Roles and Functions of Supervisors: Impact on the Learning Outcomes of Professional Engineering Doctoral Students

Yingqian Zhang, Jiabin Zhu, Wanqi Li9th 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Professional engineering doctorate (Eng.D.) programs were established to meet the rising demand for application-oriented, industry-based technical leaders. Unlike traditional research-oriented Ph.D. programs, the Eng.D. focuses on solving real-world industrial problems. This study investigates the mentoring relationship between supervisors and Eng.D. students at a leading Chinese research university, exploring how mentoring practices impact learning outcomes for students who are often full-time industry professionals.

Introduction

The landscape of engineering education is undergoing a significant shift. While the traditional Ph.D. focuses on frontier academic research, the Professional Engineering Doctorate (Eng.D.) aims to produce high-level technical leaders capable of bridging the gap between academia and industry. However, a significant challenge persists: many academic supervisors treat Eng.D. students identically to traditional Ph.D. candidates. This "homogenized" mentoring often fails to account for the unique professional status and practical needs of Eng.D. students, who typically hold leadership positions in industry while studying part-time.

Methodology

This study employed a mixed-methods approach at "University H," a research-intensive institution in China.

  • Quantitative Phase: A survey was distributed to first-year Eng.D. students across seven engineering schools, including Aerospace, Mechanical, and Biomedical engineering. The researchers received 66 valid responses from a cohort of 100 students.
  • Qualitative Phase: To capture the nuances of the mentoring relationship, the team conducted one-on-one interviews with 31 students (20 first-year and 11 second-year). These interviews focused on mentoring frequency, content delivery, and the specific value provided by supervisors.

Key Results

The quantitative data revealed a high level of overall satisfaction among the student cohort. On average, students reported an 87% satisfaction rate with their supervisors. As shown in the survey data, the vast majority of students felt their supervisors demonstrated strong professional ethics and were accessible for communication.

Survey results showing high levels of student agreement regarding supervisor professionalism and communication.

Despite the high satisfaction scores, qualitative interviews revealed a divide in how mentoring is perceived as students progress. While first-year students are often focused on coursework, second-year students begin to integrate into research groups. Approximately half of the second-year interviewees felt their mentoring was indistinguishable from a Ph.D. track, while the other half noted that their supervisors successfully adapted their guidance to be more industry-focused and multifaceted.

Discussion: The Supervisor as a Bridge

Eng.D. students serve as vital "industry-academic liaisons." Effective supervisors recognize this dual role and provide resources that benefit the student’s corporate projects rather than just their academic thesis. Key insights from the study include:

  • Frequency vs. Flexibility: Eng.D. students value a "low-frequency, high-impact" mentoring model. Because they balance full-time careers with doctoral studies, they prioritize supervisors who respect their work-life-study balance over those who demand rigid, daily attendance.
  • Practicality over Theory: The most satisfied students were those whose supervisors provided technical advice and practical problem-solving strategies directly relevant to their industrial roles.
  • The Dual Supervisor System: Although China utilizes a dual system (one academic and one industrial supervisor), the academic supervisor still bears the primary pressure of ensuring the student meets rigorous research standards while maintaining industrial relevance.

Conclusion and Future Work

While current mentoring practices at University H are generally well-received, there is a clear need for supervisors to move away from a "one-size-fits-all" academic approach. Future research should expand the sample size across more diverse engineering disciplines and include the perspective of enterprise supervisors to better understand how the dual-mentoring system functions in practice. Longitudinal studies following students through to graduation will also be essential to determine how the supervisor's role evolves during the final dissertation phase.

Summary updated

Abstract

Professional engineering doctorate degree programs (awarding a Doctor of Engineering degree, Eng.D.) was established in response to an increased demand for application-oriented, strong industrial-based high-level technical personnel, which is different from the aims of the research-oriented degree programs (offering a Doctor of Philosophy, Ph.D.). For the development of professional engineering doctoral students, the professional ability, mentoring skills and attitudes of
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2022roles,
  author = {Yingqian Zhang and Jiabin Zhu and Wanqi Li},
  title = {{Roles and Functions of Supervisors: Impact on the Learning Outcomes of Professional Engineering Doctoral Students}},
  booktitle = {9th},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.52202/066488-0120},
}
Figure