Scaling up public transport usage: a systematic literature review of service quality, satisfaction and attitude towards bus transport systems in developing countries

Eugene Sogbe, Susilawati Susilawati, Chee Pin TanPublic 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Urban sprawl driven by urbanisation has contributed to a sharp rise in privately owned vehicles and competition for restricted resource space. The utilisation of private vehicles has increased, particularly in developing countries, leading to many negative externalities, including traffic congestion and emissions. To encourage the use of sustainable modes such as public transport, it is essential for policymakers and transport authorities to carefully examine the determinants influencing public transport usage. This review offers a valuable understanding of the contemporary knowledge regarding the determinants influencing bus transport usage. It systematically reviews 104 papers published since 2000 on service quality, satisfaction, and attitudes towards bus transport. The review shows that safety, security, comfort, reliability and accessibility are the most substantial determinants shaping users' views. Challenges with first-mile and last-mile connectivity are apparent, necessitating further investigation.

Introduction

Rapid urbanization in developing countries has triggered a surge in private vehicle ownership, leading to crippling traffic congestion and high emissions. While public transport (PT) is the sustainable solution, usage has declined, exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic. Most transport policy is based on research from developed Western nations, which doesn't account for the unique infrastructure, economic constraints, and social dynamics of developing regions. This paper fills that gap by systematically evaluating what influences service quality (SQ), passenger satisfaction, and attitudes toward bus transport specifically in these emerging economies.

Methodology

The authors conducted a Systematic Literature Review (SLR) following the PRISMA guidelines to ensure a rigorous and transparent selection process.

PRISMA flow diagram showing the identification, screening, and inclusion process for the 104 reviewed studies.

The search strategy involved querying seven major databases (including Scopus and TRID), initially capturing over 55,000 records. After applying strict inclusion/exclusion criteria—focusing only on developing countries, peer-reviewed journals, and bus/BRT systems—the pool was narrowed to 104 core papers published between 2000 and 2023. The analytical methods in the reviewed literature have evolved from traditional SERVQUAL models to more robust Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) and Machine Learning (ML) algorithms like Random Forest (RF).

Geographical Distribution and Data Sources

Research is heavily concentrated in Asia, reflecting the rapid urbanization and transport challenges in the region.

Distribution of publications by country, highlighting the dominance of research from China and India.

As shown in the data, China (23 papers) and India (18) lead the output. Data sources primarily consist of surveys, interviews, and focus groups (94 studies), with a growing minority utilizing secondary data like transit agency ticketing and Automatic Vehicle Location (AVL) data. Sample sizes ranged from small qualitative cohorts to massive datasets exceeding 500,000 records.

Key Findings

The review identifies several critical determinants of bus ridership:

  • Safety and Security: Unlike in developed nations where safety is often assumed, it is a top-tier determinant of satisfaction in developing countries. Fear of crime and harassment, particularly for women, is a major deterrent.
  • The "Social-Symbolic" Hurdle: Car ownership remains a status symbol. Attitudes toward PT are often prejudiced by the perception that buses are for those who cannot afford better.
  • First-Mile/Last-Mile (FM/LM) Connectivity: The ease and safety of getting to and from the bus stop are critical. If the walk is perceived as unsafe, the quality of the bus ride becomes irrelevant.
  • Climate Factors: In hot climates, the lack of shaded stops or air-conditioned vehicles significantly degrades perceived service quality.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The review suggests that future research must target "non-users" (private car owners) to understand the tipping points for mode-shifting. Additionally, exploring Mobility-as-a-Service (MaaS) integration with informal transport (paratransit) presents a significant opportunity for developing nations. Policymakers should focus on objective performance metrics and "Mystery Shopping" to supplement subjective survey data for more effective interventions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Urban sprawl driven by urbanisation has contributed to a sharp rise in privately owned vehicles and competition for restricted resource space. The utilisation of private vehicles has increased, particularly in developing countries, and this phenomenon leads to many negative externalities, including traffic congestion and emissions. To encourage the use of sustainable modes such as public transport, it is essential for policymakers and transport authorities to carefully examine the determinants influencing public transport usage and apply successful policies and procedures. This review offers a valuable understanding of the contemporary knowledge regarding the determinants influencing bus transport usage. It systematically reviews 104 papers published since 2000 on service quality, satisfaction, and attitudes towards bus transport. The review shows that safety, security, comfort, reliability and accessibility are the most substantial determinants shaping users' views on service quality and satisfaction. This is particularly evident in situations like waiting at the bus stop, being on board the bus, and specific instances while walking to their destination. The results indicate that challenges with first-mile and last-mile connectivity are apparent, and further exploration in the context of developing countries is needed to understand these challenges, necessitating further investigation. It also demonstrates instrumental aspects such as convenience and social-symbolic aspects such as social standing, influencing attitudes towards public transport usage. It concludes by suggesting potential paths for future research and discusses the impacts of the results on policy decisions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sogbe2024scaling,
  author = {Eugene Sogbe and Susilawati Susilawati and Chee Pin Tan},
  title = {{Scaling up public transport usage: a systematic literature review of service quality, satisfaction and attitude towards bus transport systems in developing countries}},
  booktitle = {Public},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/s12469-024-00367-6},
}
Figure