Roles of Monkey Premotor Neuron Classes in Movement Preparation and Execution

Matthew T. Kaufman, Mark M. Churchland, Gopal Santhanam, Byron M. Yu, Afsheen Afshar, Stephen I. Ryu, Krishna V. ShenoyJournal of Neurophysiology 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This study challenges the prevailing "output-gating" hypothesis for movement preparation in the dorsal premotor cortex (PMd) of monkeys. By distinguishing between putative interneurons and pyramidal neurons, researchers found that interneurons are more active during planning and movement, not less, suggesting that inhibition doesn't simply "gate" output in the way previously theorized.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The dorsal premotor cortex (PMd) is known to be crucial for both planning and executing movements, particularly reaching. A key puzzle is how PMd neurons can exhibit "plan activity" – neural firing patterns that predict an upcoming movement – without actually triggering that movement prematurely. A leading hypothesis, inspired by findings in the oculomotor system, proposed an "output-gating" mechanism. This theory suggests that inhibitory interneurons act like a gate, suppressing the output of PMd neurons during the planning phase and then releasing this inhibition when it's time to move. The authors sought to test this hypothesis by examining the activity of different neuron types within PMd during a delayed reach task.

Methods

The core of this study lies in its ability to differentiate between two main classes of neurons in PMd: putative interneurons and putative pyramidal neurons. This distinction was made using extracellular recordings and analyzing spike waveform durations, specifically the trough-to-peak (TTP) duration. This method, previously established in other brain areas, was extended for use with chronically implanted multi-electrode arrays. The researchers then recorded neural activity from two monkeys performing delayed reach tasks while distinguishing these neuron types. They analyzed peristimulus time histograms (PSTHs) and cross-condition modulation patterns to compare the firing behaviors of interneurons and pyramidal neurons during the planning and movement phases.

Datasets

The study utilized neural recordings from two adult male macaque monkeys performing delayed reach tasks. No new datasets were introduced; rather, existing behavioral paradigms were employed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Interneurons are not the "off switch" for movement preparation: Contrary to the output-gating hypothesis, putative interneurons in PMd were found to be more active, not less, during both the planning and movement epochs. This directly challenges the idea that inhibition is simply turned down to allow movement.
  • Asymmetric firing patterns: Putative interneurons showed a stronger tendency to increase their firing rates during planning and movement compared to pyramidal neurons, which exhibited more symmetric increases and decreases in firing across conditions.
  • Cross-condition modulation differences: Interneurons demonstrated greater modulation across different movement conditions (e.g., reach directions) than pyramidal neurons, suggesting a more dynamic role in representing movement parameters.
  • No clear "pause-like" interneuron subset: The hypothesis that a specific subset of interneurons might pause during movement to enable gating was not supported. The distribution of activity patterns across interneurons was unimodal, not showing a distinct group of pause-like cells.
  • Complex gating mechanisms: The findings suggest that the control of movement preparation in PMd is likely more complex than a simple inhibitory gate. Alternative mechanisms, such as dynamical systems or feedforward inhibition downstream of PMd, are proposed.

Key Results

  • Putative interneurons showed significantly higher firing rates during both the planning and movement epochs compared to putative pyramidal neurons.
  • Interneurons were more likely to exhibit increases in firing rate during planning and movement, while pyramidal neurons showed a more balanced pattern of increases and decreases.
  • Cross-condition modulation was stronger in interneurons, indicating they were more sensitive to variations in movement parameters.
  • The correlation between plan-period and movement-period modulation patterns was generally low and not consistently inverted for either neuron class, further weakening the output-gating hypothesis.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their classification of neurons as "putative" interneurons and pyramidal neurons relies on waveform characteristics, which, while reliable, are not a direct measure of inhibitory or excitatory function. They also note that the precise localization of their recordings within PMd could be further refined with histology.

Future work could focus on:

  • Investigating downstream areas like primary motor cortex (M1) for potential feedforward inhibition mechanisms.
  • Exploring dynamical systems and feedback-control frameworks to explain how PMd activity can be prevalent without causing premature movement.
  • Developing more direct methods to confirm the inhibitory/excitatory nature of these neuron classes in PMd.
  • Testing the output-gating hypothesis in other motor control circuits.

Summary updated

Abstract

Dorsal premotor cortex (PMd) is known to be involved in the planning and execution of reaching movements. However, it is not understood how PMd plan activity-often present in the very same neurons that respond during movement-is prevented from itself producing movement. We investigated whether inhibitory interneurons might "gate" output from PMd, by maintaining high levels of inhibition during planning and reducing inhibition during execution. Recently developed methods permit distinguishing interneurons from pyramidal neurons using extracellular recordings. We extend these methods here for use with chronically implanted multi-electrode arrays. We then applied these methods to single- and multi-electrode recordings in PMd of two monkeys performing delayed-reach tasks. Responses of putative interneurons were not generally in agreement with the hypothesis that they act to gate output from the area: in particular it was not the case that interneurons tended to reduce their firing rates around the time of movement. In fact, interneurons increased their rates more than putative pyramidal neurons during both the planning and movement epochs. The two classes of neurons also differed in a number of other ways, including greater modulation across conditions for interneurons, and interneurons more frequently exhibiting increases in firing rate during movement planning and execution. These findings provide novel information about the greater responsiveness of putative PMd interneurons in motor planning and execution and suggest that we may need to consider new possibilities for how planning activity is structured such that it does not itself produce movement.
BibTeX
@article{kaufman2010roles,
  author = {Matthew T. Kaufman and Mark M. Churchland and Gopal Santhanam and Byron M. Yu and Afsheen Afshar and Stephen I. Ryu and Krishna V. Shenoy},
  title = {{Roles of Monkey Premotor Neuron Classes in Movement Preparation and Execution}},
  journal = {Journal of Neurophysiology},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1152/jn.00231.2009},
}
Figure