Scenario-Based Extreme Flood Risk of Residential Buildings and Household Properties in Shanghai

Xinmeng Shan, Jiahong Wen, Min Zhang, Luyang Wang, Qian Ke, Weijiang Li, Shiqiang Du, Yong Shi, Kun Chen, Banggu Liao, Xiande Li, Hui XuSustainability 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study presents a comprehensive, scenario-based analysis of extreme flood risk to residential buildings and household properties in Shanghai. By integrating advanced flood modeling with detailed asset data, it quantifies potential losses and identifies high-risk areas, providing crucial insights for urban planning and resilience strategies in this vulnerable coastal megacity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Shanghai, a major global economic hub situated in a low-lying coastal region, faces significant and increasing risks from extreme flooding. This threat is exacerbated by factors like climate change, sea-level rise, and land subsidence. While previous studies have addressed flood risks in Shanghai, a comprehensive, city-wide assessment of extreme flood risk specifically for residential buildings and household properties, considering multiple return periods and spatial patterns at a fine resolution, was lacking. This paper aims to fill that gap by providing a detailed, scenario-based analysis to inform effective risk management and urban planning.

Methods

The researchers employed a multidisciplinary approach combining flood hazard modeling, asset valuation, and risk assessment.

  • Flood Hazard Modeling: A sophisticated numerical simulation system, integrating atmospheric, ocean, and coastal models, was used to generate inundation maps for four extreme storm flood scenarios: 1/200, 1/500, 1/1000, and 1/5000-year return periods. These simulations accounted for typhoon-induced storm surges, high astronomical tides, heavy rain, and fluvial floods, considering sea dike and floodwall performance.
  • Asset Valuation: Residential building data (footprint, height) were acquired using web crawling and validated with high-resolution imagery. Housing prices were obtained from real estate platforms and augmented with machine learning for spatial coverage. Household property values (wall coating, wooden floors, appliances, furniture) were estimated using market price data and empirical methods.
  • Exposure, Loss, and Risk Analysis: A GIS-based overlay analysis combined hazard maps with asset data to determine exposed assets. Stage-damage functions were applied to estimate direct economic losses for both buildings and household properties. Finally, Average Annual Loss (AAL) was calculated, and spatial patterns of risk were identified using the local Gi* statistic to pinpoint hot spots and cold spots.

Datasets

  • Flood Scenarios: Simulated inundation maps for 1/200, 1/500, 1/1000, and 1/5000-year storm flood events in Shanghai.
  • Residential Building Data: Footprint and height information acquired from Baidu Map and validated with Google Earth imagery.
  • Housing Price Data: Obtained from Lianjia (a Chinese O2O real estate agency) and supplemented using machine learning for spatial completeness.
  • Household Property Market Price Data: Derived from the Shanghai Statistical Yearbook and company websites for household appliances and furniture.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Escalating Risk with Return Period: The study clearly demonstrates that both the extent of inundation and the potential economic losses increase dramatically with more extreme flood events (longer return periods). This highlights the critical need to plan for low-probability, high-consequence events.
  • Dominance of Building Exposure: Residential buildings represent the vast majority (around 95%) of the total exposed asset value, underscoring their primary role in flood risk. However, household properties, though a smaller portion of the total asset, are shown to be more vulnerable relative to their value.
  • Spatial Concentration of Risk: While extreme flood risk is distributed across Shanghai, specific "hot spots" emerge. These are not solely confined to the most flood-prone areas but also include densely urbanized zones with high asset values, particularly in the main urban area and along the Hangzhou Bay.
  • Inner City Vulnerability: Contrary to potential assumptions that only peripheral areas are at risk, the study reveals that the inner city is also highly threatened, with a significant portion of the AAL attributed to these areas. This is particularly concerning given the historical importance and high density of development.
  • Pudong as a High-Risk District: Pudong emerges as the district with the highest exposure and annual expected loss, emphasizing its critical role in Shanghai's flood risk management strategy.

Key Results

  • Inundation Area: For a 1/200-year flood, the inundation area for residential buildings is 24.9 km². This expands to 162.4 km² for a 1/5000-year event.
  • Total Economic Loss: The total loss for residential buildings and household properties escalates from 29.7 billion CNY (approx. 4.4 billion USD) for a 1/200-year flood to 366.0 billion CNY (approx. 54.2 billion USD) for a 1/5000-year flood.
  • Average Annual Loss (AAL): The estimated AAL for Shanghai is 590 million CNY/year (approx. 87.4 million USD/year).
  • District-Level Risk: Pudong, Baoshan, and Huangpu districts show the highest AALs. The eight downtown districts collectively account for 49% of the total AAL.
  • Vulnerable Areas: Pudong, Jiading, Baoshan Districts, and the inner city are identified as areas most vulnerable to storm flooding.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uncertainty: The authors acknowledge that inundation maps, stage-damage functions, and asset data all contain inherent uncertainties that propagate through the calculations. Future work should further address these uncertainties.
  • Scope: This study focused specifically on extreme flooding and residential buildings/household properties. The authors suggest that a comprehensive analysis should also consider other flood types (fluvial, pluvial) and integrate climate change projections, sea-level rise, and land subsidence more explicitly.
  • Household Property Vulnerability: While household properties represent a smaller portion of total exposed assets, their loss accounts for a significant percentage of total losses (around 27%), indicating higher relative vulnerability. Further research could explore this vulnerability more deeply.
  • Proactive Risk Management: The study advocates for a more proactive approach to flood risk management, moving beyond reactive measures taken after major flood events, drawing parallels with initiatives in other major global cities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Extreme flooding usually causes huge losses of residential buildings and household properties, which is critical to flood risk analysis and flood resilience building in Shanghai. We developed a scenario-based multidisciplinary approach to analyze the exposure, losses and risks of residential buildings and household properties, and their spatial patterns at the neighborhood committee level in Shanghai, based on extreme storm flood scenarios of 1/200, 1/500, 1/1000 and 1/5000-year. Our findings show that the inundation area of the residential buildings caused by a 1/200-year storm flood reaches 24.9 km2, and the total loss of residential buildings and household properties is 29.7 billion CNY (Chinese Yuan) (or 4.4 billion USD), while the inundation area of residential buildings and the total loss increases up to 162.4 km2 and 366.0 billion CNY (or 54.2 billion USD), respectively for a 1/5000-year storm flood. The estimated average annual loss (AAL) of residential buildings and household properties for Shanghai is 590 million CNY/year (or 87.4 million USD/year), with several hot spots distributed around the main urban area and on the bank of the Hangzhou Bay. Among sixteen districts, Pudong has the highest exposure and annual expected loss, while the inner city is also subject to extreme flooding with an AAL up to near half of the total. An analysis of flood risk in each of 209 subdistricts/towns finds that those most vulnerable to storm flooding are concentrated in Pudong, Jiading, Baoshan Districts and the inner city. Our work can provide meaningful information for risk-sensitive urban planning and resilience building in Shanghai. The methodology can also be used for risk analysis in other coastal cities facing the threat of storm flooding.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shan2019scenario,
  author = {Xinmeng Shan and Jiahong Wen and Min Zhang and Luyang Wang and Qian Ke and Weijiang Li and Shiqiang Du and Yong Shi and Kun Chen and Banggu Liao and Xiande Li and Hui Xu},
  title = {{Scenario-Based Extreme Flood Risk of Residential Buildings and Household Properties in Shanghai}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/su11113202},
}
Figure