Schematic Assessments of Presidential Candidates

Arthur H. Miller, Martin Wattenberg, Oksana MalanchukAmerican 1986 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper argues that voters don't just superficially assess presidential candidates; instead, they use pre-existing cognitive frameworks (schemas) to evaluate candidates based on performance-relevant criteria like competence, integrity, and reliability. These schemas are surprisingly stable over time and influence how voters interpret new information, suggesting a more structured and less "irrational" decision-making process than previously assumed.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, political science research has debated how voters evaluate presidential candidates. Traditional views, like those in "The American Voter," suggested that candidate assessments were largely driven by stable party identification and issue stances, with personality being a secondary, often superficial, factor. More recent "rational choice" models propose voters make complex calculations of utility. However, these models often struggle to explain the content of voters' thoughts about candidates. This paper addresses the gap by investigating the cognitive structures voters use to form opinions about candidates, specifically challenging the notion that personality-based judgments are inherently superficial or irrational. It aims to understand how voters process candidate information and what criteria they actually use.

Methods

The authors employ a social cognition framework, specifically the concept of "schemas," to analyze voter perceptions. They analyze a large corpus of open-ended responses from the American National Election Studies (NES) spanning from 1952 to 1984.

  • Factor Analysis: To identify the underlying cognitive categories voters use, the researchers applied factor analysis to the open-ended comments. This allowed them to group similar responses into broader dimensions.
  • Time Series and Panel Data Analysis: They used both aggregate data across election years and panel data (tracking the same individuals over time) to examine the stability and evolution of these cognitive categories. This helps determine if voters consistently apply the same criteria.
  • Multivariate Regression: Regression analyses were used to explore the predictors of using different judgmental dimensions (e.g., education, political interest, media exposure) and to link these cognitive judgments to affective evaluations and vote choice.

Datasets

The primary dataset used is the American National Election Studies (NES), specifically the open-ended survey responses from presidential election years between 1952 and 1984. This dataset is valuable because it captures voters' own words and allows for the analysis of their unprompted thoughts about candidates.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Personality" is Performance-Oriented: Contrary to popular belief and some academic interpretations, voters' focus on "personality" characteristics is not superficial. Instead, these traits are often proxies for performance-relevant criteria like competence, integrity, and reliability.
  • Stable Schemas Guide Judgments: Voters don't evaluate candidates in a vacuum. They possess pre-existing "schemas" – cognitive frameworks about what a president should be like – that they use to interpret and judge actual candidates. These schemas are remarkably stable over time.
  • Education and Cognitive Style: Higher education is correlated with a greater likelihood of using personality categories, but not in a superficial way. Instead, better-educated voters use these categories to make more complex inferences about a candidate's performance. Less educated voters tend to rely more on readily observable features.
  • The "Personal" Dimension is Complex: The "personal" dimension identified in the analysis isn't just about looks or style. It encompasses observable features that can cue inferences about a candidate's underlying qualities.
  • "Competence" Reigns Supreme: Across all years, "competence" consistently emerged as the most frequently mentioned judgmental category, underscoring its importance in voter evaluations.

Key Results

  • Five Core Dimensions: Factor analysis revealed five primary dimensions voters use to assess candidates: Competence, Integrity, Reliability, Charisma, and Personal.
  • Stability of Dimensions: Panel data showed significant continuity in the use of Competence, Integrity, and Reliability dimensions over time, suggesting these are enduring judgmental criteria.
  • Education's Counter-Intuitive Role: Higher education was linked to more "personal" comments, but these comments were found to be more about inferring performance-relevant traits (competence, integrity) rather than superficial attributes.
  • Predictive Power: Schematic judgments, particularly those related to competence, integrity, and reliability, were found to be significant predictors of affective candidate ratings and vote choice, especially for more educated voters.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: The authors acknowledge that the open-ended questions, while rich, might not be perfectly designed to distinguish between all possible cognitive process models. Further analysis with different data types might be needed to fully test alternative models of candidate evaluation.
  • Emerging Dimensions: While their analysis didn't strongly support a distinct "compassion" dimension, they note that recent research suggests such dimensions might be emerging, warranting further investigation.
  • Micro-Level Processes: The paper focuses more on the content and structure of schemas rather than the precise micro-level cognitive processes involved in their application. Future work could delve deeper into these mechanisms.
  • Generalizability: While the study covers a significant period, the authors suggest that future research could explore how these findings generalize to other political contexts or types of elections.

Summary updated

Abstract

This article applies theories of social cognition in an investigation of the dimensions of the assessments of candidates employed by voters in the United States. An empirical description of the public's cognitive representations of presidential candidates, derived from responses to open-ended questions in the American National Election Studies from 1952 to 1984, reveals that perceptions of candidates are generally focused on “personality” characteristics rather than on issue concerns or partisan group connections. Contrary to the implications of past research, higher education is found to be correlated with a greater likelihood of using personality categories rather than with making issue statements. While previous models have interpreted voting on the basis of candidate personality as indicative of superficial and idiosyncratic assessments, the data examined here indicate that they predominately reflect performance-relevant criteria such as competence, integrity, and reliability. In addition, both panel and aggregate time series data suggest that the categories that voters have used in the past influence how they will perceive future candidates, implying the application of schematic judgments. The reinterpretation presented here argues that these judgments reflect a rich cognitive representation of the candidates from which instrumental inferences are made.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{miller1986schematic,
  author = {Arthur H. Miller and Martin Wattenberg and Oksana Malanchuk},
  title = {{Schematic Assessments of Presidential Candidates}},
  booktitle = {American},
  year = {1986},
  doi = {10.2307/1958272},
}
Figure