Search for flavor-changing non-standard neutrino interactions by MINOS

P. Adamson, G. Barr, M. Bishai, A. Blake, G. J. Bock, D. Bogert, S. Cao, D. Cherdack, S. Childress, J. A. B. Coelho, L. A. Corwin, D. Cronin-Hennessy, J. K. de Jong, A. V. Devan, N. E. Devenish, M. Diwan, C. O. Escobar, J. J. Evans, E. Falk, G. J. Feldman, M. V. Frohne, H. Gallagher, R. A. Gomes, T Hara, P. Gouffon, N. Graf, R. Gran, K. Grzelak, A. Habig, J. Hartnell, R. Hatcher, A. Himmel, A. Holin, J. Hylen, G. M. Irwin, Z. Isvan, C. James, D. Jensen, T. Kafka, S. M. S. Kasahara, G. Koizumi, M. Kordosky, A. Kreymer, K. Lang, J. Ling, P. J. Litchfield, P. Lucas, W. A. Mann, M. L. Marshak, M. Mathis, N. Mayer, M. M. Medeiros, R. Mehdiyev, J. R. Meier, M. D. Messier, W. H. Miller, S. Mishra, S. Moed Sher, C. D. Moore, L. Mualem, S. Mufson, J. Musser, D. Naples, J. K. Nelson, H. B. Newman, R. J. Nichol, J. Nowak, W. P. Oliver, M. Orchanian, R. B. Pahlka, J. Paley, R. B. Patterson, G. Pawloski, S. Phan-Budd, R. Plunkett, Xin Qiu, A. Radovic, B. Rebel, C. Rosenfeld, H. A. Rubin, M. C. Sánchez, J. Schneps, A. Schreckenberger, P. Schreiner, R. Sharma, A. Sousa, N. Tagg, R. L. Talaga, J. Thomas, M. Thomson, R. Toner, D. Torretta, G. Tzanakos, J. Urheim, P. Vahle, B. Viren, A. Weber, R. Webb, C. White, L. WhiteheadPhysical 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

The MINOS experiment has placed new, stringent limits on "non-standard neutrino interactions" (NSI) by analyzing both neutrino and antineutrino data. This is the first time such a search has simultaneously fit the distinct energy spectra of both, finding no evidence for these exotic interactions and constraining a key NSI parameter to a narrow range.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Neutrinos, famously, are not as simple as they appear. While we know they can change "flavor" (electron, muon, or tau) as they travel – a phenomenon explained by standard neutrino oscillations – there's a possibility of even more exotic interactions. These "non-standard neutrino interactions" (NSI) could occur when neutrinos interact with matter, potentially altering their flavor-changing behavior beyond what standard oscillations predict. Crucially, NSI can affect neutrinos and antineutrinos differently due to the sign of the matter potential they traverse. This paper tackles the challenge of searching for these NSI by leveraging the MINOS experiment's unique capability to distinguish between neutrino and antineutrino events and analyze their energy spectra separately.

Methods

The MINOS experiment utilizes the NuMI beamline, which produces a beam of muon neutrinos (or antineutrinos). The experiment consists of two detectors: a Near Detector (ND) located close to the beam source and a Far Detector (FD) situated 735 km away. By comparing the neutrino (or antineutrino) energy spectra measured in both detectors, MINOS can study oscillations.

This paper goes a step further by incorporating the possibility of NSI. The core idea is that NSI can modify the survival probability of muon neutrinos (and antineutrinos) as they travel through the Earth's matter. The authors focus on flavor-changing NSI, specifically those that affect transitions between muon and tau flavors, parameterized by a single real value, $\epsilon_{\mu\tau}$. They employ a combined fit to the neutrino and antineutrino energy spectra from the Far Detector. This simultaneous fit allows them to constrain the standard oscillation parameters ($\Delta m^2$ and $\sin^2(2\theta)$) and the NSI parameter ($\epsilon_{\mu\tau}$) together. They account for various systematic uncertainties, including energy scales and detector responses, using penalty terms in their likelihood analysis.

Datasets

The study uses data collected by the MINOS experiment from the NuMI beam. Specifically, it includes:

  • Neutrino mode data with an exposure of $7.09 \times 10^{20}$ protons on target (POT).
  • Antineutrino mode data with an exposure of $2.95 \times 10^{20}$ POT.

This is not a new benchmark dataset but rather real experimental data from a well-established long-baseline neutrino experiment.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Differential Sensitivity to NSI: The key insight is that NSI can affect neutrino and antineutrino survival probabilities in opposite ways. This difference, amplified by the long path through the Earth, provides a powerful handle to search for NSI.
  • Simultaneous Fit is Crucial: By fitting both neutrino and antineutrino spectra simultaneously, the experiment can disentangle the effects of standard oscillations from potential NSI, which would otherwise be degenerate in a single-flavor analysis.
  • NC NSI Focus: The paper specifically targets neutral-current (NC) NSI, as charged-current NSI would lead to the absorption of the final charged lepton by the Earth, making them harder to detect in this setup.

Key Results

The MINOS experiment found no evidence for flavor-changing non-standard neutrino interactions. The analysis yielded the following best-fit values for the standard oscillation parameters:

  • $\Delta m^2 = 2.39 \pm 0.14 \times 10^{-3} \text{ eV}^2$
  • $\sin^2(2\theta) = 1.00^{+0.00}_{-0.06}$

Crucially, the search for NSI constrained the parameter $\epsilon_{\mu\tau}$ to the range:

  • $-0.20 < \epsilon_{\mu\tau} < 0.07$ at the 90% confidence level.

This represents a significant improvement in the constraints on this particular NSI parameter.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on $\epsilon_{\mu\tau}$: The analysis specifically focuses on flavor-changing NSI between muon and tau neutrinos, setting flavor-conserving NSI amplitudes to zero due to MINOS's limited sensitivity to them.
  • Real $\epsilon_{\mu\tau}$: The study considers only the real part of $\epsilon_{\mu\tau}$, which is sensitive to differences in neutrino and antineutrino survival probabilities.
  • Future Directions: The paper implicitly suggests that future, more precise neutrino experiments, or analyses with larger datasets, could further refine these NSI constraints or potentially discover them if they exist. The methodology developed here is a valuable tool for such future investigations.

Summary updated

Abstract

We report new constraints on flavor-changing non-standard neutrino interactions from the MINOS experiment, in which neutrino versus antineutrino interactions can be distinguished on an event-by-event basis. We analyzed a combined set of beam neutrino and antineutrino data from the well-understood NuMI beam, and found no evidence for deviations from standard neutrino mixing. The observed energy spectra constrain the non-standard neutrino interactions parameter to the range $\ensuremath{-}0.20&lt;{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremath{\tau}}&lt;0.07(90%\mathrm{C}.\mathrm{L}.)$.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{adamson2013search,
  author = {P. Adamson and G. Barr and M. Bishai and A. Blake and G. J. Bock and D. Bogert and S. Cao and D. Cherdack and S. Childress and J. A. B. Coelho and L. A. Corwin and D. Cronin-Hennessy and J. K. de Jong and A. V. Devan and N. E. Devenish and M. Diwan and C. O. Escobar and J. J. Evans and E. Falk and G. J. Feldman and M. V. Frohne and H. Gallagher and R. A. Gomes and T Hara and P. Gouffon and N. Graf and R. Gran and K. Grzelak and A. Habig and J. Hartnell and R. Hatcher and A. Himmel and A. Holin and J. Hylen and G. M. Irwin and Z. Isvan and C. James and D. Jensen and T. Kafka and S. M. S. Kasahara and G. Koizumi and M. Kordosky and A. Kreymer and K. Lang and J. Ling and P. J. Litchfield and P. Lucas and W. A. Mann and M. L. Marshak and M. Mathis and N. Mayer and M. M. Medeiros and R. Mehdiyev and J. R. Meier and M. D. Messier and W. H. Miller and S. Mishra and S. Moed Sher and C. D. Moore and L. Mualem and S. Mufson and J. Musser and D. Naples and J. K. Nelson and H. B. Newman and R. J. Nichol and J. Nowak and W. P. Oliver and M. Orchanian and R. B. Pahlka and J. Paley and R. B. Patterson and G. Pawloski and S. Phan-Budd and R. Plunkett and Xin Qiu and A. Radovic and B. Rebel and C. Rosenfeld and H. A. Rubin and M. C. Sánchez and J. Schneps and A. Schreckenberger and P. Schreiner and R. Sharma and A. Sousa and N. Tagg and R. L. Talaga and J. Thomas and M. Thomson and R. Toner and D. Torretta and G. Tzanakos and J. Urheim and P. Vahle and B. Viren and A. Weber and R. Webb and C. White and L. Whitehead},
  title = {{Search for flavor-changing non-standard neutrino interactions by MINOS}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.88.072011},
}
Figure