Sampling Partial Acyclic Orientations in Chordal Graphs by the Lovasz Local Lemma (Student Abstract)

Wenbo Sun, Ivona BezákováAAAI 2021 · DOI

Introduction

In the fields of graph theory and artificial intelligence, acyclic orientations play a pivotal role, particularly in the structure learning of Bayesian networks. An acyclic orientation is an assignment of directions to the edges of a graph such that no directed cycles are formed. For Bayesian networks, specific types of orientations—such as v-structure-free orientations—are essential for representing causal relationships.

This research, presented by Wenbo Sun and Ivona Bezáková, addresses the computational challenges of sampling these orientations in chordal graphs. Chordal graphs are defined by the property that every cycle of four or more vertices contains a "chord" (an edge connecting two non-adjacent vertices in the cycle). Despite the structural advantages of chordal graphs, existing algorithms for sampling their orientations uniformly at random typically suffer from exponential time complexity relative to the graph's maximum degree.

The Challenge of Efficiency

The primary bottleneck in sampling acyclic orientations is the "rejection" problem. In standard rejection sampling, a random configuration is generated; if it contains even a single directed cycle, the entire configuration is discarded. In dense graphs or graphs with high degrees, the probability of generating a valid acyclic orientation by chance is vanishingly small, leading to exponential runtimes.

Sun and Bezáková propose a shift in focus: sampling partial acyclic orientations. In this model, edges can be directed in either direction or left undirected. By leveraging the structural properties of chordal graphs and the Partial Rejection Sampling framework, the authors aim to break the efficiency barrier.

Methodology: Partial Rejection Sampling

The authors utilize the Partial Rejection Sampling framework (Guo, Jerrum, and Liu, 2019), which is deeply rooted in the Lovász Local Lemma (LLL). Unlike standard rejection sampling, this method is "local": when a "bad event" (a directed cycle) is detected, the algorithm only resamples the variables involved in that specific event and their immediate neighbors in a dependency graph.

Algorithm Design

  1. Variable Assignment: For every edge $e$ in a chordal graph $G=(V, E)$, a random variable $X_e$ is assigned one of three states: direction $u \to v$, direction $v \to u$, or undirected.
  2. Identifying Bad Events: A critical insight of this work is that in a chordal graph, any directed cycle can be decomposed into directed cycles of length three (triangles). Thus, the algorithm only needs to monitor and eliminate directed triangles to ensure the entire graph is acyclic.
  3. Iterative Resampling: The algorithm identifies directed triangles and applies a specific resampling set until no directed cycles remain.

Theoretical Results

The core contribution of the paper is the proof of the algorithm's efficiency. The authors establish a threshold for the probability $q$ that an edge is directed to ensure fast convergence.

Theorem: If the probability $q$ of an edge being directed satisfies: $$q \le 0.24d^{-2/3}$$ (where $d$ is the maximum degree of the graph), the expected number of variable resamples is bounded by $O(|E| \log |V|)$.

This result is significant because it demonstrates polynomial-time complexity—specifically, linear in the number of edges and logarithmic in the number of vertices—under the specified distribution. The resulting orientation is sampled with a probability proportional to $q^k$, where $k$ is the number of oriented edges.

Discussion and Future Directions

While the algorithm provides a highly efficient path to sampling partial orientations, some hurdles remain. Currently, the sampler produces a distribution dependent on the number of directed edges rather than a strictly uniform distribution over all possible orientations.

However, partial orientations serve as a vital stepping stone. Because partial acyclic orientations can be easily extended into complete ones, this framework provides a foundation for future uniform samplers. The authors intend to explore whether this LLL-based approach can be adapted to sample v-structure-free orientations directly, which would have immediate applications in causal discovery and Bayesian inference.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2021sampling,
  author = {Wenbo Sun and Ivona Bezáková},
  title = {{Sampling Partial Acyclic Orientations in Chordal Graphs by the Lovasz Local Lemma (Student Abstract)}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1609/aaai.v35i18.17947},
}
Figure