Runner’s Perceptions of Reasons to Quit Running: Influence of Gender, Age and Running-Related Characteristics

Daphne Menheere, Mark Janssen, Mathias Funk, Erik van der Spek, Carine Lallemand, Steven VosInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates why recreational runners quit, finding that individual reasons like injuries are more common than social ones. Interestingly, factors like running experience, context, and personal attitudes towards running significantly influence these perceived reasons for quitting, offering insights for public health initiatives to retain runners.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Physical inactivity is a major public health concern, leading to increased interest in healthy lifestyles and the popularity of recreational sports like running. While running is accessible and beneficial, a significant number of runners, particularly novices, drop out. Understanding the perceived reasons for this dropout is crucial for developing effective strategies to encourage sustained participation. Previous research has explored motivations for starting running, but the specific reasons why runners quit, as understood by the runners themselves, remain relatively unexplored. This paper aims to fill this gap by examining the factors influencing these perceived reasons for quitting among short-distance event runners.

Methods

The study employed a quantitative approach using data from the Eindhoven Running Survey 2016 (ERS16). Binary logistic regression models were used to analyze the relationship between perceived reasons for quitting (dependent variables) and various independent variables. The dependent variables, "social motives for quitting" and "individual motives for quitting," were derived from survey items and then dichotomized based on their scale average. Independent variables included socio-demographic characteristics (gender, age, education), running habits (experience, frequency, context), and attitudes, interests, and opinions (AIOs) towards running.

Datasets

The study utilized a subset of data from the standardized online Eindhoven Running Survey 2016 (ERS16). This subset comprised 898 runners who participated in the 5 km and 10 km races. The ERS16 is a pre-existing dataset, and no new benchmarks were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Individual vs. Social Reasons: Runners are more likely to perceive individual reasons for quitting (like physical constraints or injuries) as more important than social reasons (like a trainer or running partner quitting). This is likely due to the prevalence of individual running contexts.
  • The "Runner" Identity Matters: Identifying strongly as a "runner" is linked to perceiving more social reasons to quit, suggesting that those who see themselves as real runners might be more reliant on their running community. Conversely, this strong identity is associated with fewer individual reasons to quit, possibly indicating greater resilience or experience in overcoming personal barriers.
  • Experience as a Buffer: More experienced runners (over 5 years) are less likely to perceive both social and individual reasons for quitting. This suggests that overcoming initial hurdles and developing self-efficacy through experience can significantly reduce the likelihood of dropout.
  • Running Context is Key for Social Reasons: Running in a group (friends, colleagues, small groups, or clubs) significantly increases the perception of social reasons for quitting, compared to running individually. This highlights the social dynamics inherent in group running.
  • Attitudes Shape Perceptions: Runners who don't view running as an easy sport or don't perceive its advantages are more likely to cite social reasons for quitting. This suggests that a lack of perceived personal benefit or ease might lead individuals to seek social support more actively, making them more susceptible to social dropout triggers.

Key Results

  • Physical constraints/injuries were the most important perceived reason to quit running (M = 4.14).
  • Female runners were more likely to perceive social motives for quitting than male runners (OR = 1.642).
  • Runners with more than 5 years of experience were less likely to perceive social motives to quit (OR = 0.610).
  • Runners who participate in running groups or clubs were significantly more likely to perceive social motives to quit compared to individual runners (OR = 3.352 for groups, OR = 4.541 for clubs).
  • Runners who identify with running were more likely to perceive social motives to quit (OR = 1.366) but less likely to perceive individual motives to quit (OR = 0.352).
  • Older runners (≥46 years) were less likely to perceive individual motives to quit than younger runners (<35 years) (OR = 0.498).
  • Runners with higher education or university degrees were more likely to perceive individual reasons to quit running (OR = 2.012 for higher education, OR = 2.721 for university).
  • Runners who run twice a week were less likely to perceive individual motives for quitting compared to those running once a week or less (OR = 0.654).

Limitations and Future Work

The study acknowledges several limitations:

  • Self-Reported Data: The reliance on perceived reasons means the findings reflect participants' subjective experiences, not necessarily actual reasons for quitting. However, understanding perceptions is key for intervention design.
  • Binary Variables: The dependent variables were dichotomized due to non-normal distribution, leading to a loss of information about individual differences.
  • Limited Items: The study used 7 items to construct the dependent variables, acknowledging that other reasons for quitting might exist. The selection was based on previous studies with acceptable internal consistency.
  • Focus on Novice/Less Experienced Runners: The sampling strategy focused on 5 and 10 km runners, who are more likely to drop out. While this is relevant for dropout research, it may not be representative of all runners.

Future work could explore these perceived reasons in more detail, potentially using qualitative methods to gain deeper insights. The findings suggest that public health policies and sports professionals can leverage this understanding of perceived reasons to develop targeted interventions to improve runner retention.

Summary updated

Abstract

Physical inactivity has become a major public health concern and, consequently, the awareness of striving for a healthy lifestyle has increased. As a result, the popularity of recreational sports, such as running, has increased. Running is known for its low threshold to start and its attractiveness for a heterogeneous group of people. Yet, one can still observe high drop-out rates among (novice) runners. To understand the reasons for drop-out as perceived by runners, we investigate potential reasons to quit running among short distance runners (5 km and 10 km) (n = 898). Data used in this study were drawn from the standardized online Eindhoven Running Survey 2016 (ERS16). Binary logistic regressions were used to investigate the relation between reasons to quit running and different variables like socio-demographic variables, running habits and attitudes, interests, and opinions (AIOs) on running. Our results indicate that, not only people of different gender and age show significant differences in perceived reasons to quit running, also running habits, (e.g., running context and frequency) and AIOs are related to perceived reasons to quit running too. With insights into these related variables, potential drop-out reasons could help health professionals in understanding and lowering drop-out rates among recreational runners.
BibTeX
@article{menheere2020runners,
  author = {Daphne Menheere and Mark Janssen and Mathias Funk and Erik van der Spek and Carine Lallemand and Steven Vos},
  title = {{Runner’s Perceptions of Reasons to Quit Running: Influence of Gender, Age and Running-Related Characteristics}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph17176046},
}
Figure