Schizophrenia Following Early Adolescence Prodrome: A Neurodevelopmental Subtype With Autism-like Sensorimotor and Social Cognition Deficits

Anton Iftimovici, Gilles Martínez, Julie Victor, Narjès Bendjemaa, Célia Jantac, Charlotte Danset-Alexandre, Isabelle Amado, Laura Pina‐Camacho, Boris Chaumette, Mar Fatjó‐Vilas, Lourdes Fañanás, Édouard Duchesnay, Marie‐Odile KrebsSchizophrenia 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study proposes a new way to subtype schizophrenia by focusing on the age of prodrome onset, suggesting that early-adolescence prodromes (SCZ-eaP) represent a neurodevelopmental subtype with autism-like social and sensorimotor deficits. This distinction is crucial for understanding the underlying neurobiology and potentially improving prognosis and treatment strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Schizophrenia (SCZ) is a complex disorder with a wide range of symptom presentations and trajectories. While the age of psychosis onset is a common diagnostic criterion, research suggests that prodromal symptoms, which can begin years before full psychosis, are critical for understanding the illness's developmental trajectory. Specifically, there's a growing recognition of an overlap between SCZ and Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD), particularly in individuals with early onset of psychiatric symptoms. However, how the timing of these early prodromal symptoms influences specific cognitive and motor deficits, and how these relate to neurodevelopmental markers, remains unclear. This paper aims to address this gap by investigating whether SCZ with early adolescent prodromes (SCZ-eaP) exhibits a distinct profile of social cognition and sensorimotor deficits, more akin to ASD, compared to SCZ with later adolescent prodromes (SCZ-laP).

Methods

The researchers employed a transdiagnostic approach, comparing four groups: healthy controls (CTRL), individuals with ASD, SCZ-eaP (prodrome onset <15 years), and SCZ-laP (prodrome onset >15 years). Key assessments included:

  • Movie Assessment of Social Cognition (MASC): A 15-minute film used to evaluate social cognition abilities, specifically the understanding of characters' mental states (epistemic, emotional, volitional).
  • Neurological Soft Signs (NSS): A battery of 23 items assessing subtle motor and sensory integration abnormalities, considered markers of neurodevelopmental burden.
  • Structural MRI: Used to extract local gyrification indices (LGI) from 68 brain regions, serving as a marker of early brain development.

Statistical analyses involved ANCOVA to compare groups while controlling for medication and education, Pearson correlations, causal mediation analysis to explore the role of NSS in social cognition deficits, and linear regressions to link LGI with NSS.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 119 young adult participants (18-30 years old) prospectively recruited for the "From Autism to Schizophrenia" (AUSZ) study. The groups comprised:

  • 30 subjects with ASD (high-functioning autism or Asperger syndrome)
  • 25 subjects with SCZ-eaP
  • 34 subjects with SCZ-laP
  • 30 healthy controls (CTRL)

No new datasets were introduced; the study relied on existing recruitment and assessment protocols.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Prodrome Age as a Subtyping Marker: The age at which prodromal symptoms begin is a more informative marker for differentiating SCZ subtypes than the age of psychosis onset, particularly in relation to autism-like features.
  • Autism-SCZ Continuum: The findings strongly support the idea of a neurodevelopmental continuum between ASD and SCZ, with SCZ-eaP occupying an intermediate position characterized by shared deficits.
  • Sensorimotor Deficits as a Bridge: Neurological soft signs (NSS) act as a crucial mediator, linking early neurodevelopmental disruptions to social cognition impairments across the ASD-SCZ spectrum.
  • Beyond Symptom Scales: Social cognition deficits, as measured by the MASC, capture a dimension of SCZ that is more specific to autism than traditional symptom scales like the PANSS.
  • Gyrification as an Early Marker: Specific brain regions (right fusiform gyrus, right frontal pole gyrus, and left postcentral gyrus) showing altered gyrification are associated with sensorimotor impairments, suggesting these are rooted in early neurodevelopmental processes.

Key Results

  • Social Cognition and NSS: Subjects with ASD and SCZ-eaP showed similar deficits in social cognition and NSS, both differing significantly from SCZ-laP.
  • Age of Prodrome Correlation: Earlier age of prodrome onset was negatively correlated with NSS and positively correlated with social cognition performance.
  • Mediation Analysis: NSS significantly mediated the relationship between diagnostic group and social cognition deficits, indicating that sensorimotor impairments contribute to social cognitive difficulties.
  • Gyrification Associations: Three local gyrification indices (right fusiform gyrus, right frontal pole gyrus, and left postcentral gyrus) significantly explained variations in NSS, suggesting a link to early brain development.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample Size: While efforts were made to match groups, the sample sizes, particularly for SCZ-eaP, were relatively small.
  • Cross-Sectional Design: The study's cross-sectional nature prevents the dynamic study of developmental relationships between social cognition and sensorimotor impairment, highlighting the need for longitudinal research.
  • Antipsychotic Medication: While controlled for, the potential influence of antipsychotic medication on NSS remains a consideration, though the study found NSS to be high even in minimally medicated ASD participants.

Future work should focus on longitudinal studies to track the developmental trajectories of these deficits. Further research into the specific neurobiological mechanisms underlying the link between early neurodevelopment, sensorimotor function, and social cognition in SCZ-eaP is warranted. The authors suggest that gyrification markers, being more stable, could be valuable for future diagnostic and prognostic strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Earlier age of prodrome in SCZ is associated with impaired social cognition, mediated by neurodevelopmentally-related sensorimotor impairments along the ASD-SCZ spectrum. It suggests age of prodrome, rather than the age at psychosis onset, should be considered to define more homogeneous subgroups in SCZ.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{iftimovici2024schizophrenia,
  author = {Anton Iftimovici and Gilles Martínez and Julie Victor and Narjès Bendjemaa and Célia Jantac and Charlotte Danset-Alexandre and Isabelle Amado and Laura Pina‐Camacho and Boris Chaumette and Mar Fatjó‐Vilas and Lourdes Fañanás and Édouard Duchesnay and Marie‐Odile Krebs},
  title = {{Schizophrenia Following Early Adolescence Prodrome: A Neurodevelopmental Subtype With Autism-like Sensorimotor and Social Cognition Deficits}},
  booktitle = {Schizophrenia},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1093/schbul/sbae202},
}
Figure