Search for a Light Sterile Neutrino at Daya Bay

Fengpeng An, A. B. Balantekin, H. R. Band, W. Beriguete, M. Bishai, S. Blyth, Ilya Butorov, G. F. Cao, Jun Cao, Y. L. Chan, J. F. Chang, Ling-Hua Chang, Y. Chang, C. Chasman, H. Chen, Q. Y. Chen, S. M. Chen, Xia Chen, Y. X. Chen, Yaping Cheng, J. J. Cherwinka, M. C. Chu, J. P. Cummings, J. de Arcos, Z. Y. Deng, Yayun Ding, M. Diwan, Emily Draeger, X. F. Du, D. A. Dwyer, W. R. Edwards, S. Ely, Jinghua Fu, L. Q. Ge, R. Gill, M. Gonchar, G. H. Gong, M. Grassi, W. Gu, Mengyun Guan, X. H. Guo, R. Hackenburg, G. H. Han, S. Hans, M. He, K. M. Heeger, Y. K. Heng, P. Hinrichs, Y. K. Hor, Y. Hsiung, Beibei Hu, Liangming Hu, Ting Hu, W. Hu, E.-c. Huang, H. X. Huang, X. T. Huang, Patrick Huber, Ghulam Hussain, Z. Isvan, D. E. Jaffe, P. Jaffke, K. L. Jen, S. Jetter, Xihan Ji, H. J. Jiang, J. B. Jiao, R. A. Johnson, Kang Li, S. H. Kettell, M. Kramer, K. K. Kwan, M. W. Kwok, T. Kwok, Wanchang Lai, K. T. Lau, L. Lebanowski, J. Lee, R. T. Lei, R. Leitner, A.y.t. Leung, J. K. C. Leung, C. A. Lewis, D. J. Li, F. Li, G. S. Li, Q. J. Li, W. D. Li, X. N. Li, Yufeng Li, Z. B. Li, H. Liang, C. J. Lin, G. L. LinPhysical 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

The Daya Bay experiment has performed a new search for a hypothetical "sterile" neutrino by analyzing electron antineutrino disappearance. Using data from multiple detectors at different distances from nuclear reactors, they found no evidence for this new particle, setting the most stringent limits to date on its existence in a previously unexplored parameter space.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Standard Model of particle physics, our current best description of fundamental particles and forces, includes three types of "active" neutrinos (electron, muon, and tau). However, several experimental anomalies and theoretical motivations suggest the existence of additional, "sterile" neutrinos that do not interact via the weak force, only through gravity. These sterile neutrinos could explain phenomena like dark matter or discrepancies in cosmological measurements. A key way to detect them is by observing their oscillations into or out of the active neutrino flavors, which would manifest as changes in neutrino behavior. Previous experiments have searched for sterile neutrinos, particularly in the mass-squared difference range of |Δm²| > 0.1 eV², but the lower energy, smaller mass-squared difference region (|Δm²| < 0.1 eV²) remained largely unconstrained. This paper aims to fill that gap by leveraging the unique multi-baseline configuration of the Daya Bay experiment.

Methods

The Daya Bay experiment utilizes six antineutrino detectors (ADs) located at three different underground experimental halls (near halls EH1 and EH2, and far hall EH3) relative to six nuclear reactors. Electron antineutrinos (νe) produced in the reactors travel to the detectors, where they can be observed via the inverse beta decay (IBD) reaction (νe + p → e⁺ + n). The experiment's strength lies in its ability to compare the observed antineutrino spectra at different distances (baselines) from the reactors.

The core of the analysis involves searching for deviations from the expected behavior predicted by the standard three-neutrino oscillation model. Specifically, the presence of a light sterile neutrino would introduce an additional oscillation frequency, leading to a distortion in the energy spectrum of the detected antineutrinos. The researchers employed three independent analyses, all focusing on the relative measurements between the different experimental halls to minimize systematic uncertainties related to the absolute reactor antineutrino flux. These analyses involved:

  1. Simultaneous spectral and rate fitting: This method used a binned log-likelihood approach to fit data from all three halls simultaneously, incorporating nuisance parameters for detector response and backgrounds, and using covariance matrices for reactor flux uncertainties.
  2. Purely relative comparison: This approach focused on extrapolating the observed spectra from the near halls to the far hall and comparing it with the actual far hall data, making it robust against uncertainties in the absolute flux.
  3. Covariance matrix approach: Similar to the first method but using a covariance matrix derived from standard uncertainty propagation, avoiding extensive Monte Carlo simulations.

