Search for Low-energy Electron Antineutrinos in KamLAND Associated with Gravitational Wave Events

S. Abe, S. Asami, A. Gando, Y. Gando, T. Gima, Atsushi Goto, Takahiko Hachiya, K. Hata, S. Hayashida, K. Hosokawa, K. Ichimura, S. Ieki, H. Ikeda, K. Inoue, K. Ishidoshiro, Y. Kamei, N. Kawada, Y. Kishimoto, T. Kinoshita, M. Koga, N. Maemura, T. Mitsui, H. Miyake, K. Z. Nakamura, R. Nakamura, H. Ozaki, T. Sakai, H. Sambonsugi, I. Shimizu, J. Shirai, Kiyoshi Shiraishi, A. Suzuki, Y. Suzuki, A. Takeuchi, K. Tamae, K. Ueshima, Yoshiki Wada, H. Watanabe, Y. Yoshida, S. Obara, A. Kozlov, D. Chernyak, Y. Takemoto, S. Yoshida, S. Umehara, K. Fushimi, A. K. Ichikawa, M. Yoshida, B. E. Berger, B. K. Fujikawa, J. G. Learned, J. Maricic, S. N. Axani, L. A. Winslow, Z. Fu, J. L. Ouellet, Y. Efremenko, H. J. Karwowski, D. M. Markoff, W. Tornow, A. Li, J. A. Detwiler, S. Enomoto, M. P. Decowski, C. Grant, T. O’Donnell, S. Dell’OroThe Astrophysical Journal 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the first search for MeV-scale electron antineutrinos from gravitational wave (GW) events using the KamLAND detector. By analyzing data from LIGO/Virgo's second and third observing runs, the researchers found no significant antineutrino signals coincident with GW events, setting new upper limits on the antineutrino fluence from these cosmic cataclysms.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The detection of gravitational waves (GWs) has opened a new window into observing extreme astrophysical phenomena. While GWs provide information about the dynamics of events like neutron star mergers, they are often accompanied by other signals, such as electromagnetic radiation and neutrinos. Detecting these multi-messenger signals can provide a more complete picture of the underlying physics. Specifically, neutron star mergers are predicted to produce a significant flux of MeV-scale electron antineutrinos, originating from the hot, collapsing fireball and the cooling remnant. However, directly observing these low-energy neutrinos in coincidence with GW events has been a significant challenge due to their faintness and the difficulty in precisely timing their arrival relative to the GW signal. This paper addresses the problem of searching for these elusive MeV-scale electron antineutrinos from GW events using the highly sensitive KamLAND detector.

Methods

The KamLAND detector, a large liquid scintillator detector located 1 km underground, was used to search for electron antineutrino interactions. The primary signature for these antineutrinos is the inverse beta-decay (IBD) reaction: $\bar{\nu}_e + p \rightarrow e^+ + n$. This reaction produces a prompt signal from the positron and its annihilation gamma-rays, followed by a delayed signal from the neutron capture on a proton or carbon-12. A crucial aspect of the analysis is the "delayed coincidence" signature, where the delayed neutron capture signal must occur within a specific time window (0.5–1000 µs) after the prompt signal.

To associate these antineutrino events with GWs, the researchers defined a coincidence window of ±500 seconds around each reported GW event. This window was chosen to be large enough to account for potential neutrino emission scenarios and the time-of-flight delay of neutrinos traveling from distant GW sources. The analysis involved two distinct datasets corresponding to the LIGO-O2 and LIGO-O3 observing runs, with slightly different detector configurations and selection efficiencies. A likelihood-based signal selection was employed to distinguish true IBD events from accidental coincidences and other backgrounds.

Datasets

The primary datasets used in this analysis are:

  • Gravitational Wave (GW) Events: 60 GW events/candidates reported by the LIGO/Virgo collaboration during their second (LIGO-O2) and third (LIGO-O3) observing runs. These events are detailed in Tables 1 and 2 of the paper.
  • KamLAND Detector Data: Data collected by the KamLAND detector during the periods corresponding to the LIGO-O2 and LIGO-O3 observing runs. This data was filtered to identify potential IBD events.

This paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather utilizes existing GW event catalogs and KamLAND's operational data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The MeV Neutrino Window is Crucial for Neutron Star Mergers: The paper reinforces the theoretical prediction that MeV-scale neutrinos are a significant, and potentially dominant, emission channel from neutron star mergers, particularly from the hot fireball and cooling remnant. This highlights the importance of detectors sensitive to this energy range for multi-messenger astronomy.
  • KamLAND's Sensitivity to Low-Energy Neutrinos: The KamLAND detector, with its large volume and low background, is well-suited for detecting these faint MeV-scale antineutrino signals, pushing the boundaries of what's observable in coincidence with GWs.
  • Challenges in Coincidence Searches: The ±500s coincidence window, while generous, underscores the difficulty in precisely timing neutrino signals from distant, transient GW events. The time-of-flight differences for neutrinos of different energies and masses can be significant.
  • Constraining Astrophysical Models: Even in the absence of a signal, setting upper limits on neutrino fluence provides valuable constraints on theoretical models of neutrino emission from GW sources. These limits help rule out certain astrophysical scenarios or refine our understanding of the physics involved.

