Rural Living Environment Governance: A Survey and Comparison between Two Villages in Henan Province of China

Cuicui Xiao, Jingbo Zhou, Xingxing Shen, Jonathan M. Cullen, Susie Dobson, Fanran Meng, Xiaoxia WangSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates rural living environment governance in two villages in Henan, China, revealing significant differences in farmer satisfaction. The research highlights that effective grassroots government deployment and management are crucial drivers of satisfaction, offering insights for rural revitalization strategies in developing countries.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the critical issue of improving rural living environments, a key component of China's rural revitalization strategy and a global concern for economic development. While China has made strides in poverty reduction, the quality of rural living environments often lags behind urban areas. The study aims to understand how farmers perceive these improvement efforts and what factors influence their satisfaction, particularly focusing on the role of grassroots governance in less developed regions. The challenge lies in bridging the gap between government initiatives and actual resident satisfaction, especially in areas with limited resources and infrastructure.

Methods

The research employed a mixed-methods approach, combining structured interviews and participatory observation. This involved:

  • Field Investigations: Direct observation of the villages' living environments.
  • In-depth Interviews: Conducting face-to-face discussions with various stakeholders, including:
  • Farmers (differentiated by age, gender, and educational background)
    • Village cadres
    • Township cadres
    • Government staff
    • Staff of relevant environmental facilities
  • Questionnaire Surveys: Administering structured questionnaires to gather quantitative data on satisfaction levels.

The study categorized rural living environment improvements into six areas: sewage treatment, household waste treatment, construction waste treatment, toilet treatment, clean energy transformation, and village appearance. Satisfaction was measured using a standard Likert scale.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on primary data collected through field investigations and interviews.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Grassroots Governance is King: The study strongly emphasizes that the effectiveness of the grassroots government, specifically its capacity to deploy policies and manage services, is the most significant factor influencing farmers' satisfaction with their living environment.
  • Divergent Realities in Close Proximity: Despite being geographically close (only 3 km apart), the two studied villages exhibited vastly different levels of satisfaction and environmental improvement, directly linked to their differing economic development and governance approaches.
  • Economic Development Fuels Satisfaction: Villages with stronger economic foundations, often supported by government policies and industrial development (like D Village), tend to have higher levels of resident satisfaction with environmental improvements.
  • Beyond Infrastructure: Management Matters: While infrastructure is important, the study suggests that the management and deployment of services by local governments are more critical for achieving tangible improvements and resident buy-in.
  • The "Leading Goose" Effect: In D Village, proactive initiatives by the grassroots government, such as organizing village-wide clean-ups, served as a catalyst for further improvements and fostered a sense of collective responsibility.

Key Results

  • Satisfaction Disparity: D Village demonstrated extremely high satisfaction levels (100% overall), with an average Likert score of 5.0, while X Village had significantly lower satisfaction, with an average score of 2.9 and 27.3% of residents expressing strong dissatisfaction.
  • Government Effectiveness Scores: Residents in D Village rated government effectiveness much higher (4.79) compared to X Village (3.23). This pattern held across specific areas like environmental improvement and management (D: 4.84 vs. X: 2.23).
  • Specific Improvement Areas: D Village villagers reported very high satisfaction across all surveyed categories (e.g., domestic waste management at 4.95, village appearance at 5.00). In contrast, X Village saw lower scores across the board, with toilet manure treatment being particularly low (2.36).
  • Demographic Skew: The survey respondents were predominantly women in both villages, likely because men migrate for work, leaving women to manage household affairs and remain in the village.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Geographic Specificity: The study focuses on two villages in Henan Province, a major agricultural region. While it offers insights into underdeveloped areas, the findings may not be universally applicable to all rural contexts in China or other countries.
  • Focus on Grassroots Governance: While the paper highlights the importance of grassroots governance, it acknowledges that external influences and constraints also play a role. Future work could delve deeper into these external factors.
  • Need for Long-Term Mechanisms: The paper suggests that D Village's success in establishing a "leading goose" mechanism is a positive step, but emphasizes the need for more robust, long-term mechanisms for sustained improvement and a transition from government-led initiatives to widespread public participation.
  • Differentiated Policies: The authors recommend that governments adopt differentiated support policies and assessment indicators for rural human settlement environment improvement, recognizing the diverse regional characteristics and economic development levels. This suggests a need for tailored, rather than one-size-fits-all, approaches.

Summary updated

Abstract

Rural living environment governance is an issue of great importance in global economic development. It is also a significant facet of the rural revitalization strategy pursued by the Chinese government. Henan Province is a major agricultural province in the inland Central Plains region and is one of the most populous provinces in China. In this study, we take two villages in the underdeveloped areas of Henan Province in central China as case studies. We use field investigations and in-depth interviews to analyze the feelings of farmers in the case study villages towards the efforts to improve the rural environment, and explored the factors that affect levels of satisfaction with the rural living environment from the perspective of grassroots governance. The results showed that there were significant differences in the perceptions and satisfaction levels of rural residents in the two villages. The grassroots government has great influence over the rural human settlement environment, and its deployment capacities and management level are the key factors that affect overall levels of farmer satisfaction. China’s experience in improving rural human settlements provides reference for rural governance in other developing countries and regions around the world.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xiao2022rural,
  author = {Cuicui Xiao and Jingbo Zhou and Xingxing Shen and Jonathan M. Cullen and Susie Dobson and Fanran Meng and Xiaoxia Wang},
  title = {{Rural Living Environment Governance: A Survey and Comparison between Two Villages in Henan Province of China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su142114136},
}
Figure