Science Incubators: Synthesis Centers and Their Role in the Research Ecosystem

Allen G. Rodrigo, Susan C. Alberts, Karen Cranston, Joel G. Kingsolver, Hilmar Lapp, Craig R. McClain, Robin Smith, Todd Vision, Jory Weintraub, Brian M. WiegmannPLoS 2013 · DOI

Abstract

How should funding agencies enable researchers to explore high-risk but potentially high-reward science? One model that appears to work is the NSF-funded synthesis center, an incubator for community-led, innovative science. By repurposing existing data to tackle massive, cross-disciplinary questions, these centers provide a high-leverage, cost-effective model for driving innovation across the research ecosystem.

Introduction

Modern scientific inquiry is frequently hindered by institutional and disciplinary silos. While agencies like the National Science Foundation (NSF) are highly effective at funding individual investigators to collect primary data, a persistent gap remains in "synthetic" research—the integration of disparate datasets to address broad, "big picture" questions.

This paper identifies two primary obstacles to large-scale synthesis. First is the Collaboration Barrier: cross-disciplinary work requires navigating conflicting vocabularies and methodologies, a process that is often ineffective through remote communication alone. Second is the Funding Paradox: current policies often limit center funding to a 10-year lifespan to encourage "innovation." However, the authors argue that shuttering successful centers destroys the institutional infrastructure and "know-how" that makes high-risk innovation possible.

The Synthesis Center Model

Drawing on the operations of the National Evolutionary Synthesis Center (NESCent), the authors define a four-pillar approach to the synthesis center model:

  1. Face-to-Face Interaction: Prioritizing physical meetings is essential for breaking down conceptual barriers between disciplines, such as bridging the gap between marine biology and computational phylogenetics.
  2. Community-Driven Agendas: Rather than following top-down mandates, the model allows the scientific community to identify the most pressing "big questions."
  3. Flexibility: Centers must respond rapidly to shifts in the field and the evolving technical skills required to address new challenges.
  4. Friction Reduction: By providing robust informatics and administrative support, centers allow scientists to focus entirely on research, significantly lowering the "risk of failure" for ambitious projects.

The "Business Incubator" Analogy

A key insight of this perspective is the framing of synthesis centers as scientific "start-up incubators." Just as business incubators provide legal and financial services to help risky ideas reach viability, synthesis centers provide the informatics and logistical framework necessary for high-risk research.

By embedding informatics specialists directly within research communities, centers ensure that software tools are scientifically relevant and maintained over the long term. This environment allows for "quick and low-cost failure"; because the center absorbs the overhead, researchers can vet high-risk ideas without the career-ending consequences often associated with a failed five-year individual grant.

Quantifying Impact

The success of the NESCent model is supported by quantitative evidence from its first eight years of operation:

  • Scientific Productivity: Participants produced over 500 publications, which have garnered more than 8,000 citations.
  • Academic Influence: The Center achieved a notable H-index of 43.
  • Financial Return on Investment (ROI): Researchers involved in NESCent activities subsequently secured over $24 million in external grants. This represents a 1-to-1 return on the core funding provided by the NSF, demonstrating that synthesis centers act as a catalyst for further funded research.

Discussion and Future Directions

The primary limitation of the current model is the arbitrary 10-year funding cap. The authors argue that this "planned obsolescence" threatens the very communities of practice that centers have spent a decade building.

To sustain scientific progress, the authors advocate for a policy shift. Successful synthesis centers should be eligible for indefinite renewal, subject to rigorous periodic review, similar to the "institute" model. The value of these centers lies not just in their immediate publication output, but in their role as essential infrastructure for the next generation of cross-disciplinary science.

Summary updated

Abstract

How should funding agencies enable researchers to explore high-risk but potentially high-reward science? One model that appears to work is the NSF-funded synthesis center, an incubator for community-led, innovative science.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rodrigo2013science,
  author = {Allen G. Rodrigo and Susan C. Alberts and Karen Cranston and Joel G. Kingsolver and Hilmar Lapp and Craig R. McClain and Robin Smith and Todd Vision and Jory Weintraub and Brian M. Wiegmann},
  title = {{Science Incubators: Synthesis Centers and Their Role in the Research Ecosystem}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pbio.1001468},
}
Figure