Safety Assessment of Coastal Bridge Superstructures with Box Girders under Potential Landslide Tsunamis

Wanshui Han, Xin Xu, Jiajia Wang, Lili Xiao, Kai Zhou, Guo XuelianJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel framework for assessing the safety of coastal bridges with box girders against landslide tsunamis. By integrating a refined landslide-tsunami simulation model with a detailed structural safety evaluation, the study provides crucial insights into how bridge design parameters like elevation and support type influence resilience to these extreme events.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coastal bridges are vital infrastructure, but they are increasingly vulnerable to catastrophic events like landslide tsunamis. These sudden and powerful waves, triggered by underwater landslides, can cause severe damage, leading to the collapse of bridge superstructures. This not only disrupts transportation networks but also critically hinders post-disaster emergency rescue efforts. Existing research often simplifies tsunami generation or focuses on regular wave impacts, leaving a gap in understanding the complex dynamics of landslide-induced tsunamis and their specific effects on bridge components like box girders. This paper aims to bridge that gap by developing a comprehensive safety assessment framework that accounts for realistic landslide and tsunami behaviors.

Methods

The authors introduce a multi-component framework for safety assessment:

  1. Landslide-Tsunami Simulation (Tsunami Squares - TS): They employ a meshless numerical approach called Tsunami Squares (TS), which is adept at simulating fluid and solid motion. A key innovation here is the incorporation of a velocity-weakening basal friction model for landslides. This model, derived from experimental observations, better captures the energy dissipation and dynamic behavior of large, fast-moving landslides compared to traditional static friction models. This refined simulation provides more accurate tsunami wave height and velocity predictions.
  2. Wave Load Calculation: The predicted tsunami wave characteristics (height and velocity) are then used to estimate the maximum lateral and vertical wave loads acting on the box girder. This involves integrating empirical methods from previous studies, accounting for factors like wave overtopping and hydrostatic/hydrodynamic forces.
  3. Safety Evaluation Method: A finite element model of the bridge is used to compute bearing reactions under the calculated tsunami loads. The safety of the superstructure is then assessed by comparing these reactions to the bearing's capacity. A safety coefficient is defined based on the ratio of the applied load to the bearing's resistance, with values above zero indicating safety.

Datasets

The study utilizes:

  • Geographical and bathymetric data: Specifically, the GEBCO 2022 digital bathymetric model for the research area in the South China Sea.
  • Geological data for landslide scenarios: Information from previous studies on the Baiyun Slide Complex (BSC) is used to define three distinct landslide scenarios (BSC-1, BSC-2, BSC-3) with increasing thickness, area, and volume. These scenarios represent potential landslide conditions rather than specific historical events.
  • Bridge design parameters: Details of a continuous box girder bridge in southeast China, including its geometry, span lengths, and bearing specifications, are used for the case study.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Velocity-Weakening Friction is Crucial: The study highlights that modeling landslides with velocity-weakening basal friction significantly impacts tsunami generation. It leads to larger coverage areas and higher velocities, better reflecting the "superfluidity" of large landslides and resulting in more energetic tsunamis.
  • Tsunami Complexity: Landslide tsunamis are not simple single waves. The simulations show complex propagation patterns, including reflection and refraction, and the interaction with the bridge is influenced by the specific tsunami characteristics and the bridge's elevation.
  • Bridge Elevation Matters: Lowering the bridge elevation increases the vertical bearing reaction and makes the structure more vulnerable to lateral failure, especially for certain support types. A larger bottom clearance is recommended for enhanced safety.
  • Support Type is Critical: Hyperbolic spherical bearings (HSB) and direct contact (DC) offer relatively reliable lateral protection against tsunamis. Rubber bearings (RB) are deemed unsuitable for tsunami-prone regions due to their insufficient lateral restraint.

Key Results

  • Landslide Dynamics: The Baiyun Slide Complex simulations showed that landslides take about 3 hours to reach their peak and then decay. Velocity-weakening friction resulted in 2.44%–5.27% greater average velocity and coverage area compared to static friction.
  • Tsunami Dynamics: For the most severe landslide scenario (BSC-3V), the tsunami reached the bridge with a maximum wave height of 6.45 m and a velocity of 3.45 m/s. The velocity-weakening friction model consistently produced higher wave heights and velocities in the main propagation direction.
  • Bridge Safety: Under the worst-case tsunami scenario (BSC-3V), all bearings on the studied bridge maintained safety coefficients greater than zero, indicating no lateral displacement or vertical separation. The safety coefficients generally increased from the side spans to the middle spans.
  • Parametric Analysis:
    • Decreasing bridge elevation by 1.0 m significantly reduced the lateral safety coefficient. For instance, a specific bearing (B1-1) could experience lateral failure if the height decreased by more than 0.705 m.
  • The direct contact (DC) support type showed higher horizontal safety than the hyperbolic spherical bearing (HSB) at the designed elevation, but HSB performed better than DC when elevation was reduced by 1.0 m for one specific bearing.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The study acknowledges that the wave height at the bridge site did not always follow the stable pattern observed in the main propagation direction, potentially due to complex shallow water topography. The analysis of bearing safety coefficients was based on two specific moments in time (4.90 h and 5.51 h).
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring the impact of more varied vertical and lateral bearing types on bridge superstructure safety. Further research is also recommended to understand the effects of other extreme events like debris flows and to continue exploring the capabilities of the Tsunami Squares method for simulating large landslides.

Summary updated

Abstract

The superstructure of a coastal bridge is prone to overturn or unseating under a catastrophic tsunami, which seriously affects the post-disaster emergency rescue. In this paper, we establish a safety assessment framework for the superstructure of a bridge with a box girder under a potential landslide tsunami, and apply it to an in-service box girder and Baiyun Slide Complex on the southeast coast of China. First, a meshless numerical approach called Tsunami Squares (TS) is used to predict the movement of landslides and tsunamis. Additionally, we introduce the velocity-weakening basal friction effect in the model to optimize the landslide dynamics. Second, the maximum lateral and vertical wave loads on a box girder can be estimated using the time series of the wave height and velocity in the TS model. Third, we construct a safety evaluation method for the superstructure using the reaction of the bearing as the critical index. The results indicate that the framework developed here provides instructive guidance for evaluating the safety of coastal bridge superstructures during tsunami disasters, and we discuss the influence of the basal friction effect, bridge elevation, and support type on the structural safety.
BibTeX
@article{han2023safety,
  author = {Wanshui Han and Xin Xu and Jiajia Wang and Lili Xiao and Kai Zhou and Guo Xuelian},
  title = {{Safety Assessment of Coastal Bridge Superstructures with Box Girders under Potential Landslide Tsunamis}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse11051062},
}

Loading related content...

Figure