Scenario-Based Analysis of Land Use Competition and Sustainable Land Development in Zhangye of the Heihe River Basin, China

Yuping Bai, Zhe Zhao, Chuyao Weng, Wenxuan Wang, Yecui HuInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the critical challenge of balancing rapid economic development with ecological preservation in Zhangye, China, a vulnerable region in the Heihe River Basin. By employing a novel integrated modeling approach (CGELUC and DLS), the study simulates future land use changes under different development scenarios, offering crucial insights for sustainable land management and policy-making.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rapid economic growth and urbanization, particularly in ecologically sensitive areas like Zhangye, often lead to significant land use changes that can threaten natural ecosystems. Zhangye, situated in the arid Heihe River Basin, faces a growing conflict between increasing demands for built-up areas and the need to protect valuable cultivated land and fragile ecosystems. The "Silk Road Economic Belt" initiative further intensifies development pressures. This paper addresses the need for a scientific framework to understand and predict these land use dynamics under various development pathways, enabling informed decisions for sustainable land resource allocation and management in rapidly urbanizing regions of western China.

Methods

The study introduces a two-stage modeling approach:

  1. Computable General Equilibrium of Land Use Change (CGELUC) Model: This model, built upon the ORANI-G framework, simulates the socioeconomic drivers of land use change. It integrates land resources as a production factor within a multi-level nested production function structure. The model accounts for economic activities, resource constraints, and policy shocks to predict the demand for different land use types across various industrial sectors. A key innovation is the incorporation of land resource accounts and the use of a modified CET function to handle land heterogeneity and conversion elasticity.
  2. Dynamic Land System (DLS) Model: This model takes the land use demand generated by the CGELUC model and spatializes it. It simulates the spatial patterns of land use change at a grid scale, considering both natural environmental factors and socioeconomic drivers. The DLS model incorporates a driving analysis module to understand spatial relationships and a spatial allocation module that simulates land use conversion based on probabilities, rules, and land supply-demand balance at the grid level. The integration of these two models allows for a comprehensive analysis of both macro-level economic impacts and micro-level spatial dynamics of land use change.

Datasets

The study utilizes the following datasets:

  • Socioeconomic Data: Zhangye Input-Output Table 2012, which includes 7 agricultural sectors and 41 secondary and tertiary industrial sectors.
  • Natural Data: Land use data, landform type, DEM, slope, aspect, climate data (temperature, precipitation, sunshine duration), and soil data (organic matter, depth, pH). These were sourced from the Resource and Environment Science and Data Center, Chinese Academy of Science, and the Chinese Meteorological Data Center.
  • Land Resource Value Data: Calculated based on the input-output table and land prices derived from agricultural land rent and industrial/service land transfer prices.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Economic Growth Drives Land Use Shifts: The study highlights that economic growth inherently leads to a shift in land demand, favoring high value-added industries and consequently increasing the demand for built-up areas while decreasing demand for low value-added industries.
  • Cultivated Land Under Threat: Across all scenarios, cultivated land is projected to decrease, with the most significant reduction occurring under the resource consumption scenario. This underscores the persistent tension between development and food security.
  • Spatial Patterns Matter: The DLS model reveals distinct spatial patterns of built-up area expansion. The resource consumption scenario leads to concentrated, contiguous expansion, while the green development scenario promotes more uniform and discrete growth. This has significant implications for land management and infrastructure planning.
  • Green Development Offers a More Balanced Path: The green development scenario, while still showing land use changes, demonstrates a more sustainable trajectory with less drastic reductions in cultivated land and a significant expansion of ecological land.

Key Results

By 2030, the study projects the following changes in Zhangye city:

  • Cultivated Land: Decreases by 8.16% (BAU), 10.89% (RCS), and 4.16% (GDS).
  • Built-up Area: Increases by 8.61% (BAU), 10.39% (RCS), and 4.75% (GDS).
  • Forest Area: Increases by 2.60% (BAU), 1.50% (RCS), and 3.81% (GDS).
  • Grassland: Increases by 2.58% (BAU), 1.51% (RCS), and 3.81% (GDS).
  • Water Area: Increases under BAU and GDS, but decreases under RCS.
  • Unused Land: Decreases under BAU and GDS, but increases under RCS.

The Kappa index of 0.9036 for the DLS model's simulation results indicates high accuracy and reliability in predicting spatial land use patterns.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Land Resource Value Accounting: The study acknowledges that the value accounting of land resources was simplified by using unified average prices for industrial and service land. Future work should involve more accurate accounting, considering temporal and spatial variations in land rent and transfer prices.
  • Scenario Design: While three scenarios were explored, the authors suggest that future research should incorporate additional constraints, such as water resource limitations, to provide a more comprehensive reference for land use planning.
  • Model Refinement: The dynamic CGE model, while incorporating capital accumulation and employment trends, experienced some initial prediction unreasonableness in the early years due to the partial delay of capital and investment transformation. Further improvements to the model are needed.
  • Cross-Regional Studies: The CGELUC model's applicability could be enhanced through cross-regional studies, and future work will explore land use change and natural resource management on a watershed scale within the Heihe River Basin.

Summary updated

Abstract

Rapid economic growth has a significant impact on land use change, which would threaten the natural ecology. Zhangye city of the Heihe River Basin, China is an ecologically vulnerable region where land use changes significantly due to socioeconomic development and population increases. The study employed a computable general equilibrium of land use change (CGELUC) model to simulate land use change and then used a dynamic land system (DLS) model to spatialize land use change during 2015-2030 under three development scenarios in Zhangye city. The three development scenarios are the baseline scenario (BAU), the resource consumption scenario (RCS) and the green development scenario (GDS). We found that economic growth would lead to land demand increases in high value-added industries and decreases in low value-added industries. The cultivated land would decrease while the built-up area would increase. By 2030, the cultivated land will decrease by 8.16%, 10.89% and 4.16%, respectively, under BAU, RCS and GDS, while the built-up area will increase by 8.61%, 10.39% and 4.75%, respectively. The expansion of built-up area under RCS presents spatial characteristics of centralized distribution, while spatial characteristics of uniform discrete distributions are presented under GDS. The expansion of ecological land under GDS would be considerable, especially in the north of Sunan County and Gaotai County, and around the natural reserve of Ganzhou County. This paper provides a scientific reference for coordinating economic development and ecological protection in the rapidly developing urbanized areas in western China.
BibTeX
@article{bai2021scenario,
  author = {Yuping Bai and Zhe Zhao and Chuyao Weng and Wenxuan Wang and Yecui Hu},
  title = {{Scenario-Based Analysis of Land Use Competition and Sustainable Land Development in Zhangye of the Heihe River Basin, China}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph181910501},
}
Figure