L. Nellen, Indira D. Vergara Quispe, Patricia María Hansen, Analisa Mariazzi, Diego D. Melo, P. Abreu, A. Albert, Ruben Jose Alfaro, Alexander Alfonso, César Álvarez, Qi An, E. O. Angüner, Cornelia Arcaro, R. Arceo, Sandro Arias, Horacio Arnaldi, P. Assis, H. A. Ayala Solares, Alena Bakalová, U. Barres de Almeida, Ivana Batković, J. Bazo, Jose A. Bellido, E. Belmont, S. BenZvi, Abel Bernal, Wenyi Bian, C. Bigongiari, E. Bottacini, P. Brogueira, T. Bulik, G. Busetto, K. S. Caballero‐Mora, P. Camarri, Silvina Campos, Wenyu Cao, Zhe Cao, T. Capistrán, M. Cardillo, E. Carquín, A. Carramiñana, C. Castromonte, J. F. Chang, Oscar Chaparro, Shangming Chen, Marco Chianese, A. Chiavassa, Ladislav Chytka, Roberta Colallillo, R. Conceição, Giovanni Consolati, Raúl R. Cordero, Pedro J. Costa, J. Cotzomi, S. Dasso, A. De Angelis, P. Desiati, F. Di Pierro, G. Di Sciascio, J. C. Díaz–Vélez, Claudio Dib, B. L. Dingus, Julia Isabel Djuvsland, C. Dobrigkeit, Luis Miguel Domingues Mendes, T. Dorigo, M. Doro, Alberto Corrêa dos Reis, Michael Du Vernois, Mauricio Echiburu, D. Elsäesser, K. Engel, T. Ergin, Fernando Espinoza, Ke Fang, Fernando Farfán Carreras, A. Fazzi, C. Feng, M. Feroci, N. Fraija, S. Fraija, A. Franceschini, Stefano Musso, S. Funk, Sayri Garcia, J. A. García-González, F. Garfias, Gwenael Giacinti, Lucio Gibilisco, Jonas Glombitza, Hazal Goksu, Guanghua Gong, B. S. González, Magda Gonzalez, J. A. Goodman, Minhao Gu, F. Guarino, Shivangi Gupta, Fabian Haist2023 · DOI
The Southern Wide-field Gamma-ray Observatory (SWGO) is an international collaboration working on a ground-based gamma-ray observatory that will be located in the southern hemisphere. A crucial step in the analysis is to identify the showers produced by gamma rays and separate them from the abundant background of hadronic showers. In this work, we propose to adapt the observable $S_b$ used successfully to composition studies in the Pierre Auger Observatory to the SWGO detector. This observable takes into account the signal and the position of each triggered detector. It characterizes the shape of the lateral distribution of the signal, which depends on the nature of the primary particle. The value of $S_b$ is therefore suited to identify gamma induced showers and to reject the more frequent hadronic showers. This analysis has been performed using a scaling factor to link the observable $S_b$ between the central and outrigger array. Also we explore how this new observable improves the separation of primary proton and gamma-induced air showers in terms of the merit factor.
Introduction
Ground-based gamma-ray observatories like the upcoming Southern Wide-field Gamma-ray Observatory (SWGO) do not detect gamma rays directly. Instead, they observe "extensive air showers" (EAS)—cascades of secondary particles triggered when a high-energy photon or cosmic ray interacts with the atmosphere. The fundamental challenge in this field is the overwhelming background: for every single gamma-ray signal, there are thousands of hadronic cosmic rays.
To effectively map the high-energy universe, scientists must distinguish between these two types of showers. While they appear similar, their "footprints" on the ground—the lateral distribution of particles—differ slightly. This paper explores the adaptation of the $S_b$ parameter, a metric originally developed for ultra-high-energy cosmic ray studies at the Pierre Auger Observatory, to enhance gamma/hadron separation for SWGO.
Methodology: The $S_b$ Observable and Scaling Factor
The $S_b$ observable is designed to characterize the shape of the lateral distribution of the signal. It is defined as:
Where $S_i$ is the signal at a detector station, $r_i$ is its distance from the shower core, and $b$ is a free parameter used to optimize the discriminating power.
The SWGO detector layout (left) and the lateral distribution of signals for proton vs. gamma showers (right).
A primary innovation in this work is the introduction of a Scaling Factor. Unlike previous observatories with uniform grids, SWGO features a dense central array surrounded by a sparse "outrigger" array. To prevent the $S_b$ value from being biased by the shower's location, the authors derived a scaling factor of 16 based on the ratio of detector densities. This allows the heterogeneous array to be treated as a single, normalized system.
