Coon and A. Craycraft and T. Daniels and L. Darroch and SJ Daugherty and J. Davis and S. Delaquis and A. Der Mesrobian-Kabakian and R. DeVoe and J. Dilling and A. Dolgolenko and MJ Dolinski and J. Echevers and W. M. Fairbank and D. Fairbank and J. Farine and Soheyla Feyzbakhsh and P. Fierlinger and D. Fudenberg and P. Gautam and R. Gornea and G. Gratta and C. Hall and E. V. Hansen and J. Hoessl and P. Hufschmidt and M. Hughes and A. Iverson and A. Jamil and C. E. Jessiman and MJ Jewell and A. S. Johnson and A. Karelin and L. Kaufman and T. Koffas and R. Kr ucken and A. Kuchenkov and K.N.P. Kumar and Y. Lan and A. C. Larson and B.G Lenardo and D. S. Leonard and GS Li and S Li and Z. Li and C. Licciardi and YH Lin and R. MacLellan and Thomas McElroy and Thilo Michel and B. Mong and D.R. Moore and K. Murray and O. Njoya and O. Nusair and A. Odian and I. Ostrovskiy and Andréa Perna and A. Piepke and A. Pocar and F. Retière and A. C. Robinson and P. C. Rowson and D Rudde and J. Runge and Susann Schmidt and D. Sinclair and K. Skarpaas and AK Soma and Stekhanov and M. Tarka and S. Thibado and J. Todd and T. Tolba and T.I. Totev and R. Tsang and B. Veenstra and Veeraraghavan and P. Vogel and J-L Vuilleumier and M. Wagenpfeil and J. Watkins and M. Weber and LJ Wen and U. Wichoski and Gerrit Wrede and S.W. Wu},
  title = {{Search for Majoron-emitting modes of $^\{136\}$Xe double beta decay with the complete EXO-200 dataset}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.104.112002},
}
Figure