Scaling description of the yielding transition in soft amorphous solids at zero temperature

Jie Lin, Edan Lerner, Alberto Rosso, Matthieu WyartProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a new scaling theory to describe how soft amorphous solids transition from a solid-like state to a fluid-like state under shear stress, particularly at zero temperature. The theory connects the macroscopic flow behavior (how easily the material flows) to the microscopic events of plastic deformation, revealing universal relationships between these phenomena.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many everyday materials, like gels, pastes, and foams, exhibit "yield stress" – they resist flow until a certain stress threshold is reached, after which they deform readily. Understanding this yielding transition is crucial for predicting material behavior in applications ranging from food processing to geological phenomena. However, a fundamental microscopic understanding of this transition in soft amorphous solids, especially in the simplified case of zero temperature and homogeneous flow, has been lacking. Previous models often treated local plastic events independently, but recent observations suggest these events occur in coordinated "avalanches." This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a scaling description that links the macroscopic flow curve singularity to the statistics of these plastic avalanches and the underlying microscopic structure of the material.

Methods

The authors propose a scaling theory that draws parallels with the well-studied "depinning transition" of elastic interfaces in random media. However, they highlight key differences arising from the nature of interactions in amorphous solids. Their theory posits that the critical exponents governing the yielding transition can be expressed in terms of three fundamental, independent exponents:

  • θ: Characterizes the density of "soft spots" or shear transformation zones (STZs) – regions prone to yielding – as a function of the stress increment needed to trigger them.
  • df: The fractal dimension of the plastic avalanches, describing how they spread spatially.
  • z: The dynamical exponent, relating the duration of an avalanche to its spatial extent.

To test their theory, the researchers employ an elasto-plastic model. This is a computational model where a lattice represents the material, and each site can undergo plastic deformation. Crucially, when a site yields, it influences the stress on its neighbors through an interaction kernel. This kernel is designed to be long-ranged and anisotropic, mimicking aspects of amorphous solids, and differs from the simpler kernels used in depinning models. They use both two-dimensional (2D) and three-dimensional (3D) versions of this model and analyze the resulting stress-strain curves, avalanche statistics, and the distribution of soft spots.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on numerical simulations of an elasto-plastic model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Universality in Plasticity: The paper suggests that despite the complexity of amorphous solids, their yielding behavior can be described by a universal scaling framework, similar to other critical phenomena like depinning.
  • The Role of "Soft Spots": The density distribution of STZs (characterized by θ) is not a simple power law as in depinning but has a singularity at zero, which is crucial for explaining the unique features of amorphous solid yielding. This singularity arises from the non-monotonic nature of the stress-transfer kernel.
  • Connecting Micro and Macro: The theory establishes a direct link between the macroscopic Herschel-Bulkley exponent (describing the flow curve singularity) and the microscopic avalanche dynamics (df and z) and the soft spot distribution (θ).
  • Depinning Analogy and Distinction: While the analogy to depinning is fruitful, the authors emphasize that the non-monotonic and anisotropic nature of the stress-transfer kernel in amorphous solids leads to distinct critical exponents and scaling relations, particularly the non-zero value of θ.

Key Results

  • The proposed scaling relations successfully predict relationships between various critical exponents of the yielding transition.
  • Numerical simulations of the elasto-plastic model in both 2D and 3D show excellent agreement with the predictions of the scaling theory.
  • Exponent Values:
    • In 2D, the model yields θ ≈ 0.57, df ≈ 1.10, and z ≈ 0.57.
  • In 3D, the model yields θ ≈ 0.35, df ≈ 1.50, and z ≈ 0.65.
  • These simulated exponents are consistent with the derived scaling relations, validating the theoretical framework. For instance, the Herschel-Bulkley exponent β is found to be related to df and z, and the simulations confirm these predicted values.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: The elasto-plastic model, while capturing key physics, is a simplification of real amorphous materials. The interaction kernel is assumed to be instantaneous, which might affect the dynamical exponents (z and β).
  • Experimental Verification: While the authors mention comparisons with experimental data for some exponents, further direct experimental validation of the proposed scaling relations, especially for θ, would be valuable.
  • Inertia and Temperature: This study focuses on the zero-temperature, athermal limit. The authors suggest that including inertia or finite temperature effects could lead to different dynamics and potentially alter the critical exponents.
  • Anisotropy and Mean-Field Theory: The authors note that a more advanced mean-field theory that explicitly incorporates anisotropy is needed to fully understand the behavior of θ and its dependence on dimensionality. This could also shed light on the behavior of materials like granular media.

Summary updated

Abstract

Yield stress materials flow if a sufficiently large shear stress is applied. Although such materials are ubiquitous and relevant for industry, there is no accepted microscopic description of how they yield, even in the simplest situations in which temperature is negligible and in which flow inhomogeneities such as shear bands or fractures are absent. Here we propose a scaling description of the yielding transition in amorphous solids made of soft particles at zero temperature. Our description makes a connection between the Herschel-Bulkley exponent characterizing the singularity of the flow curve near the yield stress Σc, the extension and duration of the avalanches of plasticity observed at threshold, and the density P(x) of soft spots, or shear transformation zones, as a function of the stress increment x beyond which they yield. We argue that the critical exponents of the yielding transition may be expressed in terms of three independent exponents, θ, df, and z, characterizing, respectively, the density of soft spots, the fractal dimension of the avalanches, and their duration. Our description shares some similarity with the depinning transition that occurs when an elastic manifold is driven through a random potential, but also presents some striking differences. We test our arguments in an elasto-plastic model, an automaton model similar to those used in depinning, but with a different interaction kernel, and find satisfying agreement with our predictions in both two and three dimensions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lin2014scaling,
  author = {Jie Lin and Edan Lerner and Alberto Rosso and Matthieu Wyart},
  title = {{Scaling description of the yielding transition in soft amorphous solids at zero temperature}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.1406391111},
}
Figure