Safety During Transient Response in Direct Current Microgrids Using Control Barrier Functions

Krishna Chaitanya Kosaraju, S. Sivaranjani, Vijay GuptaIEEE Control. Syst. Lett 2022 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel decentralized control strategy for DC microgrids that guarantees voltages and currents remain within safe operating limits during transient events, even when the exact load dynamics are unknown. By leveraging Control Barrier Functions (CBFs) within an optimization framework, the proposed controller ensures system stability and robustness against parameter uncertainties, a critical step towards reliable microgrid operation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

DC microgrids are increasingly important for integrating renewable energy sources and improving energy efficiency. A key challenge in their operation is maintaining stable voltage and current levels, especially during sudden changes (transients) caused by varying loads or disturbances. If these levels exceed safe bounds, it can damage equipment and lead to system failure. Existing control methods often struggle with this problem because they either require precise knowledge of system dynamics (like load values), which are often unknown or time-varying in real-world microgrids, or they lack a decentralized structure, hindering scalability and robustness. This paper tackles the problem of guaranteeing safety (voltage and current bounds) during transients in DC microgrids without relying on exact load information and while maintaining a decentralized control architecture.

Methods

The core of the proposed solution lies in the application of Control Barrier Functions (CBFs). CBFs are mathematical tools that can guarantee that a system's state remains within a predefined "safe set." The authors formulate the safety objectives (voltage and current bounds) as conditions on a function's super-level set.

The control strategy is designed by solving an optimization problem at each distributed generation unit (DGU) in the microgrid. This optimization problem aims to minimize the control input while satisfying constraints derived from the CBF conditions.

The paper presents a three-step approach:

  1. Guaranteed Objective 1 (Safe Voltage) with Known Load: A decentralized controller is designed using CBFs to ensure voltages stay within specified bounds, assuming the load is known.
  2. Guaranteed Objective 1 with Unknown Load: The controller is extended to be robust to unknown load values by using only known lower and upper bounds of the load. This is achieved by modifying the CBF constraints to account for these bounds.
  3. Guaranteed Objectives 1 and 2 (Safe Voltage and Current): The approach is further extended to simultaneously guarantee both voltage and current safety by jointly considering their constraints within the optimization problem.

The controller is decentralized because each DGU computes its control input using only local state information (its own voltage and current).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper uses a simulated DC microgrid with four buck converters for evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CBFs for Microgrid Safety: The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of CBFs, a tool traditionally used in robotics and safety-critical systems, for ensuring safety in power systems like DC microgrids. This opens up new avenues for applying advanced control theory to power system challenges.
  • Decentralized Control with Robustness: The proposed controller achieves decentralized operation, which is crucial for scalability and resilience in microgrids. Crucially, it does so while being robust to uncertainties in load parameters, a significant practical advantage.
  • Optimization-Based Safety: By framing safety as an optimization problem, the controller can actively steer the system away from unsafe states while minimizing control effort. This is more proactive than traditional reactive control strategies.
  • Handling Unknown Dynamics: The ability to guarantee safety even with only bounds on load parameters is a key contribution, addressing a major practical limitation in microgrid control.

Key Results

The paper presents theoretical guarantees for the proposed controller. Through simulations of a four-DGU DC microgrid, the authors demonstrate that their controller successfully:

  • Maintains voltages within the specified safe operating region (229.0 V to 231.0 V) despite an abrupt 5% load increase at t=0.25 seconds.
  • Keeps currents within their prescribed bounds.
  • The control inputs (duty ratios) remain within the physical limits (0 to 1).
  • The controller exhibits robustness to load variations, as shown by the simulation results.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumptions: The paper relies on several assumptions, including the availability of voltage and current measurements at each DGU, purely resistive transmission lines, and the existence of feasible control inputs.
  • Initial Conditions: While the controller is designed for feasible initial conditions, the simulations show that it can handle slight violations of these assumptions by using a modified optimization problem with penalty terms.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest extending this technique to handle more complex load models, such as ZIP (Constant Impedance, Constant Current, Constant Power) loads, and to achieve safe current sharing among DGUs. Further research into extending this to AC microgrids is also a natural progression.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider the problem of guaranteeing that the transient voltages and currents stay within prescribed bounds in Direct Current (DC) microgrids, when the controller does not have access to accurate system dynamics due to the load being unknown and/or time-varying. To achieve this, we propose an optimization based controller design using control barrier functions. We show that the proposed controller has a decentralized structure and is robust with respect to the uncertainty in the precise values of the system parameters, such as the load.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kosaraju2022safety,
  author = {Krishna Chaitanya Kosaraju and S. Sivaranjani and Vijay Gupta},
  title = {{Safety During Transient Response in Direct Current Microgrids Using Control Barrier Functions}},
  booktitle = {IEEE Control. Syst. Lett},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=vxLnXDlLcE},
}
Figure