Science-Gifted Class Students' Change in Creative Personality and Creative Thinking Ability and Comparison to General Class Students in the First Grade of High School

Hyung‐Do Kim, Dong-Jin Kim, Kwang-Seo Park, Eun-Suk Kim, Dong-Joo Jin, Kuk-Tae ParkJournal of the Korean Chemical Society 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals a surprising disconnect in gifted education: high school students selected for "science-gifted" tracks possess more creative personalities than their peers, but they don't actually score higher in creative thinking ability. Furthermore, a three-month specialized science program failed to significantly improve either their creative outlook or their cognitive problem-solving skills, suggesting a need for better selection and teaching methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the race for national competitiveness, many countries—including South Korea—have established specialized "science-gifted" programs. However, there is a persistent debate over whether these programs are identifying the right students and if the curriculum actually fosters "scientific creativity."

Historically, giftedness was often equated with high IQ. Modern theories argue that creativity is just as vital. The authors of this paper investigated two key questions:

  1. Are we actually selecting students with high scientific creativity for these gifted classes?
  2. Do these specialized classes actually improve a student's creative personality and thinking ability?

Methods

The researchers conducted a pre-test/post-test study comparing two groups of first-year high school students (72 total students).

  • The Intervention: The "science-gifted" group participated in a 3-month program involving advanced chemistry and biology experiments. The curriculum focused on hands-on laboratory work rather than standard textbook learning.
The specialized science curriculum included advanced topics like aspirin synthesis and atomic structure analysis.
  • The Assessment Tools:
    • Khatena-Torrance Creative Perception Inventory (KTCPI): Measures the "affective" side of creativity—personality traits like self-confidence, inquisitiveness, and imagination.
  • Torrance Test of Creative Thinking (TTCT) - Verbal Form A: Measures the "cognitive" side of creativity—the ability to generate many ideas (fluency), varied ideas (flexibility), and unique ideas (originality).

Key Insights and Ideas

Personality ≠ Ability

One of the most striking findings was the near-zero correlation between creative personality traits and creative thinking scores. A student can feel like a creative, adventurous risk-taker (personality) without necessarily being better at divergent thinking or problem-solving (ability).

Statistical analysis shows very low correlation coefficients between creative personality factors and creative thinking scores, suggesting they are independent variables.

Selection Bias

The gifted selection process successfully identified students with "creative personalities" (who scored significantly higher than the general group). However, it failed to distinguish them in terms of "thinking ability." This suggests that the entrance exams—which focused on subject-matter knowledge—might be filtering for personality and academic grit rather than raw creative cognition.

The "Stagnation" of Creativity

Perhaps most concerningly, the 3-month gifted program did not improve creativity scores. In fact, some scores slightly decreased. This suggests that simply doing "harder science" isn't the same as "teaching creativity."

Key Results

  • Creative Personality: The gifted group scored significantly higher (30.97) than the general group (27.22) at the start ($p < 0.05$). Specifically, they showed higher scores in "Acceptance of Authority" (meaning they were more likely to challenge it) and "Disciplined Imagination."
  • Creative Thinking Ability: There was no statistically significant difference between the gifted group (185.53) and the general group (167.50) in total thinking scores ($p = 0.131$).
  • Program Impact: After three months of specialized instruction, the gifted group’s creative personality score actually dropped slightly (from 30.97 to 28.06), and their thinking ability scores showed no significant improvement.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several hurdles:

  • Duration: Three months (six sessions) may be too short to fundamentally alter a student's creative cognitive architecture.
  • Curriculum Design: The gifted classes may have focused too much on "knowledge delivery" and "standard experiments" rather than open-ended, creative problem-solving.
  • Selection Criteria: The study suggests that the current selection process needs to be revamped to include specific metrics for creative thinking, rather than relying on subject-matter tests that favor students who have simply studied more advanced material in advance.

The researchers conclude that for science-gifted education to be effective, we must develop teaching-learning models specifically designed to stimulate the "aha!" moment, rather than just increasing the "volume" of scientific facts.

Summary updated

Abstract

이 연구의 목적은 고등학교 1학년 과학영재 학급 학생과 일반 학급 학생의 창의적 성격과 창의 적 인지력을 비교함으로써 과학 창의성이 있는 학생이 과학영재로 선발되었는지와 과학영재 학급 수 업을 통해 창의성이 향상되었는지를 알아보는 것이다. 연구를 위하여 과학영재 학급 학생과 일반 학급 학생에 대해 Khatena-Torrance 창의적 성격검사와 Torrance 창의성 검사 중 언어검사 A형을 영재 수업 전․후에 실시하였다. 연구결과, 과학영재 학급 학생이 일반 학급 학생에 비하여 창의적인 성격을 가지 고 있는 것으로 나타났으나, 창의적 인지력 면에서는 유의미한 차이를 보이지 않았다. 과학영재 학급 학생과 일반 학급 학생의 창의적 성격의 하위 요인과 창의적 인지력의 하위 요인 사이의 상관관계가 매 우 낮아, 창의적 성격과 창의적 인지력이 서로 독립적인 것으로 나타났다. 그리고 과학영재 수업 실시 후에 과학영재 학급 학생들의 창의적 성격과 창의적 인지력은 향상되지 않았다. 따라서 과학 창의성이 있는 학생을 과학영재 학생으로 선발하는 방법과 과학영재 학생의 창의성을 향상시킬 수 있는 교수-학 습 방법에 대한 연구와 개발이 필요하다. The purpose of this study was to find out whether scientifically creative students were selected as science-gifted class students and whether their creativity improved after class for the science-gifted students by comparing the science gifted class students to general class students in the first grade of high school. This was achieved by comparing science-gifted class students with general ones on creative personality and creative thinking ability. For this study, science-gifted class students and general class students were surveyed using Khatena-Torrance creative perception inventory and Torrance test of creative thinking with words of form A, before and after class for the science-gifted group. The results showed that science-gifted class students scored significantly higher than general class students on the creative personality. However, there was no significant difference between the two groups in their creative thinking ability. Also, in this study, the sub-factors of creative personality and those of creative thinking ability showed very low levels of correlation, which implies that the two variables are highly independent. In addition, science-gifted class students did not show significant improvement in their scores on the creative personality and the creative thinking ability after class. Therefore, further research and development on the selection of science-gifted students and teaching-learning methods which can improve the creativity of these students are needed.
BibTeX
@article{kim2009science,
  author = {Hyung‐Do Kim and Dong-Jin Kim and Kwang-Seo Park and Eun-Suk Kim and Dong-Joo Jin and Kuk-Tae Park},
  title = {{Science-Gifted Class Students' Change in Creative Personality and Creative Thinking Ability and Comparison to General Class Students in the First Grade of High School}},
  journal = {Journal of the Korean Chemical Society},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.5012/jkcs.2009.53.2.189},
}
Figure