Sea Level Rise and the Dynamics of the Marsh-Upland Boundary

Sergio Fagherazzi, Shimon C. Anisfeld, Linda K. Blum, Emily V. Long, Rusty A. Feagin, Arnold Fernandes, William S. Kearney, Kimberlyn WilliamsFrontiers in Environmental Science 2019 · DOI

Abstract

As sea levels rise, salt marshes transgress inland, invading low-lying forests, agricultural fields, and suburban areas. This transgression is a complex process regulated by infrequent storms that flood upland ecosystems, increasing soil salinity and replacing upland vegetation with halophyte marsh plants. This paper reviews the main processes and feedbacks regulating this transition, introducing a process-based framework centered on the "ecological ratchet"—the interaction between the gradual "press" of sea-level rise and the episodic "pulse" of storm disturbances.

The Ecological Ratchet Model

Traditional "bathtub models" often fail to predict marsh migration because they ignore biological and hydrological feedbacks. Instead, the migration of the marsh-upland boundary is best understood through the Ecological Ratchet Model. This framework distinguishes between a regeneration niche (where seedlings establish) and a persistence niche (where mature plants survive but cannot reproduce).

Conceptual framework of the patterns and causes of marsh expansion into a forest, illustrating the transition from regenerating forest to marsh.

In this model, gradual sea-level rise (the press) slowly increases soil salinity and thins the freshwater lens. However, it is often a storm (the pulse) that triggers the actual transition by killing mature trees or preventing seed germination. Once the upland vegetation is removed, the increased salinity ensures that only salt-tolerant marsh plants can occupy the space, preventing the forest from regenerating and creating a "one-way" inland movement.

Ghost Forest Mechanics and Storm Impacts

The phenomenon of "ghost forests"—stands of dead trees at the marsh edge—is a visible result of this ratchet. Storms deliver multiple stressors to the upland boundary, including wind damage, storm surges, and heavy rainfall. These events lead to immediate physical effects like foliage loss and uprooting, as well as longer-term physiological stressors like soil salinity changes.

Flowchart illustrating how associated peril types from storms (winds, rain) lead to specific damage, effects, and temporal impacts on vegetation.

These disturbances determine the size of the "persistence zone," where mature trees remain as "living ghosts"—surviving in increasingly saline conditions but unable to produce a new generation. Eventually, root damage and non-optimal growth conditions lead to tree mortality, completing the conversion to marshland.

The Slope Paradox and Land-Use Pathways

Research into Vertical Migration Rates (VMR) has revealed a "slope paradox." Counter-intuitively, steeper slopes can sometimes lead to higher vertical migration rates. This is likely because steeper terrain improves drainage, reducing prolonged waterlogging stress and shortening the distance marsh plants must travel to reach fresh groundwater.

Land use also dictates the speed of transgression:

  • Forests: Transition is slowed by the long-lived "persistence niche" of mature trees.
  • Farmland: Transition is rapid; once the freshwater lens thins, soil salinization leads to quick abandonment. In Virginia alone, approximately 192 hectares of farmland are converted to salt marsh annually.
  • Urban Lawns: Managed landscapes present unique barriers, such as mowing and turfgrass competition, which are not yet fully integrated into migration models.

Economic Implications and Conservation

The transition from upland to marsh is often a "zero-sum game" between private owners and public interests. Because private property typically has a higher "discount rate" (future value is weighted more heavily), owners have strong incentives to build sea walls to protect current assets. However, if a private upland and a public marsh have equal value today, a 3% difference in discount rates will make the upland worth twice as much as the marsh in just 25 years. This economic reality underscores the need for early conservation land-buys to ensure the long-term survival of coastal ecosystems.

Future Directions

While the ecological ratchet provides a strong conceptual foundation, significant data gaps remain. Future research must focus on high-resolution measurements of vegetation-hydrology feedbacks, the unique dynamics of marsh invasion into managed urban landscapes, and improved predictive modeling for extreme water levels caused by the interaction of sea-level rise and major storm events.

Summary updated

Abstract

During sea level rise, salt marshes transgress inland invading low-lying forests, agricultural fields, and suburban areas. This transgression is a complex process regulated by infrequent storms that flood upland ecosystems increasing soil salinity. As a result upland vegetation is replaced by halophyte marsh plants. Here we present a review of the main processes and feedbacks regulating the transition from upland ecosystems to salt marshes. The goal is to provide a process-based framework that enables the development of quantitative models for the dynamics of the marsh-upland boundary. Particular emphasis is given to the concept of ecological ratchet, combining the press disturbance of sea level rise with the pulse disturbance of storms.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fagherazzi2019sea,
  author = {Sergio Fagherazzi and Shimon C. Anisfeld and Linda K. Blum and Emily V. Long and Rusty A. Feagin and Arnold Fernandes and William S. Kearney and Kimberlyn Williams},
  title = {{Sea Level Rise and the Dynamics of the Marsh-Upland Boundary}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Environmental Science},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3389/fenvs.2019.00025},
}
Figure