Scalable pooled CRISPR screens with single-cell chromatin accessibility profiling

Noa Liscovitch‐Brauer, Antonino Montalbano, Jiale Deng, Alejandro Méndez‐Mancilla, Hans‐Hermann Wessels, Nicholas J. Moss, Chia-Yu Kung, Akash Sookdeo, Xinyi Guo, Evan Geller, Suma Jaini, Peter Smibert, Neville E. SanjanabioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces CRISPR-sciATAC, a novel high-throughput single-cell method that simultaneously links CRISPR-induced genetic perturbations with genome-wide chromatin accessibility. This allows researchers to precisely map how altering specific genes impacts the 3D organization of DNA, offering unprecedented insights into gene regulation in both healthy and diseased states.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how genes function and contribute to cellular processes and diseases often involves perturbing them and observing the consequences. While pooled CRISPR screens are powerful for identifying genes involved in specific phenotypes, linking these genetic changes to the underlying molecular mechanisms, particularly chromatin accessibility, has been challenging. Traditional methods struggle with scalability, cost, and the ability to resolve these effects at a single-cell level. This paper addresses the need for a method that can efficiently and affordably connect genetic perturbations with dynamic changes in chromatin accessibility across thousands of individual cells.

Methods

The core innovation is CRISPR-sciATAC, a method that combines pooled CRISPR perturbations with single-cell combinatorial indexing for ATAC-seq (Assay for Transposase-Accessible Chromatin). Here's a breakdown:

  • Pooled CRISPR Perturbations: Cells are transduced with a library of sgRNAs targeting specific genes.
  • Single-Cell Combinatorial Indexing: This is the key to scaling. Instead of isolating each cell individually, the method uses a two-step barcoding process:
  • Combinatorial Index 1: Nuclei are pooled and then split into multiple plates. During this process, ATAC-seq fragments (representing open chromatin) and sgRNAs are tagged with unique barcodes.
  • Combinatorial Index 2: After a second pooling and splitting step, a second set of barcodes is added. This allows for the unique identification of each cell's genetic perturbation and its corresponding chromatin accessibility profile.
  • TnY Transposase: A novel, hyperactive transposase (TnY) is used for efficient and uniform tagmentation of accessible chromatin.
  • Computational Analysis: Sophisticated pipelines are used to demultiplex the barcoded reads, align them to reference genomes, and quantify chromatin accessibility and sgRNA presence at a single-cell level. This enables the correlation of specific genetic perturbations with changes in accessibility.

Datasets

  • Human and Mouse Cell Lines: HEK293FT (human) and NIH3T3 (mouse) cells were used for initial validation of the species-mixing experiment.
  • Human Myelogenous Leukemia Cells (K562): This cell line was used for the main screens, targeting chromatin modifiers and chromatin remodeling complexes.
  • ENCODE ChIP-seq Data: Used to assess changes in chromatin accessibility at specific histone and DNA modification sites.
  • JASPAR Database: Used for identifying transcription factor binding sites (TFBSs).
  • eQTLGen Consortium Data: Used to investigate if chromatin modifier perturbations affect accessibility at SNPs associated with regulatory function.

The paper introduces a new experimental approach (CRISPR-sciATAC) rather than a new benchmark dataset for evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Gap: The most significant insight is the successful integration of pooled CRISPR screening with single-cell ATAC-seq, providing a scalable way to link genetic perturbations to chromatin dynamics.
  • EZH2's Role in HOX Gene Regulation: The loss of EZH2 (a histone methyltransferase) leads to increased accessibility at heterochromatic regions, specifically activating the HOXA and HOXD gene clusters, which are crucial for embryonic development. This highlights EZH2's role in repressing these developmental genes.
  • Chromatin Remodeler Heterogeneity: Disrupting different subunits within chromatin remodeling complexes can have varied and sometimes opposing effects on chromatin accessibility, revealing the complex, subunit-specific roles within these complexes.
  • Enhancers vs. Promoters: The study suggests that chromatin modifiers have a greater impact on accessibility at enhancers than at promoters, indicating that distal regulatory elements are more dynamically regulated.
  • Nucleosome Dynamics: CRISPR-sciATAC can also reveal changes in nucleosome positioning around TFBSs, showing how chromatin remodelers influence the precise arrangement of nucleosomes, which is critical for gene regulation.