Simulation and Performance
Since SWGO is currently in the design phase, the study relies on high-fidelity simulations using CORSIKA for air shower generation and a HAWC-based framework for detector simulation. The parameter $b$ was found to be dynamic, with optimal values increasing from 1.1 to 3.1 as the primary particle energy increases.
The $S_b$ observable showed excellent performance in separating gammas from protons, particularly in the mid-energy range:
Peak Performance: At energies around 10 TeV, the method achieved a Quality Factor (Q) of 11.3 and a Merit Factor (MF) of 1.55.
High Purity: At 50% gamma-ray efficiency, the proton contamination was as low as 0.2% for the best-performing energy bin.
Consistency: Most energy bins yielded a Q-factor greater than 3, indicating that $S_b$ is a reliable discriminator across a wide range of primary particle energies.
Conclusion
The adaptation of the $S_b$ parameter represents a successful cross-disciplinary application of cosmic ray physics to gamma-ray astronomy. While discrimination power slightly decreases at the highest PeV scales due to wider energy binning, the method remains highly effective for the TeV range. Future work will test the $S_b$ parameter against heavier nuclei backgrounds and incorporate more complex experimental noise profiles as the project moves toward construction.
Summary updated
Abstract
The Southern Wide-field Gamma-ray Observatory (SWGO) is an international collaboration working on a ground-based gamma-ray observatory that will be located in the southern hemisphere. A crucial step in the analysis is to identify the showers produced by gamma rays and separate them from the abundant background of hadronic showers. In this work, we propose to adapt the observable $S_b$ used successfully to composition studies in the Pierre Auger Observatory to the SWGO detector. This observable takes into account the signal and the position of each triggered detector. It characterizes the shape of the lateral distribution of the signal, which depends on the nature of the primary particle. The value of $S_b$ is therefore suited to identify gamma induced showers and to reject the more frequent hadronic showers. This analysis has been performed using a scaling factor to link the observable $S_b$ between the central and outrigger array. Also we explore how this new observable improves the separation of primary proton and gamma-induced air showers in terms of the merit factor.
BibTeX
@misc{nellen2023s,
author = {L. Nellen and Indira D. Vergara Quispe and Patricia María Hansen and Analisa Mariazzi and Diego D. Melo and P. Abreu and A. Albert and Ruben Jose Alfaro and Alexander Alfonso and César Álvarez and Qi An and E. O. Angüner and Cornelia Arcaro and R. Arceo and Sandro Arias and Horacio Arnaldi and P. Assis and H. A. Ayala Solares and Alena Bakalová and U. Barres de Almeida and Ivana Batković and J. Bazo and Jose A. Bellido and E. Belmont and S. BenZvi and Abel Bernal and Wenyi Bian and C. Bigongiari and E. Bottacini and P. Brogueira and T. Bulik and G. Busetto and K. S. Caballero‐Mora and P. Camarri and Silvina Campos and Wenyu Cao and Zhe Cao and Zhen Cao and T. Capistrán and M. Cardillo and E. Carquín and A. Carramiñana and C. Castromonte and J. F. Chang and Oscar Chaparro and Shangming Chen and Marco Chianese and A. Chiavassa and Ladislav Chytka and Roberta Colallillo and R. Conceição and Giovanni Consolati and Raúl R. Cordero and Pedro J. Costa and J. Cotzomi and S. Dasso and A. De Angelis and P. Desiati and F. Di Pierro and G. Di Sciascio and J. C. Díaz–Vélez and Claudio Dib and B. L. Dingus and Julia Isabel Djuvsland and C. Dobrigkeit and Luis Miguel Domingues Mendes and T. Dorigo and M. Doro and Alberto Corrêa dos Reis and Michael Du Vernois and Mauricio Echiburu and D. Elsäesser and K. Engel and T. Ergin and Fernando Espinoza and Ke Fang and Fernando Farfán Carreras and A. Fazzi and C. Feng and M. Feroci and N. Fraija and S. Fraija and A. Franceschini and Stefano Musso and S. Funk and Sayri Garcia and J. A. García-González and F. Garfias and Gwenael Giacinti and Lucio Gibilisco and Jonas Glombitza and Hazal Goksu and Guanghua Gong and B. S. González and Magda Gonzalez and J. A. Goodman and Minhao Gu and F. Guarino and Shivangi Gupta and Fabian Haist},
title = {{$S\_b$ for gamma/hadron separation in SWGO}},
year = {2023},
doi = {10.22323/1.444.0952},
}