Sampling Random Chordal Graphs by MCMC (Student Abstract)

Wenbo Sun, Ivona BezákováAAAI 2020 · DOI

Chordal graphs, characterized by the property that every cycle of length four or more contains a chord, represent a vital class of graphs in algorithmic research. Their unique structural properties allow for efficient solutions to otherwise NP-hard problems, making them indispensable in fields such as Bayesian network learning, computer vision, and database management. However, the development and testing of robust algorithms for these graphs require high-quality, unbiased test data. This paper, originally presented as a student abstract at AAAI-20, introduces a novel Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) method designed to sample connected chordal graphs uniformly at random, specifically addressing the need for treewidth-bounded samples.

The Problem of Bias in Graph Generation

A significant hurdle in evaluating graph algorithms is the lack of uniform samplers. Existing tools for generating chordal graphs often exhibit structural bias, favoring certain topologies over others. This bias can lead to skewed performance evaluations, providing researchers with a "false sense of security" regarding an algorithm's efficiency or accuracy.

Furthermore, while the computational complexity of many graph algorithms is directly tied to treewidth—a measure of how closely a graph resembles a tree—previous generation methods lacked the ability to strictly bound this parameter during the sampling process. Without the ability to control treewidth, researchers cannot effectively test how their algorithms scale with increasing graph complexity.

Methodology: The Simplicial Vertex Move

The authors employ an MCMC framework to navigate the state space of chordal graphs. The core of any MCMC algorithm is its transition rule, which must allow the chain to explore the state space while maintaining the desired graph properties (chordality and connectivity). The authors leverage the concept of simplicial vertices to achieve this. A vertex is considered simplicial if its neighborhood forms a clique (i.e., every neighbor is connected to every other neighbor). A fundamental property of chordal graphs is that every such graph is guaranteed to contain at least two simplicial vertices.

The proposed transition step involves the following process:

  1. Identify a Simplicial Vertex: Select a simplicial vertex $u$ from the current graph.
  2. The Move: Detach $u$ from its current neighbors and re-attach it to a new set of vertices $W'$, provided that $W'$ also forms a clique in the remaining graph.
  3. Treewidth Control: By limiting the size of the set $W'$ to a constant $r$, the algorithm ensures the graph stays within a specific treewidth bound.

By ensuring that the transition moves are symmetric, the authors utilize the Metropolis-Hastings framework to guarantee that the Markov chain converges to a uniform distribution. This means every valid graph within the specified constraints has an equal probability of being sampled, eliminating the bias found in previous methods.

Theoretical Guarantees and Results

The paper provides several key mathematical proofs regarding the performance and validity of the sampler:

  • Ergodicity: The authors prove that the Markov chain is ergodic, meaning it is theoretically possible to reach any valid chordal graph from any starting point using these simplicial moves. This ensures the sampler can explore the entire space of possible graphs.
  • State Space Diameter: The "diameter" of the state space is shown to be $O(n^2)$, where $n$ is the number of vertices. This indicates that any two chordal graphs are at most a quadratic number of moves apart.
  • Rapid Mixing for Trees: For the specific case of trees (which are chordal graphs with a treewidth of 1), the authors prove the chain "mixes rapidly." Specifically, it takes $O(kn \log n)$ steps to reach a random state (where $k$ is the number of simplicial vertices). This is a strong indicator of the algorithm's efficiency.

Conclusion and Future Work

This MCMC-based sampler provides a mathematically rigorous tool for generating unbiased chordal graphs, filling a critical gap in the toolkit for graph algorithm researchers. While the authors have proven rapid mixing for trees, the formal proof for the mixing time of general chordal graphs or those with higher treewidths remains an open challenge. However, the initial evidence and the ergodicity proof suggest that this method is a significant step forward in providing the unbiased datasets necessary for modern algorithmic benchmarking.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2020sampling,
  author = {Wenbo Sun and Ivona Bezáková},
  title = {{Sampling Random Chordal Graphs by MCMC (Student Abstract)}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1609/aaai.v34i10.7237},
}
Figure