Rossby waves and the PSA

T. Okane2017 · DOI

Abstract

This paper addresses internal inconsistencies in studies invoking WKB or ray tracing theory to explain correlations between the tropics and mid-to-high latitudes of the Southern Hemisphere. It specifically examines the role of stationary Rossby waves in the Pacific South American (PSA) pattern, highlighting seasonally dependent barriers to wave propagation that are often overlooked in mechanistic explanations of Antarctic climate variability.

Introduction

The relationship between tropical climate signals and Antarctic sea ice variability is a central theme in Southern Hemisphere climatology. A common explanation involves "stationary Rossby waves" propagating from the tropics to high latitudes. However, this commentary by T. O’Kane identifies significant internal inconsistencies in this narrative, particularly regarding the application of WKB (Wentzel–Kramers–Brillouin) theory and ray tracing in an atmosphere characterized by seasonally dependent barriers.

The Challenge of Atmospheric Barriers

A fundamental issue in invoking stationary Rossby waves is the presence of "reflecting surfaces" poleward of the subtropical jet. During much of the year (austral spring through winter), these regions act as physical barriers where the mathematical conditions for wave propagation fail. In these zones, the total wavenumber becomes imaginary, effectively blocking tropical waves from reaching the mid-to-high latitudes. Consequently, the theoretical "rays" often used in climate models to connect the tropics to Antarctica may be physically impossible under observed atmospheric conditions.

Internal Dynamics of the PSA Pattern

The Pacific South American (PSA) pattern is a key driver of Antarctic weather, including warming in the Antarctic Peninsula. While often linked to the El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO), recent research suggests this relationship is weak. O’Kane argues that the PSA is better described as an "internal waveguide instability"—a self-sustaining feature of the mid-latitude atmosphere driven by local jet stream instabilities. Most PSA variability occurs on synoptic to intraseasonal timescales, which are too rapid to be explained by slow-moving tropical forcing.

Causality vs. Correlation

The commentary emphasizes that correlation does not equal causation. While tropical signals are present in Southern Hemisphere variability, they likely represent only a small fraction of the total variance. Instead of direct wave propagation, the tropics may influence high latitudes by modulating the thermal wind components of mid-latitude jets. To prove causal links, researchers must move beyond simple correlations and utilize advanced methods like nonstationary nonparametric time-series analysis and dynamical mode theory.

Conclusion and Future Directions

To provide a robust mechanistic underpinning for Antarctic climate changes, future studies must account for the inherently unstable nature of the atmosphere. O’Kane calls for direct calculations of Rossby wave sources and wave activity flux, rather than relying on simplified wave theory. Understanding the PSA as a multiscale nonlinear dynamical mode is essential for accurately modeling the Southern Hemisphere's response to both tropical and local forcing.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper, has several internal inconsistencies in common with similar works invoking WKB or ray tracing theory to give a mechanistic underpinning to the correlation found between the tropics and mid to high latitudes of the Southern Hemisphere troposphere, largely in terms of stationary Rossby waves.The role of stationary Rossby waves in connecting tropical variability to the South Pacific and the Pacific South American pattern has been loosely applied in many studies, often without sufficient regard for the seasonally dependent barriers to stationary Rossby wave propagation of the type identified by Ambrizzi et al. (1995) and more recently reexamined by Li et al. (2015).In particular, it is well known from ray tracing C1
BibTeX
@misc{okane2017rossby,
  author = {T. Okane},
  title = {{Rossby waves and the PSA}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.5194/tc-2017-51-sc1},
}
Figure