Exclusion limits were set using both the Feldman-Cousins and CLs statistical methods.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this analysis consists of 217 days of data collected by the Daya Bay Reactor Antineutrino Experiment, corresponding to over 300,000 inverse beta decay (IBD) events. This data was recorded during the six-detector data-taking period from December 2011 to July 2012. The data was collected across six 2.9 GW(th) nuclear reactors and six antineutrino detectors.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Multi-baseline advantage: The experiment's unique setup with near and far detectors at distinct baselines (512 m, 561 m, and 1579 m) is crucial for probing sterile neutrino oscillations in the low |Δm²| region. Different baselines are sensitive to different oscillation frequencies.
  • Spectral distortion as a signature: The key signature for a light sterile neutrino is an additional, distinct spectral distortion in the electron antineutrino energy spectrum, beyond the one predicted by the standard three-neutrino model.
  • Complementarity of analyses: Employing three independent analyses with different treatments of systematic uncertainties and fitting methods provides a strong cross-check and increases confidence in the results.
  • No evidence for sterile neutrino: Despite the high precision and unique experimental setup, no significant deviation from the three-neutrino oscillation model was observed, indicating the absence of a light sterile neutrino in the probed parameter space.

Key Results

The Daya Bay experiment found that the observed electron antineutrino disappearance is consistent with the standard three-neutrino oscillation model. Based on this, the experiment has set the most stringent limits to date on the mixing parameter sin²(2θ₁₄) for light sterile neutrinos in the mass-squared splitting region of 10⁻³ eV² ≲ |Δm⁴₁| ≲ 0.1 eV². The 95% confidence level exclusion contours are presented in Figure 3 and Figure 4 of the paper, significantly improving upon previous limits in this specific parameter range.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the current precision is dominated by statistics. With at least three more years of data collection, the sensitivity to sin²(2θ₁₄) is expected to improve by a factor of two for most |Δm⁴₁| values. Future work will likely involve incorporating more data to further refine these limits and potentially extend the search to other regions of the parameter space. The paper also mentions that a future publication will focus on the |Δm⁴₁| > 0.3 eV² region by comparing event rates with flux model predictions.

Summary updated

Abstract

A search for light sterile neutrino mixing was performed with the first 217 days of data from the Daya Bay Reactor Antineutrino Experiment. The experiment's unique configuration of multiple baselines from six 2.9 GW(th) nuclear reactors to six antineutrino detectors deployed in two near (effective baselines 512 m and 561 m) and one far (1579 m) underground experimental halls makes it possible to test for oscillations to a fourth (sterile) neutrino in the 10(-3) eV(2)<|Δm(41)(2) |< 0.3 eV(2) range. The relative spectral distortion due to the disappearance of electron antineutrinos was found to be consistent with that of the three-flavor oscillation model. The derived limits on sin(2) 2θ(14) cover the 10(-3) eV(2) ≲ |Δm(41)(2)| ≲ 0.1 eV(2) region, which was largely unexplored.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{an2014search,
  author = {Fengpeng An and A. B. Balantekin and H. R. Band and W. Beriguete and M. Bishai and S. Blyth and Ilya Butorov and G. F. Cao and Jun Cao and Y. L. Chan and J. F. Chang and Ling-Hua Chang and Y. Chang and C. Chasman and H. Chen and Q. Y. Chen and S. M. Chen and Xia Chen and Xia Chen and Y. X. Chen and Y. Chen and Yaping Cheng and J. J. Cherwinka and M. C. Chu and J. P. Cummings and J. de Arcos and Z. Y. Deng and Yayun Ding and M. Diwan and Emily Draeger and X. F. Du and D. A. Dwyer and W. R. Edwards and S. Ely and Jinghua Fu and L. Q. Ge and R. Gill and M. Gonchar and G. H. Gong and H. Gong and M. Grassi and W. Gu and Mengyun Guan and X. H. Guo and R. Hackenburg and G. H. Han and S. Hans and M. He and K. M. Heeger and Y. K. Heng and P. Hinrichs and Y. K. Hor and Y. Hsiung and Beibei Hu and Liangming Hu and L. J. Hu and Ting Hu and W. Hu and E.-C. Huang and H. X. Huang and X. T. Huang and Patrick Huber and Ghulam Hussain and Z. Isvan and D. E. Jaffe and P. Jaffke and K. L. Jen and S. Jetter and Xihan Ji and X. L. Ji and H. J. Jiang and J. B. Jiao and R. A. Johnson and Kang Li and S. H. Kettell and M. Kramer and K. K. Kwan and M. W. Kwok and T. Kwok and Wanchang Lai and K. T. Lau and L. Lebanowski and J. Lee and R. T. Lei and R. Leitner and A.Y.T. Leung and J. K. C. Leung and C. A. Lewis and D. J. Li and F. Li and G. S. Li and Q. J. Li and W. D. Li and X. N. Li and X. Q. Li and Yufeng Li and Z. B. Li and H. Liang and C. J. Lin and G. L. Lin},
  title = {{Search for a Light Sterile Neutrino at Daya Bay}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.113.141802},
}
Figure