Search for K0SK0S in J/ψ and ψ(2S) decays

J.z. Bai, Y. Ban, J. G. Bian, X. Cai, J. F. Chang, H.f. Chen, H.s. Chen, Hua-Xing Chen, J. Chen, Mei-Yi Chen, Y.b. Chen, S.p. Chi, Y. P. Chu, X. Z. Cui, H. L. Dai, Y.s. Dai, Z. Y. Deng, L. Y. Dong, S. X. Du, Zhihong Du, J. Fang, S. S. Fang, C. D. Fu, H. Y. Fu, L. P. Fu, C. S. Gao, M. Gao, Ya Gao, Ming Gong, W. X. Gong, S. Gu, Y. N. Guo, Z. J. Guo, S. Han, F. A. Harris, J. He, K. L. He, M. He, X. He, Y. K. Heng, H. M. Hu, J. F. Hu, G. S. Huang, L. Huang, X. P. Huang, X. B. Ji, Qing Jia, C. H. Jiang, X. S. Jiang, D. P. Jin, S. Jin, Y. Jin, Y. F. Lai, F. Li, G. Li, Heng-Ne Li, J. Li, Q.j. Li, R.b. Li, Rui-Ping Li, Shan Li, W. Li, X.l. Li, X.q. Li, X.s. Li, Y. F. Liang, H. Liao, C.x. Liu, Fang Liu, H.m. Liu, J.b. Liu, J.p. Liu, R.g. Liu, Y. Liu, Zhi-Jie Liu, Z.x. Liu, G. R. Lu, F. X. Lu, J. G. Lu, C. L. Luo, X. L. Luo, F.c. Ma, Jian Ma, Long Ma, X. Y. Ma, Z. P. Mao, X. C. Meng, X. H. Mo, J. Nie, Z. D. Nie, S. L. Olsen, H. P. Peng, N. D. Qi, C. D. QianPhysics 2004 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reports on the search for two rare CP-violating decays, J/ψ → K⁰SK⁰S and ψ(2S) → K⁰SK⁰S, using a large dataset from the Beijing Spectrometer. While no signal was observed, the study sets new, stringent upper limits on the branching ratios for these decays, providing valuable constraints for theoretical models.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Standard Model of particle physics predicts that certain particle decays should either conserve or violate Charge-Parity (CP) symmetry in specific ways. Investigating decays that are expected to be CP-violating, or where CP violation is predicted to be very small, is crucial for testing the Standard Model and searching for new physics. The decays J/ψ → K⁰SK⁰S and ψ(2S) → K⁰SK⁰S are of particular interest because they are CP-violating processes. While CP violation has been well-established in other systems (like kaon and B meson decays), searching for it in these charmonium (charm quark-antiquark bound state) decays provides an independent test. Furthermore, these decays have been proposed as a way to test fundamental quantum mechanics principles, specifically the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) paradox, by examining the correlations between the two K⁰S mesons. Previous searches, like the one by the MARK-III experiment for J/ψ → K⁰SK⁰S, found no signal and set an upper limit. This paper aims to improve upon these limits with a significantly larger dataset and to perform the first search for the ψ(2S) → K⁰SK⁰S decay.

Methods

The researchers utilized data collected by the Beijing Spectrometer (BESII) detector at the Beijing Electron Positron Collider (BEPC). They analyzed approximately 58 million J/ψ events and 14 million ψ(2S) events.

The core of the analysis involved identifying events where a J/ψ or ψ(2S) meson decays into two K⁰S mesons. K⁰S mesons are neutral and decay into two charged pions (π⁺π⁻). The identification process relied on reconstructing the decay products of the K⁰S mesons. Key steps included:

  • Event Reconstruction: Identifying four charged tracks with a net charge of zero, consistent with the decay of two K⁰S mesons into two pairs of charged pions.
  • K⁰S Identification: For each pair of oppositely charged tracks, the invariant mass was calculated. This mass was expected to be close to the known mass of the K⁰S meson.
  • Kinematic Cuts: Various cuts were applied to distinguish signal events from background. These included requirements on the decay length of the K⁰S mesons, their invariant mass (within a certain resolution), and for ψ(2S) decays, a recoil mass cut to remove background from other decay modes like ψ(2S) → π⁺π⁻J/ψ.
  • Monte Carlo Simulation: A detailed Monte Carlo simulation was used to model the detector response, estimate signal efficiencies, and understand background processes. This simulation was crucial for determining selection criteria and calculating systematic uncertainties.
  • Background Estimation: Backgrounds were estimated using both Monte Carlo simulations and by examining data in control regions. For J/ψ decays, a significant background source was identified as J/ψ → K(892)⁰K⁰ + c.c., where the K(892)⁰ decays into K⁰Sπ⁰. For ψ(2S) decays, backgrounds included ψ(2S) → γXcJ, with XcJ decaying into K⁰SK⁰S, and ψ(2S) → K*(892)⁰K⁰ + c.c.

Datasets

  • Experimental Data:
    • 58 million J/ψ events.
  • 14 million ψ(2S) events. These datasets were collected by the Beijing Spectrometer (BESII) detector.

  • Monte Carlo Simulation:

    • 10,000 simulated events for each signal channel (J/ψ → K⁰SK⁰S and ψ(2S) → K⁰SK⁰S).
  • Additional Monte Carlo samples were used for background estimation and efficiency studies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Probing CP Violation in New Systems: The paper highlights the importance of searching for CP violation in charmonium decays as a complementary approach to studying kaon and B meson systems.
  • Testing Fundamental Quantum Mechanics: The K⁰SK⁰S system is a unique quantum entangled system, and its study in these decays offers a way to probe the validity of quantum mechanics against alternative theories like those based on EPR locality.
  • Data-Driven Trigger Efficiency: The trigger efficiency for these rare decays, which are not typically the primary trigger events, was measured directly from data rather than relying solely on simulation, improving the reliability of the results.
  • Careful Background Subtraction and Estimation: The analysis meticulously accounts for various background processes, including those from other charmonium decays and misidentified particles, which is critical for setting meaningful limits on rare decays.

Key Results

  • No Signal Observed: In both the J/ψ and ψ(2S) decay channels, no statistically significant signal for K⁰SK⁰S production was observed.
  • Upper Limits on Branching Ratios: The study sets the following upper limits at the 95% confidence level:
  • B(J/ψ → K⁰SK⁰S) < 1.0 × 10⁻⁶
    • B(ψ(2S) → K⁰SK⁰S) < 4.6 × 10⁻⁶
  • Improved Limits: The upper limit for J/ψ → K⁰SK⁰S is significantly more stringent than the previous limit from the MARK-III experiment.
  • First Limit for ψ(2S): This is the first reported search and resulting upper limit for the ψ(2S) → K⁰SK⁰S decay.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Statistical Limitations: Despite the large dataset, the observed number of events for these extremely rare decays is very small (one candidate event in each channel for J/ψ and ψ(2S) respectively, after selection). This limits the precision with which the branching ratios can be constrained.
  • Systematic Uncertainties: While efforts were made to quantify and minimize systematic errors (e.g., from tracking efficiency, detector resolutions, and event selection), they contribute to the overall uncertainty in the limits. The total systematic errors are quoted as 12.0% for J/ψ and 12.7% for ψ(2S).
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that future experiments with even larger datasets or improved detectors could further refine these limits or potentially observe these rare decays, offering deeper insights into CP violation and fundamental quantum mechanics. The current limits are still above the sensitivity required to definitively test certain aspects of the EPR paradox.

Summary updated

Abstract

The CP violating processes J/psi-->K_S K_S and psi(2S)-->K_S K_S are searched for using samples of 58 million J/psi and 14 million psi(2S) events collected with the Beijing Spectrometer at the Beijing Electron Positron Collider. No signal is observed, and upper limits on the decay branching ratios are determined to be BR(J/psi-->K_S K_S) < 1.0x10^{-6} and BR(psi(2S)-->K_S K_S) < 4.6x10^{-6} at the 95% confidence level.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bai2004search,
  author = {J.Z. Bai and Y. Ban and J. G. Bian and X. Cai and J. F. Chang and H.F. Chen and H.S. Chen and Hua-Xing Chen and J. Chen and J.C. Chen and Jun Chen and Mei-Yi Chen and Y.B. Chen and S.P. Chi and Y. P. Chu and X. Z. Cui and H. L. Dai and Y.S. Dai and Z. Y. Deng and L. Y. Dong and S. X. Du and Zhihong Du and J. Fang and S. S. Fang and C. D. Fu and H. Y. Fu and L. P. Fu and C. S. Gao and M. Gao and Ya Gao and Ming Gong and W. X. Gong and S. Gu and Y. N. Guo and Yi-Qing Guo and Z. J. Guo and S. Han and F. A. Harris and J. He and K. L. He and M. He and X. He and Y. K. Heng and H. M. Hu and J. F. Hu and G. S. Huang and L. Huang and X. P. Huang and X. B. Ji and Qing Jia and C. H. Jiang and X. S. Jiang and D. P. Jin and S. Jin and Y. Jin and Y. F. Lai and F. Li and G. Li and Heng-Ne Li and J. Li and J.C. Li and Q.J. Li and R.B. Li and Rui-Ping Li and Shan Li and W. Li and Weilan Li and X.L. Li and X.Q. Li and X.S. Li and Y. F. Liang and H. Liao and C.X. Liu and Fang Liu and F. Liu and H.M. Liu and J.B. Liu and J.P. Liu and R.G. Liu and Y. Liu and Zhi-Jie Liu and Z.X. Liu and G. R. Lu and F. X. Lu and J. G. Lu and C. L. Luo and X. L. Luo and F.C. Ma and Jian Ma and Long Ma and X. Y. Ma and Z. P. Mao and X. C. Meng and X. H. Mo and J. Nie and Z. D. Nie and S. L. Olsen and H. P. Peng and N. D. Qi and C. D. Qian},
  title = {{Search for K0SK0S in J/ψ and ψ(2S) decays}},
  booktitle = {Physics},
  year = {2004},
  doi = {10.1016/j.physletb.2004.03.047},
}
Figure