Salting-out re-distillation combined with sensory-directed analysis to recover odor-active compounds for improving the flavor quality of instant Pu-erh tea

Chao Wang, Juan Li, Ya Zhang, Xuejiao Wu, Zhongrong He, Yin Zhang, Xingmin Zhang, Qin Li, Jianan Huang, Zhonghua LiuFood 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "salting-out re-distillation" (SRD) method to recover volatile odor-active compounds (OACs) lost during instant Pu-erh tea (IPT) production. By optimizing SRD parameters and integrating sensory analysis, the researchers significantly improved the flavor profile and aroma coordination of IPT, offering a more effective and cost-efficient alternative to existing methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The production of instant tea, including the popular Pu-erh variety, often leads to the loss of valuable volatile odor-active compounds (OACs). These OACs are crucial for the characteristic aroma and sensory quality of tea. Their loss not only diminishes the flavor of the final instant product but also contributes to environmental pollution through odorous emissions. Existing methods for recovering these compounds, such as membrane technology or oil adsorption, have limitations including high costs, short service life, contamination issues, and incomplete recovery. This study aims to address this gap by developing a more efficient, cost-effective, and environmentally friendly method to recover OACs specifically for improving the flavor quality of instant Pu-erh tea.

Methods

The core of this research lies in the development and optimization of a Salting-Out Re-Distillation (SRD) technique. This method leverages the principle of salting-out, where adding inorganic salts (sodium chloride in this case) to an aqueous solution reduces the solubility of organic compounds, facilitating their separation.

The process involves several key steps:

  • Initial Condensation: Pu-erh tea is soaked and then steam-distilled to recover an initial batch of condensed water rich in OACs. The soaking time and volume of this initial condensed water were optimized to maximize OAC release.
  • Salting-Out Re-Distillation (SRD): The initial condensed water is then subjected to re-distillation in the presence of sodium chloride. This step is crucial for further concentrating the OACs. The researchers systematically investigated and optimized several parameters for SRD:
  • Amount of Sodium Chloride: The concentration of NaCl was varied to find the optimal level for OAC release.
  • Recovery Volume of Condensed Water (SRD): The volume of condensed water collected during the SRD process was adjusted.
  • Re-use Times of Sodium Chloride: The study explored the feasibility of reusing the sodium chloride to reduce costs and waste.
  • Sensory-Directed Analysis: Throughout the optimization process, sensory evaluation played a vital role. This involved trained panelists assessing the aroma profiles and overall coordination of instant Pu-erh tea samples prepared with OACs recovered by different methods.
  • Analytical Techniques:
    • Gas Chromatography-Olfactometry (GC-O): Used to identify and characterize the perceived aromas of the OACs by trained assessors.
  • Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry (GC-MS): Employed for the identification and quantification of the OACs, using internal standards for accuracy.
  • Headspace Solid-Phase Micro-extraction (HS-SPME) and Liquid-Liquid Extraction: Standard techniques for extracting volatile compounds from samples.

For comparison, the study also evaluated the Reverse Osmosis Membrane (ROM) method, a common industrial technique for concentrating OACs.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilizes Pu-erh tea samples from Yunnan Tasly Deepure Biological Tea Group Co., Ltd. and various chemical standards for analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Salting-out is a powerful tool for OAC recovery: The addition of sodium chloride significantly enhances the release and recovery of volatile compounds from aqueous solutions, making it a highly effective technique for tea aroma recovery.
  • Sensory feedback is critical for process optimization: Integrating sensory analysis alongside chemical analysis allowed the researchers to not only quantify OAC recovery but also to ensure that the recovered compounds actually improved the desirable aroma attributes of the instant tea.
  • SRD outperforms membrane technology for Pu-erh tea: The study demonstrates that SRD is substantially more effective than the conventional membrane method for recovering OACs from Pu-erh tea, achieving significantly higher recovery rates for most compound classes.
  • Reusability of sodium chloride is feasible: The research shows that sodium chloride can be reused multiple times without a significant loss in recovery efficiency, contributing to the cost-effectiveness and sustainability of the SRD method.
  • Specific OACs are key to Pu-erh aroma: The paper details the identification of numerous OACs, highlighting specific alcohols, ketones, aldehydes, and methoxy-phenolic compounds that are crucial for the characteristic aroma of Pu-erh tea. Their effective recovery is directly linked to improved flavor.

Key Results

  • Identification of OACs: Forty-four odor-active compounds (OACs) were identified in Pu-erh tea, including alcohols, ketones, aldehydes, and methoxy-phenolic compounds.
  • Initial Distillation Recovery: In the first distillation step, 41 OACs were recovered with a total recovery rate of 83.94%.
  • SRD Recovery: Under optimized SRD conditions, 41 OACs were recovered with a total recovery rate of 72.29%.
  • Membrane (ROM) Recovery: The membrane method achieved a lower total recovery rate of 33.46% for 38 OACs.
  • Optimized SRD Parameters:
    • Soaking time: 3 hours.
  • Amount of sodium chloride: 30% (by weight of condensed water).
  • Recovery volume of condensed water (SRD): 6% of the first recovered condensed water.
  • Sodium chloride re-use: Up to six times with no significant loss in efficiency.
  • Sensory Improvement: Instant Pu-erh tea prepared with OACs recovered by SRD exhibited stronger intensities of desirable aroma attributes (stale/musty, woody, floral, fruity) and better aroma coordination compared to both original Pu-erh tea and tea prepared with OACs recovered by the membrane method.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Productive Application: While the study demonstrates the effectiveness of SRD, the authors acknowledge that further optimization of influencing factors and verification of the recovery process are needed for large-scale industrial application.
  • Cost-Benefit Analysis: A detailed economic analysis comparing SRD with other methods would be beneficial for industrial adoption.
  • Broader Tea Types: The study focuses specifically on Pu-erh tea. Investigating the applicability and optimization of SRD for other tea varieties could expand its utility.
  • Long-term Stability: Further research could explore the long-term stability of the recovered OACs and their impact on the shelf-life of instant tea products.

Summary updated

Abstract

The objective of this study was to develop an effective recovery technology of odor-active compounds (OACs) to improve the flavor quality of instant Pu-erh tea (IPT) based on their released behaviors. Salting-out re-distillation (SRD) combined with sensory-directed analysis was developed. The contributing factors, including the soaking time of tea, recovery volume of condensed water of first distillation, amount of sodium chloride, recovery volume of condensed water of SRD, and re-use times of sodium chloride, were studied systematically. Under optimized conditions, 41 OACs were recovered in the first distillation, and the total recovery rate was 83.94%. Forty-one OACs were recovered via SRD, and the total recovery rate reached 72.29%, significantly better than membrane method (33.46%). The IPT prepared by adding OACs that recovered via SRD showed strong aroma attributes intensities and good coordination. This developed method can provide a more effective scheme to improve the flavor quality of IPT.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2022salting,
  author = {Chao Wang and Juan Li and Ya Zhang and Xuejiao Wu and Zhongrong He and Yin Zhang and Xingmin Zhang and Qin Li and Jianan Huang and Zhonghua Liu},
  title = {{Salting-out re-distillation combined with sensory-directed analysis to recover odor-active compounds for improving the flavor quality of instant Pu-erh tea}},
  booktitle = {Food},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1016/j.fochx.2022.100310},
}
Figure