Search for Double Beta Decay of $^{136}$Xe to the $0^+_1$ Excited State of $^{136}$Ba with PandaX-4T

PandaX Collaboration, Lingyin Luo, Zihao Bo, Wei Chen, Xun Chen, Yunhua Chen, Zhaokan Cheng, Xiangyi Cui, Yuqiang Fang, Deqing Fang, Zhixing Gao, Li‐Sheng Geng, Karl Giboni, Xunan Guo, Xuyuan Guo, Zichao Guo, Chencheng Han, Ke Han, Changda He, Jinrong He, Di Huang, Houqi Huang, J. Huang, Ruquan Hou, Yu Hou, Xiangdong Ji, Xiangpan Ji, Yonglin Ju, Chenxiang Li, T. Li, Jiafu Li, Mingchuan Li, Shuaijie Li, Zhiyuan Li, Qiang Li, Jianglai Liu, Congcong Lu, Xiaoying Lu, Yunyang Luo, Wenbo Ma, Yugang Ma, Yajun Mao, Meng Yue, Xuyang Ning, Binyu Pang, Ningchun Qi, Zhicheng Qian, Xiangxiang Ren, Dong Shan, Xiaofeng Shang, Xiyuan Shao, Guofang Shen, Manbin Shen, Wenliang Sun, Yi Tao, Anqing Wang, Guanbo Wang, H. M. Wang, Jiamin Wang, Lei Wang, Meng Wang, Qiuhong Wang, Shaobo Wang, Siguang Wang, Wei Wang, Xiuli Wang, Xu Wang, Zhou Wang, Yuehuan Wei, Weihao Wu, Yuan Wu, Mengjiao Xiao, Xiang Xiao, Kaizhi Xiong, Yifan Xu, Shunyu Yao, Binbin Yan, Xiyu Yan, Yong Yang, Peihua Ye, Chunxu Yu, Ying Yuan, Zhe Yuan, Youhui Yun, Xinning Zeng, Minzhen Zhang, Peng Zhang, Shibo Zhang, Shu Zhang, Tao Zhang, Wei Zhang, Yang Zhang, Yingxin Zhang, Yuanyuan Zhang, Liguo Zhao, Jifang Zhou, Jiaxu Zhou, Ning Zhou, Xiaopeng Zhou, Yubo ZhouarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We perform a search of double beta decay of $^{136}$Xe to the excited state, $0^+_1$, of $^{136}$Ba ($2 uetaeta$-$0_1^+$), using the dual-phase xenon detector of PandaX-4T with the first 94.9-day commissioning data. The multi-site events are reconstructed up to the MeV energy scale, which helps to improve the background model significantly. The background contribution from the stainless steel platform outside PandaX-4T cryostat is evaluated for the first time. No significant evidence for $2 uetaeta$-$0_1^+$ is observed, resulting in a lower limit on half-life of $7.5 \times 10^{22}$ yr at the 90% confidence level. This is the first experimental limit on such a rare decay in a natural xenon-based detector.

Introduction

Double beta decay ($2 uetaeta$) is an extremely rare nuclear process where two neutrons simultaneously transform into two protons, emitting two electrons and two antineutrinos. While this process is typically observed as a transition to the ground state of the daughter nucleus, transitions to excited states are also possible.

In the case of $^{136}$Xe, the decay to the $0^+_1$ excited state of $^{136}$Ba is of particular interest. This transition is followed by the emission of de-excitation gamma rays as the nucleus returns to its ground state. Measuring these transitions is crucial for constraining Nuclear Matrix Elements (NMEs), which are essential for interpreting searches for the hypothetical neutrinoless double beta decay ($0 uetaeta$).

Decay scheme of $^{136}$Xe to the ground and excited states of $^{136}$Ba.

Experimental Method and Analysis

The PandaX-4T experiment, located at the China Jinping Underground Laboratory, utilizes a dual-phase xenon Time Projection Chamber (TPC). Unlike many dedicated double beta decay experiments that use enriched xenon, PandaX-4T uses natural xenon, containing approximately 8.9% $^{136}$Xe.

Multi-Site Reconstruction

A key challenge in detecting the $2 uetaeta$-$0_1^+$ signal is its multi-site (MS) nature. While standard $2 uetaeta$ to the ground state produces two electrons that deposit energy in a single location (Single-Site or SS), the excited state decay involves de-excitation gammas that often scatter at multiple locations within the detector.

Extracted figure from page 5 of Search for Double Beta Decay of $^{136}$Xe to the $0^+_1$ Excited State of $^{136}$Ba with PandaX-4T

To capture this signal, the researchers developed a pipeline to reconstruct MS events up to the MeV energy scale. By analyzing the number of ionization (S2) peaks associated with a single scintillation (S1) trigger, the team could effectively discriminate between SS and MS events. This dual-spectrum fitting approach allows for superior background separation, as the signal is predicted to be 98.8% multi-site.

Background Modeling and Insights

Using the BambooMC Geant4-based framework, the team simulated the detector's response to various background sources. A significant finding during this study was the impact of the 6.8-tonne stainless steel platform (SSP) supporting the detector cryostat. High-energy gamma rays from this external structure were found to contribute significantly to the MS background between 1800 and 2400 keV. Accounting for this previously unmodeled background was essential for achieving a precise fit to the data.

Results

Analysis of 94.9 days of commissioning data showed no significant excess of events corresponding to the $2 uetaeta$-$0_1^+$ signal (p-value = 0.13). Consequently, a lower limit on the half-life of $^{136}$Xe decay to the $0^+_1$ state was set at:

$T_{1/2} > 7.5 \times 10^{22}$ years (90% C.L.)

This result represents the first experimental limit for this decay mode achieved using a natural xenon-based detector. Furthermore, the study successfully quantified the radioactivity of the external support platform ($319 \pm 24$ mBq/kg for $^{232}$Th), providing a more robust background model for future physics searches.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

While no signal was observed in this initial commissioning phase, the sensitivity of PandaX-4T will continue to grow with increased exposure. Recent upgrades, including an active veto system in the water shield, are expected to further suppress backgrounds from external structures like the stainless steel platform. These improvements, combined with the massive sensitive volume of the detector, position PandaX-4T to remain highly competitive in the search for rare nuclear transitions.

Summary updated

Abstract

We perform a search of double beta decay of $^{136}$Xe to the excited state, $0^+_1$, of $^{136}$Ba (2$νββ$-0$_1^+$), using the dual-phase xenon detector of PandaX-4T with the first 94.9-day commissioning data. The multi-site events are reconstructed up to the MeV energy scale, which helps to improve the background model significantly. The background contribution from the stainless steel platform outside PandaX-4T cryostat is evaluated for the first time. No significant evidence for 2$νββ$-$0_1^+$ is observed, resulting in a lower limit on half-life of $7.5 \times 10^{22}$ yr at the 90% confidence level. This is the first experimental limit on such a rare decay in a natural xenon-based detector.
BibTeX
@misc{collaboration2025search,
  author = {PandaX Collaboration and Lingyin Luo and Zihao Bo and Wei Chen and Xun Chen and Yunhua Chen and Zhaokan Cheng and Xiangyi Cui and Yuqiang Fang and Deqing Fang and Zhixing Gao and Li‐Sheng Geng and Karl Giboni and Xunan Guo and Xuyuan Guo and Zichao Guo and Chencheng Han and Ke Han and Changda He and Jinrong He and Di Huang and Houqi Huang and J. Huang and Ruquan Hou and Yu Hou and Xiangdong Ji and Xiangpan Ji and Yonglin Ju and Chenxiang Li and T. Li and Jiafu Li and Mingchuan Li and Shuaijie Li and Zhiyuan Li and Qiang Li and Jianglai Liu and Congcong Lu and Xiaoying Lu and Yunyang Luo and Wenbo Ma and Yugang Ma and Yajun Mao and Meng Yue and Xuyang Ning and Binyu Pang and Ningchun Qi and Zhicheng Qian and Xiangxiang Ren and Dong Shan and Xiaofeng Shang and Xiyuan Shao and Guofang Shen and Manbin Shen and Wenliang Sun and Yi Tao and Anqing Wang and Guanbo Wang and H. M. Wang and Jiamin Wang and Lei Wang and Meng Wang and Qiuhong Wang and Shaobo Wang and Siguang Wang and Wei Wang and Xiuli Wang and Xu Wang and Zhou Wang and Yuehuan Wei and Weihao Wu and Yuan Wu and Mengjiao Xiao and Xiang Xiao and Kaizhi Xiong and Yifan Xu and Shunyu Yao and Binbin Yan and Xiyu Yan and Yong Yang and Peihua Ye and Chunxu Yu and Ying Yuan and Zhe Yuan and Youhui Yun and Xinning Zeng and Minzhen Zhang and Peng Zhang and Shibo Zhang and Shu Zhang and Tao Zhang and Wei Zhang and Yang Zhang and Yingxin Zhang and Yuanyuan Zhang and Liguo Zhao and Jifang Zhou and Jiaxu Zhou and Ning Zhou and Xiaopeng Zhou and Yubo Zhou},
  title = {{Search for Double Beta Decay of $^\{136\}$Xe to the $0^+\_1$ Excited State of $^\{136\}$Ba with PandaX-4T}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2502.03017},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.03017},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure