Safe and dependable physical human-robot interaction in anthropic domains: State of the art and challenges

Rachid Alami, Alin Albu‐Schäffer, Antonio Bicchi, Rainer Bischoff, Raja Chatila, Alessandro De Luca, Agostino De Santis, Georges Giralt, Jérémie Guiochet, G. Hirzinger, Félix Ingrand, Vincenzo Lippiello, R. Mattone, David Powell, Soumen Sen, Bruno Siciliano, Giovanni Tonietti, Luigi Villani2006 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper surveys the state-of-the-art and challenges in safe and dependable physical human-robot interaction (pHRI) within human-centric environments. It argues for a paradigm shift from "rigid design for accuracy, active control for safety" to "design robots that are intrinsically safe, and control them to deliver performance," emphasizing mechanical design, actuation, and control architectures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As robots move beyond structured factory floors into everyday human environments (homes, hospitals, public spaces), ensuring their safety and dependability during physical interaction with humans becomes paramount. Current robots, often designed with a focus on precision and speed in isolation, can pose significant risks due to their inherent power and potential for unexpected movements. The challenge lies in developing robots that can coexist and cooperate with humans without causing harm, addressing not just the "brain" of the robot but its physical embodiment and interaction dynamics. This requires a holistic approach that considers mechanical design, actuation, control, sensing, and fault tolerance, moving beyond traditional safety standards that are often inadequate for shared workspaces.

Methods

The paper doesn't propose a single novel algorithm but rather surveys existing and emerging approaches to achieve safe pHRI. Key methods discussed include:

  • Intrinsic Safety Design: Focusing on reducing the inherent risk of the robot itself. This involves:
  • Lightweight Design: Using advanced materials to minimize manipulator inertia and weight.
  • Compliant Actuation/Transmission: Incorporating elements like harmonic drives, cable-driven systems, or series elastic actuators (SEAs) to decouple motor inertia from links and absorb impact energy.
  • Variable-Impedance Actuation (VIA): Dynamically adjusting stiffness, damping, and gear ratios to balance safety and performance during interaction.
  • Control Strategies:
    • Force/Impedance Control: Moving beyond pure position control to allow robots to react compliantly to contact forces, making interactions more natural and reducing injury risk.
  • Passivity-Based Control: Ensuring that the robot does not introduce more energy into the system than is strictly necessary, a key concept for safe interaction.
  • Reactive Motion Planning: Integrating on-line sensing and reactivity to adapt robot motion in real-time to unpredictable human movements and environmental changes.
  • Dependability Assessment:
    • Fault Diagnosis and Tolerance: Developing systems that can detect, isolate, and tolerate faults in sensors, control systems, and hardware to maintain safe operation.
  • Integrated Control Architectures: Designing modular, hierarchical, and real-time operating systems that can manage complex interactions and ensure consistent, adaptable, and robust behavior.
  • Safety Metrics and Standards: Discussing the limitations of current safety standards (e.g., ANSI/RIA R15.06) for shared workspaces and the need for new metrics that consider impact forces, energy transfer, and injury criteria (like HIC, MPI, MSC) tailored for robotic interactions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on surveying existing research and outlining future project directions rather than presenting experimental results on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Paradigm Shift Needed: The traditional approach to robot design (accuracy first, safety as an add-on) is insufficient for human-robot interaction. A new paradigm of "intrinsically safe design" is crucial.
  • Physicality is Key: While cognitive aspects of HRI are important, the paper emphasizes that the physical interaction is where immediate safety risks lie.
  • Beyond "Three Laws": Asimov's laws are a useful thought experiment, but practical robot safety requires concrete engineering solutions for mechanical design, control, and fault tolerance.
  • Dependability is Integrated: Safety, reliability, availability, maintainability, and integrity are interconnected and must be considered holistically for robust pHRI.
  • Human Perception Matters: Robots are often anthropomorphized, leading to user expectations that may not align with the robot's actual capabilities or safety features. This "mental model" needs careful consideration.
  • Standards Lag Behind: Existing safety standards are often geared towards industrial settings and do not adequately address the complexities of robots sharing unstructured human environments.

Key Results

This paper is a survey and a call to action, rather than a presentation of experimental results. Its key "results" are the identification of:

  • State-of-the-Art: A comprehensive overview of current research in intrinsic safety, compliant actuation, force/impedance control, and reactive planning.
  • Challenges: A clear articulation of the significant hurdles in defining safety metrics, developing robust control architectures, ensuring dependability, and establishing relevant standards for pHRI.
  • Future Directions: The paper highlights the goals of the PHRIENDS project, which aims to develop key components for next-generation intrinsically safe robots and establish new standards for collaborative human-robot operation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Lack of Standardized Benchmarks: The paper notes the general difficulty in defining benchmarks for service robotics and pHRI, making direct quantitative comparisons challenging.
  • Injury Criteria Limitations: While existing injury criteria (like HIC) are useful starting points, their applicability to robotic impacts (especially direct impacts and squeezing) needs further investigation and validation.
  • Integration Complexity: Combining mechanical design, advanced control, and robust sensing for truly safe and dependable pHRI remains a complex engineering challenge.

Future work, as outlined by the PHRIENDS project, will focus on:

  • Developing new actuator concepts and prototypes.
  • Creating dependable algorithms for human-friendly motion planning and control.
  • Integrating these components into experimental platforms for testing and evaluation.
  • Contributing to the establishment of new international standards for collaborative human-robot operation.
  • Exploring the use of AI for sensor fusion and decision-making in pHRI.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the immediate future, metrics related to safety and dependability have to be found in order to successfully introduce robots in everyday environments. The crucial issues needed to tackle the problem of a safe and dependable physical human-robot interaction (pHRI) were addressed in the EURON Perspective Research Project PHRIDOM (Physical Human- Robot Interaction in Anthropic Domains), aimed at charting the new "territory" of pHRI. While there are certainly also "cognitive" issues involved, due to the human perception of the robot (and vice versa), and other objective metrics related to fault detection and isolation, the discussion in this paper will focus on the peculiar aspects of "physical" interaction with robots. In particular, safety and dependability will be the underlying evaluation criteria for mechanical design, actuation, and control architectures. Mechanical and control issues will be discussed with emphasis on techniques that provide safety in an intrinsic way or by means of control components. Attention will be devoted to dependability, mainly related to sensors, control architectures, and fault handling and tolerance. After PHRIDOM, a novel research project has been launched under the Information Society Technologies Sixth Framework Programme of the European Commission. This "Specific Targeted Research or Innovation" project is dedicated to "Physical Human-Robot Interaction: depENDability and Safety" (PHRIENDS). PHRIENDS is about developing key components of the next generation of robots, including industrial robots and assist devices, designed to share the environment and to physically interact with people. The philosophy of the project proposes an integrated approach to the co-design of robots for safe physical interaction with humans, which revolutionizes the classical approach for designing industrial robots – rigid design for accuracy, active control for safety – by creating a new paradigm: design robots that are intrinsically safe, and control them to deliver performance. This paper presents the state of the art in the field as surveyed by the PHRIDOM project, as well as it enlightens a number of challenges that will be undertaken within the PHRIENDS project.
BibTeX
@misc{alami2006safe,
  author = {Rachid Alami and Alin Albu‐Schäffer and Antonio Bicchi and Rainer Bischoff and Raja Chatila and Alessandro De Luca and Agostino De Santis and Georges Giralt and Jérémie Guiochet and G. Hirzinger and Félix Ingrand and Vincenzo Lippiello and R. Mattone and David Powell and Soumen Sen and Bruno Siciliano and Giovanni Tonietti and Luigi Villani},
  title = {{Safe and dependable physical human-robot interaction in anthropic domains: State of the art and challenges}},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1109/iros.2006.6936985},
}
Figure