Scan power reduction based on clock-gating

Ning Huang, En ZhuIEICE Electron. Express 2012 · OpenReview

Abstract

In modern integrated circuit (IC) manufacturing, scan testing is essential for quality assurance but introduces significant power consumption challenges. High switching activity during testing can lead to overheating and physical damage. This paper proposes a hardware-software co-design to mitigate these issues. The approach features a scan-clock-control circuit that selectively gates clocks for scan chains and a greedy pattern-reordering algorithm to maximize gating efficiency. Experimental results on industrial designs demonstrate a reduction in peak shift power by up to 73.6% with minimal area overhead and no impact on fault coverage.

Introduction

Scan testing is the industry standard for verifying the structural integrity of ICs. By connecting flip-flops into scan chains, test patterns can be shifted in and responses shifted out. However, the switching activity during this process often exceeds the chip's functional power limits, causing voltage noise and thermal stress. Existing power-reduction techniques often target either shift or capture power in isolation or require complex modifications to the Automatic Test Pattern Generation (ATPG) flow. This work addresses these challenges through a unified hardware-software strategy that maintains compatibility with standard industrial workflows.

Methodology

The proposed solution consists of two primary components: a hardware control block and a software optimization algorithm.

Scan-Clock-Control Circuit

The hardware component is a specialized control block integrated into the chip's test architecture. It utilizes clock-gating cells, shift registers, and update registers to manage the clock signals for individual scan chains.

The proposed scan-clock-control circuit architecture.

The circuit performs two critical functions:

  1. Shift-Control: It addresses the inefficiency caused by unequal scan chain lengths. By gating the clock for shorter chains once they have finished their respective load/unload operations, the circuit eliminates unnecessary switching.
  2. Capture-Control: During the capture phase, the circuit identifies scan chains that do not contain active observation points for a given test pattern and blocks their clock signals entirely.

Scan Pattern Reordering Algorithm

To maximize the effectiveness of the hardware gating, the authors developed a greedy pattern-reordering algorithm. The algorithm uses a "wasted power" metric, defined as the sum of excess shift cycles across all chains. By reordering the test patterns, the algorithm ensures that the scan chains remain in a gated (off) state for the maximum possible duration.

Experimental Evaluation

The methodology was validated using three large-scale industrial circuit designs:

  • T161: 360,000 gates with 107 scan chains.
  • T5572: 1.6 million gates with 297 scan chains.
  • T9283: 2.9 million gates with 288 scan chains.

These designs provide a realistic assessment of the method's performance in complex semiconductor manufacturing environments.

Results and Discussion

The proposed method was compared against established benchmarks in the field.

Power Reduction

The primary achievement was in peak shift power reduction, which ranged from 61.7% to 73.6% across the tested designs. This significantly outperformed baseline methods. Capture power reduction was more modest, ranging from 4.5% to 6.9%. The lower reduction in capture power is attributed to the design choice of not modifying internal clock-gating cells during ATPG, prioritizing ease of integration over maximum theoretical savings.

Overhead and Compatibility

The hardware overhead is minimal, consisting of a small number of additional gates for the control logic. While there is a slight increase in test data volume due to the need for "control codes," the overall test time remains unchanged. Crucially, the method does not require "power-aware" ATPG, allowing it to be seamlessly integrated into existing design-for-test (DFT) flows.

Conclusion

This paper demonstrates an effective hardware-software co-design for reducing scan power. By combining a flexible clock-gating circuit with an efficient pattern-reordering algorithm, the authors achieved substantial power savings in industrial-scale designs. Future work will explore deeper integration with scan segmentation techniques to further enhance capture power reduction.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2012scan,
  author = {Ning Huang and En Zhu},
  title = {{Scan power reduction based on clock-gating}},
  booktitle = {IEICE Electron. Express},
  year = {2012},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=7VAUlo4KUsc},
}

Loading related content...

Figure