Safe Linear Leveling Bandits

Ilker Demirel, Mehmet Ufuk Ozdemir, Cem TekinarXiv 2021 · arXiv

Abstract

Traditional multi-armed bandit algorithms focus on maximizing cumulative rewards. However, in critical domains like healthcare, the objective is often "leveling"—maintaining an outcome near a specific target while adhering to strict safety constraints. This paper introduces SALE-LTS (Safe Leveling via Linear Thompson Sampling), an algorithm designed to minimize regret relative to a target level while respecting two-sided safety bounds. Evaluated on a high-fidelity Type 1 Diabetes simulator, SALE-LTS demonstrates near-perfect safety and superior performance compared to standard clinical calculators and human experts.

Introduction

In many real-world applications, the "more is better" philosophy of standard bandits is inappropriate. For instance, in blood pressure management or insulin dosing, the goal is to maintain a physiological variable within a "Goldilocks zone." Deviations in either direction—too high or too low—can be dangerous.

Existing "safe" bandit literature often focuses on one-sided constraints (e.g., lower bounds) and reward maximization. This paper addresses two critical gaps:

  1. The Leveling Objective: Shifting the focus from maximization to keeping outcomes close to a target level $K$.
  2. Two-Sided Safety: Ensuring outcomes remain between a lower bound ($C_1$) and an upper bound ($C_2$).

A primary motivating example is Type 1 Diabetes management, where insulin doses must be precisely calibrated to avoid both hyperglycemia and life-threatening hypoglycemia.

Methodology

The authors propose SALE-LTS, which integrates safety constraints into the Linear Thompson Sampling (LTS) framework. The algorithm operates by maintaining a confidence region for the environment's parameters and restricting its actions to a "proxy safe set."

The SALE-LTS algorithm pseudocode detailing the construction of the proxy safe set and the leveling-based action selection.

Key Components

  • Proxy Safe Set Construction: At each round $t$, the algorithm computes a confidence region $\mathcal{C}_t(\delta')$ for the unknown parameter $\theta_*$. It then identifies a subset of actions $\hat{\mathcal{X}}_t^s$ that are guaranteed to yield outcomes within $[C_1, C_2]$ for all $\theta \in \mathcal{C}_t(\delta')$.
  • Leveling Acquisition Strategy: Unlike standard LTS, which selects actions to maximize expected reward, SALE-LTS selects the action from the safe set (or a small initial seed set $\mathcal{X}_1^{iss}$) that minimizes the distance between the predicted outcome and the target $K$.
  • Optimism in Leveling: In this context, "optimism" implies assuming there exists a parameter within the uncertainty range that allows the target $K$ to be hit exactly.

The authors prove that SALE-LTS achieves sublinear regret, matching the efficiency of standard unsafe LTS while maintaining strict safety guarantees.

Experimental Evaluation

The algorithm was tested using the UVa/PADOVA T1DM Simulator, an FDA-recognized high-fidelity model for postprandial blood glucose (PPBG) levels.

Setup

  • Subjects: 30 virtual patients (10 children, 10 adolescents, 10 adults).
  • Baselines: Standard formula-based "tuned calculators" and recommendations from human clinicians.
  • Metrics: Safe frequency (percentage of rounds within bounds) and Risk Index (distance from target).

Results and Discussion

SALE-LTS demonstrated exceptional performance across all categories:

  • Safety: The algorithm achieved a Safe Frequency of 0.999, effectively eliminating safety violations. In contrast, an unsafe variant (LE-LTS) had a safety frequency of only 0.756 in initial rounds.
  • Accuracy: SALE-LTS maintained blood glucose levels significantly closer to the target (112.5 mg/dl) than standard calculators.
  • Clinical Comparison: In experiments against human clinicians, SALE-LTS achieved a lower Risk Index (3.123 vs. 7.878), primarily due to its superior ability to avoid hyperglycemia without inducing hypoglycemia.

Inter-Contextual Learning

A significant finding was the algorithm's ability to perform inter-contextual learning. By modeling the patient's general response, the algorithm could generalize knowledge across different contexts (e.g., different meal sizes), leading to faster personalization than traditional trial-and-error methods.

Conclusion and Future Work

SALE-LTS provides a robust framework for safe leveling in linear environments. While highly effective in simulation, future work must address the linearity assumption, as real biological systems are often non-linear and time-varying. Additionally, the requirement for an initial "seed set" of safe actions remains a practical hurdle for entirely unknown environments. Moving toward in vivo clinical settings will require further robustness to real-world noise and unmodeled patient behaviors.

Summary updated

Abstract

Multi-armed bandits (MAB) are extensively studied in various settings where the objective is to \textit{maximize} the actions' outcomes (i.e., rewards) over time. Since safety is crucial in many real-world problems, safe versions of MAB algorithms have also garnered considerable interest. In this work, we tackle a different critical task through the lens of \textit{linear stochastic bandits}, where the aim is to keep the actions' outcomes close to a target level while respecting a \textit{two-sided} safety constraint, which we call \textit{leveling}. Such a task is prevalent in numerous domains. Many healthcare problems, for instance, require keeping a physiological variable in a range and preferably close to a target level. The radical change in our objective necessitates a new acquisition strategy, which is at the heart of a MAB algorithm. We propose SALE-LTS: Safe Leveling via Linear Thompson Sampling algorithm, with a novel acquisition strategy to accommodate our task and show that it achieves sublinear regret with the same time and dimension dependence as previous works on the classical reward maximization problem absent any safety constraint. We demonstrate and discuss our algorithm's empirical performance in detail via thorough experiments.
BibTeX
@misc{demirel2021safe,
  author = {Ilker Demirel and Mehmet Ufuk Ozdemir and Cem Tekin},
  title = {{Safe Linear Leveling Bandits}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2112.06728},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2112.06728},
}
Figure