Key Results

  • No Coincident Signals: The KamLAND experiment found no statistically significant coincident electron antineutrino events within the ±500s timing window for any of the 60 GW events analyzed.
  • Upper Limits on Fluence: The study sets 90% confidence level (C.L.) upper limits on the electron antineutrino fluence. These limits range from $10^8$ to $10^{13}$ cm$^{-2}$ for neutrino energies between 1.8 and 111 MeV.
  • Comparison with Other Detectors: The paper presents these limits in comparison to those from other neutrino detectors (Borexino, Super-Kamiokande, Daya Bay), showing KamLAND's competitive performance, particularly at lower energies.
  • Energy Radiated Limits: For specific GW source classes (BNS and BBH), upper limits on the total energy radiated in neutrinos were derived, assuming Fermi-Dirac energy spectra. These limits are $7.92 \times 10^{58}$ erg for BNS and $8.22 \times 10^{60}$ erg for BBHs.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Detector Efficiency and Backgrounds: While KamLAND is highly sensitive, the analysis is limited by detector efficiencies and residual backgrounds. The paper notes that the selection efficiencies differ between the LIGO-O2 and LIGO-O3 datasets due to detector upgrades (specifically, the inner balloon cut in LIGO-O3).
  • Assumptions on Neutrino Spectra: The derived fluence and energy limits rely on assumptions about the neutrino energy spectra (e.g., monochromatic or Fermi-Dirac). Different emission mechanisms could lead to different spectral shapes, affecting the interpretation of the limits.
  • Limited Number of GW Events: The analysis is based on a finite number of GW events. Future observing runs with more frequent and potentially closer GW events will allow for improved sensitivity.
  • Future Work: The authors emphasize the potential for future improvements by combining data from more GW events, particularly from the ongoing LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA observing runs. They also highlight the importance of integrating with other multi-messenger observatories (GeV/TeV neutrino detectors, X-ray/gamma-ray telescopes) to further constrain neutrino emission mechanisms from astrophysical sources. The KamLAND detector continues to operate and monitor for transient astrophysical events, with an implemented online monitor for rapid correlation searches.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract We present the results of a search for MeV-scale electron antineutrino events in KamLAND coincident with the 60 gravitational wave events/candidates reported by the LIGO/Virgo collaboration during their second and third observing runs. We find no significant coincident signals within a ±500 s timing window from each gravitational wave and present 90% C.L. upper limits on the electron antineutrino fluence between 10 8 and 10 13 cm −2 for neutrino energies in the energy range of 1.8–111 MeV.
BibTeX
@article{abe2021search,
  author = {S. Abe and S. Asami and A. Gando and Y. Gando and T. Gima and Atsushi Goto and Takahiko Hachiya and K. Hata and S. Hayashida and K. Hosokawa and K. Ichimura and S. Ieki and H. Ikeda and K. Inoue and K. Ishidoshiro and Y. Kamei and N. Kawada and Y. Kishimoto and T. Kinoshita and M. Koga and N. Maemura and T. Mitsui and H. Miyake and K. Z. Nakamura and K. Nakamura and R. Nakamura and H. Ozaki and T. Sakai and H. Sambonsugi and I. Shimizu and J. Shirai and Kiyoshi Shiraishi and A. Suzuki and Y. Suzuki and A. Takeuchi and K. Tamae and K. Ueshima and Yoshiki Wada and H. Watanabe and Y. Yoshida and S. Obara and A. Kozlov and D. Chernyak and Y. Takemoto and S. Yoshida and S. Umehara and K. Fushimi and A. K. Ichikawa and K. Z. Nakamura and M. Yoshida and B. E. Berger and B. K. Fujikawa and J. G. Learned and J. Maricic and S. N. Axani and L. A. Winslow and Z. Fu and J. L. Ouellet and Y. Efremenko and H. J. Karwowski and D. M. Markoff and W. Tornow and A. Li and J. A. Detwiler and S. Enomoto and M. P. Decowski and C. Grant and T. O’Donnell and S. Dell’Oro},
  title = {{Search for Low-energy Electron Antineutrinos in KamLAND Associated with Gravitational Wave Events}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/abd5bc},
}
Figure