Key Results

  • Scalability and Efficiency: CRISPR-sciATAC can generate data from tens of thousands of single cells at a significantly lower cost and time compared to previous methods.
  • Low Doublet Rate: The species-mixing experiment demonstrated a low rate of doublet cells (cells incorrectly identified as a single cell), indicating good single-cell resolution.
  • EZH2 Perturbation: Loss of EZH2 led to a significant increase in chromatin accessibility at H3K27me3-marked regions and a nearly 3-fold increase in accessibility at the HOXA locus.
  • HOX Gene Expression: Following EZH2 loss, previously silenced HOX genes (e.g., HOXA3, HOXA5) became highly expressed.
  • Chromatin Remodeler Complexes: The screen identified two main groups of chromatin remodeling complexes: those whose loss generally increases accessibility (e.g., CoREST, NuRF) and those whose loss decreases it (e.g., CREST-BRG1, SWI/SNF-B).
  • ARID1A and Enhancers: Loss of ARID1A (a SWI/SNF subunit) specifically reduced accessibility at enhancers, not promoters.
  • Nucleosome Compaction/Expansion: Loss of certain remodelers (e.g., ARID1A) caused nucleosome compaction at AP-1 binding sites, while others (e.g., EP400) caused expansion.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Incomplete Knock-out: The authors acknowledge that CRISPR-driven gene perturbation might not always result in complete loss-of-function due to in-frame repair or variable guide RNA efficiency. However, they emphasize that their method looks for consistent effects across multiple sgRNAs.
  • Computational Methods for Perturbation Identification: Future work will involve developing more advanced computational methods to precisely discern perturbed cells from unperturbed ones, similar to those being developed for single-cell RNA-seq.
  • Broader Applications: The authors suggest that CRISPR-sciATAC can be broadly applied to study diverse phenotypes and diseases, and to understand the complex interplay between genetic changes and genome-wide chromatin accessibility. This includes investigating therapeutic resistance, cell proliferation, and Mendelian disorders.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Pooled CRISPR screens have been used to identify genes responsible for specific phenotypes and diseases, and, more recently, to connect genetic perturbations with multi-dimensional gene expression profiles. Here, we describe a method to link genome-wide chromatin accessibility to genetic perturbations in single cells. This scalable, cost-effective method combines pooled CRISPR perturbations with a single-cell combinatorial indexing assay for transposase-accessible chromatin (CRISPR-sciATAC). Using a human and mouse species-mixing experiment, we show that CRISPR-sciATAC separates single cells with a low doublet rate. Then, in human myelogenous leukemia cells, we apply CRISPR-sciATAC to target 21 chromatin-related genes that are frequently mutated in cancer and 84 subunits and cofactors of chromatin remodeling complexes, generating chromatin accessibility data for ~30,000 single cells. Using this large-scale atlas, we correlate loss of specific chromatin remodelers with changes in accessibility — globally and at the binding sites of individual transcription factors. For example, we show that loss of the H3K27 methyltransferase EZH2 leads to increased accessibility at heterochromatic regions involved in embryonic development and triggers expression of multiple genes in the HOXA and HOXD clusters. At a subset of regulatory sites, we also analyze dynamic changes in nucleosome spacing upon loss of chromatin remodelers. CRISPR-sciATAC is a high-throughput, low-cost single-cell method that can be applied broadly to study the role of genetic perturbations on chromatin in normal and disease states.
BibTeX
@misc{liscovitchbrauer2020scalable,
  author = {Noa Liscovitch‐Brauer and Antonino Montalbano and Jiale Deng and Alejandro Méndez‐Mancilla and Hans‐Hermann Wessels and Nicholas J. Moss and Chia-Yu Kung and Akash Sookdeo and Xinyi Guo and Evan Geller and Suma Jaini and Peter Smibert and Neville E. Sanjana},
  title = {{Scalable pooled CRISPR screens with single-cell chromatin accessibility profiling}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.11.20.390971},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure