Rotation-based schedules in elementary schools to prevent COVID-19 spread: a simulation study

Cyril Brom, Tomáš Diviák, Jakub Drbohlav, Václav Korbel, René Levı́nský, Roman Neruda, Gabriela Kadlecová, Josef Šlerka, Martin Šmíd, Ján Trnka, Petra VidnerováScientific 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

By combining agent-based modeling with empirical social contact data, researchers demonstrated that weekly rotations between in-person and distance learning can reduce COVID-19 spread in schools by 75–81%. The study identifies teachers as critical "network bridges" whose high contact density makes them disproportionately responsible for transmission, while also showing that frequent, low-sensitivity antigen testing is nearly as effective as less frequent, high-sensitivity PCR testing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

During the COVID-19 pandemic, school closures were a blunt-force instrument used to curb viral transmission, but they came with severe costs to children's development and social equity. The challenge for policymakers was finding a "middle way"—strategies to keep schools open without turning them into primary engines of the epidemic.

While many models have explored school interventions, they often rely on synthetic data or simplified assumptions about how people interact. This paper addresses the need for high-fidelity simulations based on real-world social structures to evaluate the specific efficacy of rotation-based schedules and various testing regimes.

Methods

The authors developed a sophisticated Agent-Based Model (ABM) built upon a multi-layer graph structure.

  • Empirical Foundation: Instead of assuming random interactions, they used survey data from an elementary school in Prague (624 pupils, 55 teachers) to map ~27,000 social contacts.
  • Multi-Layered Contacts: The model uses 10 distinct layers to represent different types of interactions (e.g., sitting at the same desk, cafeteria lunches, after-school clubs, and teacher-to-teacher office contacts).
  • Epidemiological Engine: They applied a modified SEIR (Susceptible-Exposed-Infectious-Recovered) model to this network, differentiating between symptomatic and asymptomatic transmission.
  • Calibration: The model parameters were calibrated using real-world epidemiological data from the Czech Republic’s initial 2020 outbreak.

Datasets

  • Primary Dataset: A bespoke questionnaire survey conducted in a Prague elementary school. It captured the frequency and location of interactions among students (Grades 1–9) and teachers.
  • Epidemiological Data: Publicly available data from the Institute of Health Information and Statistics of the Czech Republic (IHIS CR) used for model calibration.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Teacher Bridge" Effect: Teachers represent only 8% of the school population, but their social network is an order of magnitude denser than that of the students. Because they move between different classes and share offices, they act as "bridges" for the virus. In secondary grades, teachers were responsible for 14–18% of infections—nearly ten times what a "naive" symmetric model would predict.
  • Age-Based Density: Older pupils (Grades 6–9) have contact graphs roughly 1.5 times denser than younger pupils, leading to faster transmission in secondary school settings.
  • Frequency Trumps Sensitivity: One of the most practical insights is that the frequency of testing is more important than the analytical sensitivity of the test. Antigen tests with only 40% sensitivity, if performed twice a week, were found to be roughly as effective as high-sensitivity PCR tests performed once a week.
  • Structural Intervention: Rotations work because they fundamentally alter the topology of the contact network, preventing the formation of long-chain transmissions that lead to large outbreaks.

Key Results

  • Rotation Efficacy: Implementing weekly rotations (half the school at home, half in-class) reduced the infection rate to 19–25% of the baseline (a 75–81% reduction).
  • Testing Impact:
    • PCR (1x/week): Reduced infections to 38–45% of baseline.
  • Antigen (2x/week, 40% sensitivity): Reduced infections to 43–48% of baseline.
  • Combined Measures: The "gold standard" of weekly rotations plus twice-weekly antigen testing (40% sensitivity) resulted in a massive 84–86% reduction in infections.
  • Class Halving: Dividing every class in half and rotating them weekly was even more effective than rotating whole grade levels, reducing infections to 13–15% of baseline.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Behavioral Assumptions: The model assumes "perfect compliance" with isolation and does not account for "compliance fatigue" or behavioral changes (e.g., students being less cautious after a negative test).
  • Variant Specifics: The study was calibrated on the original strain of SARS-CoV-2. While the structural insights remain valid, more infectious variants (like Delta or Omicron) would likely require even stricter measures to achieve the same percentage reductions.
  • External Environment: The model focuses on intra-school transmission and imports from the community, but it does not model how school-based infections subsequently spread back into households or the wider city.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest this framework could be adapted for other respiratory diseases, such as seasonal influenza, to optimize school operations during peak flu seasons.

Summary updated

Abstract

Rotations of schoolchildren were considered as a non-pharmacological intervention in the COVID-19 pandemic. This study investigates the impact of different rotation and testing schedules.We built an agent-based model of interactions among pupils and teachers based on a survey in an elementary school in Prague, Czechia. This model contains 624 schoolchildren and 55 teachers and about 27 thousands social contacts in 10 layers. The layers reflect different types of contacts (classroom, cafeteria, etc.) in the survey. On this multi-graph structure we run a modified SEIR model of covid-19 infection. The parameters of the model are calibrated on data from the outbreak in the Czech Republic in spring 2020. Weekly rotations of in-class and distance learning are an effective preventative measure in schools reducing the spread of covid-19 by 75-81% . Antigen testing twice a week or PCR once a week significantly reduces infections even when using tests with a lower sensitivity. The structure of social contacts between pupils and teachers strongly influences the transmission. While the density of contact graphs for older pupils is 1.5 times higher than for younger pupils, the teachers' network is an order of magnitude denser. Teachers moreover act as bridges between groups of children, responsible for 14-18% of infections in the secondary school compared to 8-11% in the primary school. Weekly rotations with regular testing are a highly effective non-pharmacological intervention for the prevention of covid-19 spread in schools and a way to keep schools open during an epidemic.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{brom2023rotation,
  author = {Cyril Brom and Tomáš Diviák and Jakub Drbohlav and Václav Korbel and René Levı́nský and Roman Neruda and Gabriela Kadlecová and Josef Šlerka and Martin Šmíd and Ján Trnka and Petra Vidnerová},
  title = {{Rotation-based schedules in elementary schools to prevent COVID-19 spread: a simulation study}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-023-45788-8},
}
Figure