Scenario-based Unit Commitment Optimization for Power System with Large-scale Wind Power Participating in Primary Frequency Regulation

Lili Hao, Jing Ji, Dongliang Xie, Haohao Wang, Wei Li, Philip AsaahJournal of Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy 2020 · DOI

Abstract

The continuous increase of wind power penetration introduces significant randomness to power systems and leads to a shortage of primary frequency regulation (PFR) reserves, traditionally provided by conventional units. This paper proposes a unit commitment (UC) optimization model that coordinates steady-state and transient-state operations, allowing large-scale wind power to participate in PFR. The model considers traditional operation costs alongside wind farm de-loaded operation losses, environmental benefits, and transient frequency safety costs. A selection method for high-risk scenarios is introduced to improve calculation efficiency, and an inner-outer iterative optimization method is proposed for the solution. Validation on the New England 10-machine system demonstrates that the model ensures both transient frequency safety and operational economy.

Introduction

As global energy systems transition toward renewables, traditional synchronous generators are increasingly replaced by wind turbines. This shift presents a stability challenge: conventional plants provide inherent inertia and automatic reserves to stabilize grid frequency. In contrast, wind turbines are often decoupled from grid frequency via power electronics, failing to respond naturally to frequency drops. This results in a PFR reserve shortage and increased stochastic risk from unpredictable wind patterns. Standard optimization models often overlook "black-swan" events—low-probability, high-risk scenarios—that could trigger system collapse during frequency instability.

Proposed Methodology

The proposed UC model balances operational economics with transient safety through several key technical innovations:

Wind De-loaded Operation

Rather than operating wind turbines at maximum power, the model employs "de-loading" techniques, such as rotor over-speed and pitch angle control. This creates a power buffer that can be injected into the grid during frequency dips, effectively turning wind farms into high-speed reserve sources.

High-Risk Scenario Selection

To manage computational complexity, the authors developed a selection method based on the Ratio of Remaining Risk (RR). This identifies scenarios where power deficits are likely to breach safety margins, prioritizing the consequence of a scenario over its mere probability.

Inner-Outer Iterative Optimization

The model is solved using a dual-loop iterative approach. The outer loop updates the set of high-risk scenarios, while the inner loop utilizes Benders Decomposition to split the problem into a steady-state master problem and a transient-state sub-problem.

Figure 4: Flowchart of the proposed inner-outer iterative optimization method.

Experimental Results and Discussion

The model was validated using the New England 10-machine system, featuring 6 thermal units, 1 hydropower unit, and 3 large-scale wind farms, with wind penetration levels between 25% and 50%.

Economic and Safety Performance

The total operational cost for the test system was approximately $8.23 million. Crucially, in high-risk scenarios involving major generator trips, the model maintained frequency deviations within a safe limit of 0.5 Hz. In comparison, models ignoring transient safety or wind PFR experienced frequency drops exceeding 2.2 Hz, which would likely lead to blackouts.

Wind Utilization for Reserves

The results highlight that wind farms and hydropower units were prioritized for PFR reserves due to their lower response costs compared to thermal units. Figure 6 illustrates how wind farms maintain reserve capacity through varying de-loaded levels throughout the day to ensure system stability.

Figure 6: Total reserve capacity and de-loaded levels of wind farms (G8, G9, G10) over a 24-hour period.

Conclusion

The proposed scenario-based UC model successfully integrates large-scale wind power into primary frequency regulation. By prioritizing high-risk scenarios and coordinating steady and transient states, the system achieves a balance between economic efficiency and grid resilience. Future research will address complexities such as wake effects within wind farms and the integration of diverse turbine types with varying control characteristics.

Summary updated

Abstract

Continuous increase of wind power penetration brings high randomness to power system, and also leads to serious shortage of primary frequency regulation (PFR) reserve for power system whose reserve capacity is typically provided by conventional units. Considering large-scale wind power participating in PFR, this paper proposes a unit commitment optimization model with respect to coordination of steady state and transient state. In addition to traditional operation costs, losses of wind farm de-loaded operation, environmental benefits and transient frequency safety costs in high-risk stochastic scenarios are also considered in the model. Besides, the model makes full use of interruptible loads on demand side as one of the PFR reserve sources. A selection method for high-risk scenarios is also proposed to improve the calculation efficiency. Finally, this paper proposes an inner-outer iterative optimization method for the model solution. The method is validated by the New England 10-machine system, and the results show that the optimization model can guarantee both the safety of transient frequency and the economy of system operation.
BibTeX
@article{hao2020scenario,
  author = {Lili Hao and Jing Ji and Dongliang Xie and Haohao Wang and Wei Li and Philip Asaah},
  title = {{Scenario-based Unit Commitment Optimization for Power System with Large-scale Wind Power Participating in Primary Frequency Regulation}},
  journal = {Journal of Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.35833/mpce.2019.000418},
}
Figure