Role of MdERF3 and MdERF118 natural variations in apple flesh firmness/crispness retainability and development of QTL‐based genomics‐assisted prediction

Bei Wu, Fei Shen, Xuan Wang, Wen Yan Zheng, Chen Xiao, Yang Deng, Ting Wang, Zhen Yu Huang, Qian Zhou, Yi Wang, Ting Wu, Xue Feng Xu, Zhen Han, Xin Zhong ZhangPlant 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study identifies key genetic variations in apple's MdERF3 and MdERF118 genes that significantly impact flesh firmness and crispness retention during storage. By developing genomics-assisted prediction (GAP) models, the researchers achieved promising accuracy in predicting these traits, offering a valuable tool for accelerating apple breeding programs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Maintaining desirable flesh texture—firmness and crispness—in apples after harvest is crucial for consumer satisfaction and extending shelf life. However, the genetic underpinnings of how apples retain these qualities during cold storage are not fully understood. Traditional breeding methods for these complex, polygenic traits are slow and inefficient. This paper aims to bridge this knowledge gap by identifying specific genetic markers associated with flesh texture retention and developing a predictive model to aid in breeding efforts.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Bulked Segregant Analysis sequencing (BSA-seq): This technique was used to identify quantitative trait loci (QTLs) associated with flesh firmness and crispness retainability by comparing DNA from groups of individuals with extreme phenotypes.
  • RNA-sequencing (RNA-seq): This was used to identify differentially expressed genes (DEGs) between different phenotype groups, providing insights into the molecular mechanisms at play.
  • Candidate Gene Prediction: By integrating BSA-seq and RNA-seq data with parental re-sequencing, the study pinpointed candidate genes within QTL intervals.
  • Genomics-Assisted Prediction (GAP) Modeling: This involved pyramiding marker genotype effects from identified QTLs to predict phenotype values.
  • Functional Validation: Techniques like yeast one-hybrid (Y1H) assays, electrophoretic mobility shift assays (EMSA), transient expression in tobacco, and virus-induced gene silencing (VIGS) were used to confirm the roles of candidate genes (MdERF3 and MdERF118) and their interactions.

Datasets

The study utilized phenotype data from 2,664 F1 hybrids derived from crosses between Malus domestica cultivars ('Red Fuji', 'Golden Delicious', 'Jonathan') and Malus asiatica ('Zisai Pearl') collected over two years (2016-2017). Genotype data was generated through BSA-seq and parental re-sequencing. RNA-seq data was also collected from fruit samples at various time points during cold storage.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Specific Gene Variants Drive Texture Retention: The discovery of an 8-bp deletion in the MdERF3 promoter and a 3-bp deletion in the MdERF118 promoter as key drivers of reduced flesh firmness and crispness retainability is a significant finding. These deletions appear to disrupt binding sites for regulatory proteins, leading to altered expression of downstream genes involved in fruit softening.
  • Complex Regulatory Network: The study highlights a sophisticated genetic network involving ethylene biosynthesis and signaling, cell wall degradation, and other phytohormones, all contributing to flesh texture. The interaction between MdERF3 and MdERF118 further underscores this complexity.
  • Crispness as a Prerequisite: The data suggests that maintaining flesh firmness might be a prerequisite for achieving long-term crispness retainability, indicating a hierarchical relationship between these two traits.
  • GAP Models Show Promise: The development of genomics-assisted prediction models demonstrates a practical application of genetic insights for breeding, offering a more efficient alternative to traditional methods.

Key Results

  • High Heritability: Flesh firmness and crispness retainability exhibited high broad-sense heritability (83.85% and 83.64%, respectively).
  • QTL Identification: 62 QTLs were identified for flesh firmness and crispness retainability, with significant overlaps on chromosomes 3 and 16.
  • Candidate Genes Identified: MdERF3 and MdERF118 were identified as key candidate genes.
  • Promoter Deletions Impact Gene Expression: An 8-bp deletion in MdERF3's promoter disrupted MdDOF5.3 binding, reducing MdERF3 expression and consequently affecting downstream genes. A 3-bp deletion in MdERF118's promoter disrupted MdRAVL1 binding, also reducing MdERF118 expression.
  • GAP Model Accuracy: Fivefold cross-validation yielded prediction accuracies of 0.5541 for flesh firmness retainability and 0.6018 for crispness retainability.
  • Simulative Selection Efficiency: The GAP models showed potential for efficient simulative selection, with high accuracy in identifying desirable hybrids.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Non-additive Effects: While the GAP models showed good accuracy, the paper notes that pure genomic selection (GS) models neglect non-additive allelic effects and epistasis, which can be important in outcrossing species. The developed GAP models aim to incorporate some of these effects.
  • Further Validation: While functional validation was performed for MdERF3 and MdERF118, further investigation into the broader genetic network and the precise mechanisms of interaction between all identified candidate genes would be beneficial.
  • Broader Application: The study focused on specific hybrid populations. Expanding the validation of GAP models across a wider range of apple germplasm and different environmental conditions would strengthen their applicability.
  • Breeding Implementation: The authors suggest that these GAP models can assist in apple breeding, implying future work will involve their direct application in breeding programs to accelerate the development of apple varieties with improved storage quality.

Summary updated

Abstract

Retention of flesh texture attributes during cold storage is critical for the long-term maintenance of fruit quality. The genetic variations determining flesh firmness and crispness retainability are not well understood. The objectives of this study are to identify gene markers based on quantitative trait loci (QTLs) and to develop genomics-assisted prediction (GAP) models for apple flesh firmness and crispness retainability. Phenotype data of 2664 hybrids derived from three Malus domestica cultivars and a M. asiatica cultivar were collected in 2016 and 2017. The phenotype segregated considerably with high broad-sense heritability of 83.85% and 83.64% for flesh firmness and crispness retainability, respectively. Fifty-six candidate genes were predicted from the 62 QTLs identified using bulked segregant analysis and RNA-seq. The genotype effects of the markers designed on each candidate gene were estimated. The genomics-predicted values were obtained using pyramiding marker genotype effects and overall mean phenotype values. Fivefold cross-validation revealed that the prediction accuracy was 0.5541 and 0.6018 for retainability of flesh firmness and crispness, respectively. An 8-bp deletion in the MdERF3 promoter disrupted MdDOF5.3 binding, reduced MdERF3 expression, relieved the inhibition on MdPGLR3, MdPME2, and MdACO4 expression, and ultimately decreased flesh firmness and crispness retainability. A 3-bp deletion in the MdERF118 promoter decreased its expression by disrupting the binding of MdRAVL1, which increased MdPGLR3 and MdACO4 expression and reduced flesh firmness and crispness retainability. These results provide insights regarding the genetic variation network regulating flesh firmness and crispness retainability, and the GAP models can assist in apple breeding.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2020role,
  author = {Bei Wu and Fei Shen and Xuan Wang and Wen Yan Zheng and Chen Xiao and Yang Deng and Ting Wang and Zhen Yu Huang and Qian Zhou and Yi Wang and Ting Wu and Xue Feng Xu and Zhen Han and Xin Zhong Zhang},
  title = {{Role of <i>MdERF3</i> and <i>MdERF118</i> natural variations in apple flesh firmness/crispness retainability and development of QTL‐based genomics‐assisted prediction}},
  booktitle = {Plant},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1111/pbi.13527},
}
Figure