Intimate partner violence (IPV) is a pervasive public health crisis, affecting nearly one in four women and one in ten men in the United States. Trauma patients are at a particularly high risk, yet clinical practices for identifying and assisting these victims vary significantly across healthcare institutions. This systematic review, conducted by a multidisciplinary team from the Eastern Association for the Surgery of Trauma (EAST), evaluates the effectiveness of screening and intervention protocols for IPV in acute care settings.
The Problem: Identifying the Gap in Care
Healthcare providers in emergency departments (EDs) and trauma centers are often the first point of contact for victims of violence. However, without standardized, evidence-based guidelines, many cases go undetected. The core challenge addressed by this paper is twofold: determining if formal screening tools actually increase identification rates and assessing whether subsequent intervention protocols lead to improved patient outcomes, such as reduced future injury or mortality.
Methodology
The authors employed the GRADE (Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluations) methodology to synthesize existing literature. They focused on two primary "PICO" (Population, Intervention, Comparator, Outcome) questions:
- Screening: Does a formal IPV screening tool increase victim identification compared to no formal screening?
- Intervention: Does a formal IPV intervention protocol reduce mortality or adverse outcomes compared to no formal intervention?
Following an exhaustive search of over 12,000 records, the team identified only seven studies that met their strict inclusion criteria. The selection process is detailed in the PRISMA flow diagram below:
Key Results and Data Synthesis
The review synthesized data from seven primary studies, consisting mostly of prospective cohorts and one case-control study. These studies involved thousands of ED and trauma patients across the US and Canada.
Screening Effectiveness
The most consistent finding was that implementing any formal screening protocol—whether via nurse-led interviews, physician questioning, or computer-based health screens—dramatically outperformed "usual care" or informal triage. Identification rates jumped from a baseline of 0.3%–5.6% under standard care to 1%–33.5% with formal protocols. For example, one study (McLeer et al.) reported an increase from 5.6% to 30% identification simply by instituting a nursing IPV screening protocol.
The "Intervention Gap"
While screening proved highly effective, the review uncovered a startling lack of evidence regarding interventions. Zero studies met the inclusion criteria for PICO 2, meaning there is currently no high-quality data proving that interventions like social work referrals or safety planning successfully "break the cycle" of violence in the trauma population.
Discussion and Insights
- Direct Questioning: Face-to-face questioning by clinicians appeared to capture the highest number of victims. However, computer-based screens offer a private alternative that some patients may prefer for initial disclosure.
- Normalization: Successful protocols often utilized "normalizing statements" (e.g., "Many people who come to the ED with similar injuries are victims of violence at home. Could this be happening to you?") to reduce stigma.
- Evidence Quality: Despite the clear trend in identification, the overall quality of evidence was rated as Low due to the observational nature of the studies and relatively small sample sizes.
Conclusion and Future Directions
Based on the high potential benefit and low risk of harm, the authors conditionally recommend universal IPV screening for all adult trauma and ED patients. However, they highlight critical gaps that must be addressed in future research:
- Diversity: Most studies focused almost exclusively on female patients, leaving a data gap regarding male and LGBTQ+ victims.
- Long-term Outcomes: There is an urgent need for research that tracks whether identification in the ED leads to a reduction in future hospitalizations or homicides.
In summary, while the medical community has proven it can identify victims through formal screening, the next challenge is proving which interventions effectively save lives.
Summary updated