Safe Weakly Supervised Learning

Yu-Feng LiIJCAI 2021 · OpenReview

Abstract

Weakly Supervised Learning (WSL) aims to leverage incomplete, inexact, or inaccurate data to improve model performance. However, incorporating such "weak" data can sometimes lead to performance degradation compared to using only limited high-quality data. This paper reviews the "Safe WSL" framework, focusing on the SAFEW and DS3L algorithms. These methods provide theoretical guarantees that the resulting models will not perform worse than a baseline trained on strong supervision, even in the presence of out-of-distribution or noisy data.

Introduction

In traditional supervised learning, performance generally scales with the amount of labeled data. However, obtaining high-quality "strong" labels is often expensive or impractical. Weakly Supervised Learning (WSL) addresses this by utilizing incomplete data (semi-supervised learning), inexact data (multi-instance learning), or inaccurate data (noisy labels).

Despite the potential benefits, a critical challenge in WSL is the risk of "unsafe" learning, where the inclusion of weak data causes the model to perform worse than a simple baseline trained only on limited high-quality data. This degradation often stems from incorrect model assumptions or the presence of Out-of-Distribution (OOD) unlabeled data. This paper explores strategies to build "Safe" WSL algorithms that robustly improve performance or, at a minimum, "do no harm."

The SAFEW Framework

For scenarios involving in-distribution data, the SAFEW (Safe Weakly Supervised Learning) framework is proposed. SAFEW shifts the focus from optimizing average performance to a "maximin" optimization strategy that seeks to maximize performance gain in the worst-case scenario.

Instead of relying on a single weak learner, SAFEW generates multiple predictions from various base learners. The problem is formulated as a geometric projection: the algorithm takes a baseline prediction (derived from limited labeled data) and projects it onto a convex set formed by the base learners to identify the most reliable improvement.

Geometric projection in the SAFEW framework.

As illustrated in the figure above, the safe prediction $\bar{f}$ is found within the convex set $\Omega$ (defined by the base learners $\mathbf{f}_i$). The framework ensures that the distance to the ground truth $f^*$ is minimized relative to the baseline $f_0$, providing a mathematical guarantee that the SAFEW prediction will not be inferior to the baseline.

DS3L for Out-of-Distribution Data

When dealing with OOD data, where unlabeled instances may belong to classes not present in the training set, the DS3L (Deep Safe Semi-Supervised Learning) approach is employed. Unlike standard semi-supervised methods that treat all unlabeled data equally, DS3L utilizes a selective weighting function.

DS3L employs a bi-level optimization (or "learning to learn") strategy:

  1. Inner Loop: The model is trained using weighted unlabeled data.
  2. Outer Loop: The weights are optimized to ensure the model performs well on a small set of clean, labeled validation data.

By treating unlabeled data as potential "poison," the model effectively learns to ignore OOD instances that would otherwise cause performance to degenerate.

Theoretical Insights and Results

A key contribution of this research is the relaxation of conditions for success. Previous safe methods required the ground truth to be one of the base learners. In contrast, SAFEW achieves safeness as long as the ground truth can be represented as a convex combination of base learners—a significantly more practical condition.

Theoretical analysis (Theorems 2 and 3) demonstrates that the empirical risk of the DS3L model is never worse than a model trained only on labeled data. Furthermore, the DS3L approach establishes a generalization bound, converging toward optimal weighting at a rate of $O(\sqrt{d \ln(n)/n})$, where $d$ is the dimension and $n$ is the number of labeled samples.

Future Directions

While SAFEW and DS3L represent significant progress, several frontiers in Safe WSL remain:

  • Dynamic Environments: Adapting safeness guarantees to online, streaming data where distributions drift over time.
  • Scaling to Deep Learning: Extending theoretical guarantees from shallow models (like SVMs) to massive neural networks.
  • Imbalanced Data: Addressing the bias toward majority classes in real-world "long-tailed" datasets.
  • AutoWSL: Developing automated systems to select hyperparameters and architectures while maintaining safeness guarantees.

Summary updated

Abstract

Weakly supervised learning (WSL) refers to learning from a large amount of weak supervision data. This includes i) incomplete supervision (e.g., semi-supervised learning); ii) inexact supervision (e.g., multi-instance learning) and iii) inaccurate supervision (e.g., label noise learning). Unlike supervised learning which typically achieves performance improvement with more labeled data, WSL may sometimes even degenerate performance with more weak supervision data. It is thus desired to study safe WSL, which could robustly improve performance with weak supervision data. In this article, we share our understanding of the problem from in-distribution data to out-of-distribution data, and discuss possible ways to alleviate it, from the aspects of worst-case analysis, ensemble-learning, and bi-level optimization. We also share some open problems, to inspire future researches.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2021safe,
  author = {Yu-Feng Li},
  title = {{Safe Weakly Supervised Learning}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=Nc3iHD0lsZ},
}
Figure