TL;DR
This study investigates why rural residents in Southern Xinjiang, China, intend to participate in pro-poor tourism (PPT). Using the Theory of Planned Behavior, it found that residents' positive attitudes towards PPT and their perceived control over participation significantly drive their intention. Surprisingly, government support, despite being substantial, did not directly influence this intention, highlighting the importance of internal motivations for sustainable development.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Pro-poor tourism (PPT) aims to alleviate poverty by directly benefiting local communities. While its effectiveness is acknowledged, the sustainability of PPT hinges on the continuous support and active participation of the very people it's meant to help – the poor themselves. However, empirical research on the factors influencing the intention of these impoverished residents to participate in PPT has been limited. This paper addresses this gap by exploring the micro-level determinants of participation intention among rural residents in Southern Xinjiang, a region facing unique environmental and socioeconomic challenges. Understanding these drivers is crucial for designing more effective and sustainable PPT initiatives.
Methods
The study employs the Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB) as its theoretical framework. TPB posits that behavioral intention is shaped by three key components: attitude towards the behavior, subjective norms (social pressure), and perceived behavioral control. The researchers adapted this framework to investigate the intention to participate in PPT.
They conducted a questionnaire survey among 1012 rural residents in six National Pilot Villages of PPT in Southern Xinjiang. The survey measured:
- Attitude towards PPT: Beliefs about PPT's benefits (e.g., increased employment, income, life skills).
- Perception of support for PPT: Satisfaction with government and enterprise support (e.g., tourism materials, training, pioneer incentives).
- Participation behavioral control of PPT: Perceived ease or difficulty in participating (e.g., confidence in local resources, opportunities, industry fragility).
- Intention to participate in PPT: The primary dependent variable.
Statistical analysis was performed using the Ordered Logit Model (OLOGIT) and Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) regression to analyze the relationships between these constructs and control variables (like age, education, Mandarin level, and proximity to scenic spots).
Datasets
The study utilized data collected from a household survey of 1012 rural residents in six National Pilot Villages of Pro-Poor Tourism in Southern Xinjiang, China. The survey was conducted between October and December 2019. No new datasets or benchmarks were introduced.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Internal Motivation Over External Support: The most striking finding is that while residents' positive attitudes towards PPT and their belief in their ability to participate (behavioral control) strongly predict their intention, direct government support did not. This suggests that for PPT to be truly effective, it needs to tap into the residents' own desires for development rather than relying solely on external aid.
- The "Easy Refuge" Mentality: Despite acknowledging potential benefits, residents often prefer more stable, traditional livelihoods (agriculture, animal husbandry) over the perceived volatility of tourism. This "easy refuge" tendency, coupled with a lack of strong internal motivation for self-development, hinders their proactive engagement.
- Language as a Double-Edged Sword: A higher Mandarin language proficiency negatively impacted participation intention. This is counterintuitive, as language skills usually facilitate engagement. The authors suggest that better Mandarin speakers might be more discerning, weighing risks and benefits more carefully, and potentially preferring more stable, fixed-wage employment offered by government or management departments.
- Proximity Matters: Living closer to scenic spots positively correlated with a higher intention to participate, indicating that tangible proximity can foster greater enthusiasm and awareness of tourism opportunities.
Key Results
- Attitude towards PPT: Had a significant positive impact on participation intention (OLOGIT: 0.489, OLS: 0.220).
- Participation Behavioral Control of PPT: Also had a significant positive impact on participation intention (OLOGIT: 0.509, OLS: 0.224), being the strongest predictor.
- Perception of Support for PPT: Had no significant impact on participation intention in either model, leading to the rejection of Hypothesis 2.
- Proximity to Scenic Spot: Showed a positive impact in the OLOGIT model (0.065**).
- Mandarin Level: Had a significant negative impact on participation intention (OLOGIT: -0.087, OLS: -0.043*).
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Limited Scope of Variables: The study focused on three independent variables from TPB. Future research could incorporate other psychological theories (e.g., field theory) to identify a broader range of predictors.
- Convenience Sampling: The survey used a convenience sampling approach, which might introduce bias, although the sample size is relatively large.
- Generalizability: The findings are specific to the unique context of Southern Xinjiang and may not be directly generalizable to other poverty-stricken areas.
Future work could explore:
- Facilitators and Inhibitors: A deeper dive into both the factors that encourage and hinder participation intention.
- Activating Self-Development Needs: Investigating how to better motivate residents' internal drive for self-development, perhaps through exposure to successful tourism models in other regions.
- Government Investment: Recommending continued government investment in tourism infrastructure to improve accessibility and foster positive perceptions.
- Targeted Training: Emphasizing training that enhances participation capability, as behavioral control is a key driver.
Summary updated