Science communication in the face of skepticism, populism, and ignorance: what ‘Don’t Look Up’ tells us about science denial — and what it doesn’t

Niels G. MedeJournal of Science Communication 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses the film "Don't Look Up" as a lens to examine how science denial and science communication are portrayed in popular media. While the film offers a vivid, albeit exaggerated, depiction of anti-science sentiments, it overlooks crucial nuances in public perception, media influence, and effective communication strategies, potentially leading to a pessimistic and outdated view of these complex issues.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the gap between the complex reality of science denial and science communication and their often simplified or sensationalized portrayal in popular culture, using the film "Don't Look Up" as a case study. The film, while lauded for its depiction of scientists' struggles against skepticism and political interference, is critiqued for presenting a narrow view of public engagement with science. Specifically, it examines how the film's narrative might reinforce outdated "hypodermic needle" media effects models, oversimplify the public as a monolithic and passive entity, and present science denial as an inevitable and insurmountable problem. This misrepresentation, the authors argue, can hinder productive discussions about how to effectively communicate science in an era of skepticism and populism.

Methods

This paper is a commentary and analysis, not an empirical research study. The authors employ a "science communication lens" to scrutinize the film "Don't Look Up." This involves:

  • Analyzing the film's narrative: Identifying how the film depicts science denial, the societal context, and the media landscape.
  • Comparing film portrayals to scholarly literature: Contrasting the film's representations with findings from sociology, psychology, and science communication research on topics like public perception, media effects, populism, and conspiracy theories.
  • Identifying strengths and weaknesses: Acknowledging where the film accurately reflects current challenges while highlighting areas where it simplifies, exaggerates, or omits important complexities.
  • Inspiring debate: Using the film as a springboard for further discussion on the accurate portrayal of science denial and effective communication strategies.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Don't Look Up" as a mirror, but a distorted one: The film effectively captures the frustration and alienation many scientists feel when their expertise is dismissed, but it often exaggerates these sentiments and the societal conditions that foster them.
  • The "Monolithic Passive Public": The film tends to portray the general public as easily manipulated and lacking agency, a view that contradicts research showing publics can be resilient, actively scrutinize information, and engage in civic action.
  • US-centric view of denial: The film's depiction of science denial is heavily influenced by the US context, potentially overlooking how these phenomena manifest differently in other countries, especially in the face of crises like pandemics.
  • Fatalistic portrayal of science denial: The film suggests that efforts to combat science denial are ultimately futile, a perspective that neglects research on effective interventions like inoculation and debunking.
  • Pathologizing media: While media certainly plays a role in spreading misinformation, the film's overwhelmingly negative portrayal of social media, talk shows, and the entertainment industry overlooks their potential for positive science communication and engagement.
  • Limited view of science communication: The film primarily depicts science communication as a top-down, information-dumping process, neglecting the importance of participatory, dialogue-based approaches and the role of diverse expertise (including social sciences).

Key Results

The paper does not present quantitative results. Its key "results" are analytical insights derived from comparing the film's narrative to existing scholarship:

  • Strengths: The film vividly illustrates aspects of science denial, corporate counter-research, populist anti-elitism, and the role of media in public controversies. It resonates with the experiences of many scientists facing skepticism.
  • Weaknesses: The film oversimplifies public agency, presents a US-centric view of denial, suggests an inevitable persistence of denial, and pathologizes media without acknowledging its positive roles. It also underemphasizes the importance of social science expertise and participatory communication strategies.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • The paper acknowledges that the film's objective may not have been to provide a comprehensive or entirely accurate portrayal of science denial.
  • The commentary focuses on the film's limitations in representing science communication and denial, rather than offering a definitive solution.

Future Work:

  • The authors hope their commentary will inspire further debate and reflection on how popular media portrays science denial and anti-science phenomena.
  • They suggest the analysis of films like "Don't Look Up" is important for understanding public perceptions of scientists and for informing science communication research and practice.
  • The paper aims to inspire further empirical research on science communication within public controversies and on popular media representations of science.

Summary updated

Abstract

‘Don’t Look Up’ tells the story of a team of astrophysicists whose efforts to warn politicians, media makers, and the public about an apocalyptic comet impact on planet Earth are undermined by fundamental skepticism toward their expertise. On the one hand, the film offers a rich portrayal of contemporary anti-science sentiments, their societal conditions, and the media and communication ecology surrounding them. But on the other hand, ‘Don’t Look Up’ ignores and exaggerates several facets of those sentiments and the communicative settings in which they spread. This commentary analyzes this contrast through a science communication lens: it scrutinizes the (mis)representation of science denial and science communication in ‘Don’t Look Up’ — and aims to inspire further debate about portrayals of anti-science phenomena and potential remedies within popular media.
BibTeX
@article{mede2022science,
  author = {Niels G. Mede},
  title = {{Science communication in the face of skepticism, populism, and ignorance: what ‘Don’t Look Up’ tells us about science denial — and what it doesn’t}},
  journal = {Journal of Science Communication},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.22323/2.21050305},
}
Figure