Scale Factor Calibration for a Rotating Accelerometer Gravity Gradiometer

Huafeng Liu, Zhongguang Deng, Chenyuan Hu, Xiangqing Huang, Wen-Jie Wu, Fangjing Hu, Huafeng Liu 0002, Liang Cheng TuSensors 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel static-platform calibration system for Rotating Accelerometer Gravity Gradiometers (RAGGs), a crucial technology for resource exploration and navigation. The proposed method effectively calibrates the RAGG's scale factor by precisely controlling the movement of a reference mass, demonstrating repeatable and stable results with a calibrated scale factor of (5.4 ± 0.2) E/µV.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Gravity gradient measurements are vital for applications like resource exploration and gravity-aided navigation. Rotating Accelerometer Gravity Gradiometers (RAGGs) are a key technology in this domain, but their accuracy heavily relies on precise calibration of their scale factor. Existing methods for RAGG calibration are either not fully detailed or require further experimental verification. This paper addresses the need for an effective and repeatable method to calibrate the scale factor of RAGGs, particularly in environments that might have mass disturbances.

Methods

The authors propose a calibration system that utilizes a RAGG instrument assembled on a rotary table. The core idea is to measure the spatial variation of the gravity gradient induced by a precisely moved reference mass.

  • RAGG Setup: Four metal spring-based accelerometers with good consistency are orthogonally mounted on a rotary table. This setup allows the RAGG to measure the spatial variation of the gravity gradient.
  • Gravity Gradient Excitation: A lead cylinder, chosen for its high density and affordability, serves as the reference mass. This cylinder is moved along a rail to create a controlled gravity gradient.
  • Calibration Strategy: The key innovation lies in how the reference mass is moved. By changing the approaching and receding pattern of the mass relative to the RAGG, and by varying the angle of approach (represented by β), the system can effectively isolate the gravity gradient signal and mitigate the influence of surrounding masses and human disturbances. This controlled movement allows for the demodulation of the gravity gradient signal.
  • Demodulation: The RAGG employs mechanical rotation modulation and synchronous electrical demodulation to extract the gravity gradient signal. The output voltage is then processed using reference signals (sin 2ωt and cos 2ωt) to extract specific components of the gravity gradient tensor.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments were conducted using a custom-built calibration setup and a lead cylinder as the excitation mass.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Controlled Mass Movement for Calibration: The paper highlights the effectiveness of precisely controlling the movement of a reference mass (both in terms of distance and angle of approach) to generate a measurable and repeatable gravity gradient signal for calibration.
  • Mitigating Environmental Disturbances: By strategically changing the direction of the gravity gradient excitation (approaching/receding) and the angle of the mass's movement relative to the RAGG, the influence of static surrounding masses and human disturbances can be significantly reduced.
  • Demodulation for Signal Extraction: The use of synchronous electrical demodulation with specific reference signals (sin 2ωt and cos 2ωt) is crucial for isolating and extracting the desired gravity gradient components from the accelerometer outputs.
  • Repeatability is Key: The experimental results demonstrate the repeatability of the scale factor calibration, which is essential for a reliable measurement instrument.

Key Results

  • Scale Factor Obtained: The proposed method successfully obtained a stable scale factor for the RAGG, determined to be (5.4 ± 0.2) E/µV.
  • Detection Range: The system demonstrated the ability to detect a gravity gradient excitation from a 260 kg lead cylinder within a range of approximately 1.6 meters.
  • Consistency: The experimental results showed good consistency with theoretical simulations.
  • Error Analysis: The authors identified positioning error of the excitation mass as the main limitation, suggesting that higher accuracy positioning rails could further improve performance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Positioning Error: The primary limitation acknowledged is the positioning error of the excitation mass. The accuracy of the calibration is directly impacted by how precisely the lead cylinder can be positioned.
  • Future Improvements:
    • Using higher accuracy position horizontal guide rails to minimize positioning errors.
  • Developing a more accurate gravity gradient excitation model that accounts for higher-order effects.
  • Employing a higher precision accelerometer.
  • Conducting multiple independent RAGG measurements to further improve reliability.
  • Exploring the use of a spherical lead ball for a more idealized excitation source.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{liu2018scale,
  author = {Huafeng Liu and Zhongguang Deng and Chenyuan Hu and Xiangqing Huang and Wen-Jie Wu and Fangjing Hu and Huafeng Liu and Liang Cheng Tu},
  title = {{Scale Factor Calibration for a Rotating Accelerometer Gravity Gradiometer}},
  journal = {Sensors},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/s18124386},
}

Loading related content...

Figure