Salt Ion Diffusion Behavior and Adsorption Characteristics of Fracturing Fluid in Tight Sandstone Gas Reservoir

Xueping Zhang, Youquan Liu, Yuzhou Liu, Chuanrong Zhong, Pengfei ZhangEnergies 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates why fracturing fluids become highly saline when flowing back from tight sandstone gas reservoirs. Researchers found that while both KCl and polymers interact with the rock, KCl improves pore structure and permeability through electrostatic adsorption with clay, whereas polymers form films that hinder flow, offering crucial insights for optimizing fracturing fluid design in these challenging reservoirs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Hydraulic fracturing is essential for unlocking unconventional gas reserves in tight sandstone formations. However, a significant challenge is the high salinity observed in the flowback fluids, which is not fully understood. This salinity can impact reservoir performance and fluid recycling. The paper aims to elucidate the underlying mechanisms by examining how the rock's structure (composition, pore characteristics) influences the interaction with fracturing fluids, specifically focusing on salt ion diffusion and adsorption behaviors. Understanding these processes is critical for improving reservoir development strategies and mitigating potential formation damage.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted experimental approach:

  • X-ray Diffraction (XRD): To determine the mineral composition of the sandstone, particularly the clay content.
  • Linear Swelling Experiments: To assess the water sensitivity of the sandstone.
  • Low-Temperature Nitrogen Adsorption: To characterize the pore structure, specific surface area, and pore volume distribution before and after treatment.
  • Salt Ion Diffusion Experiments: Using a conductivity meter to monitor the diffusion of ions over time in samples of varying particle sizes.
  • Isothermal Adsorption Experiments: To study the adsorption behavior of potassium chloride (KCl) and acrylamide polymers on sandstone powder.
  • Fractal Dimension Analysis: Using the Frenkel-Halsey-Hill (FHH) model to quantify the complexity and irregularity of the pore structure.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilizes experimental data generated from laboratory tests on sandstone samples from the Shaximiao Formation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Clay is King (and Queen): The high clay mineral content (37.5%) in the Shaximiao sandstone is a primary driver of its water sensitivity and influences ion diffusion and adsorption.
  • Slow Diffusion, Long Haul: Salt ion diffusion in tight sandstone takes significantly longer to stabilize than self-imbibition, with diffusion rates showing a near log-linear relationship with time after imbibition equilibrium.
  • Particle Size Matters: Smaller particle sizes lead to higher initial conductivity but slower ion diffusion rates, suggesting a complex interplay between surface area and pore connectivity.
  • KCl vs. Polymers: Opposing Forces: While both KCl and polymers adsorb onto sandstone, their effects on pore structure are diametrically opposed. KCl enhances pore uniformity and permeability via electrostatic attraction with clays, whereas polymers create blocking films that reduce pore diameter and permeability.
  • Fractal Fingerprints: Polymer adsorption increases the fractal dimension (D2) of the pore structure, indicating increased complexity and reduced homogeneity, which correlates with decreased permeability. Conversely, KCl adsorption decreases D2, suggesting a more uniform pore network and improved permeability.

Key Results

  • The Shaximiao sandstone exhibits moderately severe water-sensitive damage with a linear swelling rate of 8.74%.
  • Both KCl and acrylamide polymers were effective in inhibiting clay swelling, with KCl showing a stronger effect at lower concentrations.
  • Salt ion diffusion stabilization took much longer than imbibition stabilization.
  • The adsorption of both KCl and polymers followed the Langmuir model, but their mechanisms and impact on pore structure differed significantly.
  • KCl adsorption was found to increase pore throat diameter and permeability by enhancing pore uniformity through electrostatic adsorption with clay particles.
  • Polymer adsorption was found to decrease pore diameter and form films that obstruct pore throats, leading to permeability impairment.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Scope of Minerals: While the study focused on the Shaximiao Formation, the findings might not be universally applicable to all tight sandstone reservoirs due to variations in mineralogy and pore structure.
  • Lab vs. Field: The experiments were conducted under controlled laboratory conditions. Scaling these results to complex field scenarios with varying pressures, temperatures, and flow regimes requires further investigation.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further research could explore the synergistic effects of different fracturing fluid additives, investigate the long-term impact of these interactions on reservoir performance, and develop more predictive models for ion diffusion and adsorption in complex tight gas reservoirs. Understanding the precise contribution of different clay types and their interactions with various ions would also be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

The degree of salinity in the hydraulic fracturing rejection fluid of the Shaximiao reservoir in the central Sichuan Basin is high, and the underlying mechanism causing this salinity is not clearly understood. We evaluated the rock structure of tight sandstone, including rock composition, pore structure, ion diffusion, and adsorption behavior, to determine how the rock structure influences the mechanism of the sandstone’s interaction with the fracturing fluid. X-ray diffraction revealed that the rock mineral fraction has a significant clay mineral concentration. The results of linear swelling experiments revealed that the water sensitivity of tight sandstone reservoirs exhibits moderately robust characteristics. The time required for salt ion diffusion stabilization is much longer than that required for self-imbibition stabilization, and the diffusion of salt ions is almost log-linear with time after imbibition stabilization. The diffusion rates of salt ions were determined for different single minerals and particle sizes, with clay minerals and particle sizes controlling the diffusion rates. The samples were treated with different concentrations of KCl and acrylamide polymer solutions, and both the pore size distribution and pore throat properties were characterized by low-temperature nitrogen adsorption. Although the adsorption isotherms of both KCl and polymers are consistent with the Langmuir model, their adsorption mechanisms acting on tight sandstone and the effect of adsorption on the pore throat structure are inconsistent. The adsorption of potassium chloride enhances the rock’s pore throat diameter and permeability by increasing the uniformity of the pore throat by electrostatic adsorption with clay particles. However, polymer adsorption reduces the pore diameter of the rock and forms a thin film that obstructs the pore throat, complicating the pore throat and weakening its permeability. This research has led to a greater comprehension of the ion diffusion characteristics of the tight sandstone in the Shaximiao reservoir and the adsorption mechanism on the pore structure of the rock.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2023salt,
  author = {Xueping Zhang and Youquan Liu and Yuzhou Liu and Chuanrong Zhong and Pengfei Zhang},
  title = {{Salt Ion Diffusion Behavior and Adsorption Characteristics of Fracturing Fluid in Tight Sandstone Gas Reservoir}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/en16062877},
}
Figure