Robustness of tripartite entangled states in passive PT-symmetric qubits

Chimdessa Gashu Feyisa, Chengyu Liu, Muhammad S. Hasan, J. S. You, Huan-Yu Ku, H. H. JenarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have demonstrated that non-Hermitian quantum systems, specifically those with "passive PT-symmetry," can generate complex tripartite entangled states (GHZ and W states) significantly faster than traditional Hermitian systems. These states prove remarkably robust against common experimental imperfections like non-uniform coupling strengths and off-resonant driving, provided the system operates near a mathematical singularity known as an Exceptional Point (EP).

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Entanglement is the "secret sauce" of quantum computing, but creating and maintaining it is notoriously difficult. In standard (Hermitian) quantum mechanics, generating entanglement between three or more qubits is often slow, leaving the system vulnerable to decoherence.

Recently, physicists have turned to non-Hermitian systems—systems that exchange energy with their environment (loss and gain). These systems possess unique features called Exceptional Points (EPs), where the system's energy levels and their corresponding states "coalesce" or merge into one. While EPs are known to accelerate entanglement, we didn't fully understand how robust these states are when the experimental conditions aren't perfect. This paper investigates whether EP-induced entanglement can survive non-uniform interactions, frequency detuning, and hybrid setups where some qubits are "lossy" and others are not.

Methods

The authors theoretically modeled a three-qubit system based on superconducting transmon circuits. They utilized a non-Hermitian Hamiltonian to describe the dynamics, specifically focusing on passive PT-symmetry (where the system only experiences loss, rather than a balance of gain and loss).

Key methodological components included:

  • Coupling Topologies: Comparing "all-to-all" coupling (every qubit talks to every other qubit) versus "nearest-neighbor" coupling (a chain-like interaction).
  • Entanglement Metrics: Using pairwise concurrence to check for two-qubit correlations, residual three-tangle ($\tau$) to identify GHZ states, and von Neumann entropy ($S_j$) to identify W states.
  • Numerical Simulation: Solving the Schrödinger-like equation for non-Hermitian systems and applying "post-selection" (mathematically normalizing the state to account for the loss of particles/energy).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This is a theoretical and numerical study; no external datasets were used, and no new benchmarks were established beyond the theoretical models presented.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Topology Dictates the State: The way qubits are wired determines the type of entanglement. All-to-all coupling naturally leads to GHZ states (highly entangled but fragile if one qubit is lost), while nearest-neighbor coupling produces W states (more robust to the loss of a single qubit).
  • The Speed Advantage: Non-Hermitian qubits generate entanglement roughly 50% faster than their Hermitian counterparts. This is because the proximity to an EP makes the system's state extremely sensitive to even weak inter-qubit couplings.
  • Robustness to "Messy" Physics: The entanglement is surprisingly resilient. It persists even when the coupling strengths between qubits are not identical or when the driving lasers are slightly off-resonance ($\Delta \neq 0$), as long as the "messiness" stays below the scale of the optimal coupling strength.
  • Hybrid Setup Failure: Interestingly, mixing Hermitian and non-Hermitian qubits in a "hybrid" setup prevents the formation of genuine tripartite entanglement. The mismatched evolution times between the "lossy" and "perfect" qubits cause the system to settle into simpler, bipartite (two-qubit) entangled states instead.

Key Results

  • GHZ Generation: For all-to-all coupling, the system reached a three-tangle ($\tau$) near 1 (perfect GHZ state) at approximately 3.23 µs.
  • W State Generation: For nearest-neighbor coupling, the system achieved entanglement entropies ($S_j \approx 0.637$) characteristic of a maximally entangled W state.
  • Phase Transitions: By tuning the Rabi frequency (driving strength), the authors showed the system transitions from a "PT-broken" phase (where loss kills entanglement) to a "PT-symmetric" phase. In the symmetric phase, strong driving can sustain entanglement over long periods by effectively "countering" the intrinsic losses of the system.
  • Coupling Sensitivity: In the low-dissipation regime, increasing the inter-qubit coupling strength ($J$) significantly enhances the entanglement growth rate.

Limitations and Future Work

  • The Cost of Post-Selection: Because the system is "passive" (only loss), the total probability of the system remaining in the desired state decreases over time. In a real experiment, this means many runs would be discarded, leading to a lower "success rate" even if the entanglement itself is high-quality.
  • Quantum Jumps: The study uses a non-Hermitian Hamiltonian approach, which is an approximation. It does not explicitly account for "quantum jumps"—the sudden, stochastic emission of a photon/energy packet—which could alter the entanglement dynamics in a real-world open system.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest exploring active PT-symmetry (adding gain) to boost success rates and investigating the non-Hermitian skin effect, where states pile up at the boundaries of a system, potentially creating even more exotic forms of multi-qubit entanglement.

Summary updated

Abstract

Non-Hermitian quantum systems have attracted significant interest in recent years due to the presence of unique spectral singularities known as exceptional points (EPs), where eigenvalues and eigenvectors coalesce. The drastic changes in these systems around their EPs have led to unique entanglement dynamics, which remained elusive until quite recently. In this work, we theoretically investigate the robustness of tripartite entanglement induced by EPs of the passive PT-symmetric non-Hermitian superconducting qubits, both in stand-alone configurations and hybrid setups with Hermitian qubits. In particular, we consider the qubits with both all-to-all and nearest-neighbour couplings under uniform and non-uniform coupling strengths. Our results reveal that non-Hermitian qubits with all-to-all coupling generate GHZ states, while those with nearest-neighbour interactions produce W states. These entangled states are resilient to non-uniform couplings and off-resonant driving fields. Moreover, the hybrid configurations combining Hermitian and non-Hermitian qubits suggest the importance of EPs for generating and maintaining genuine tripartite entanglement in our system. Additionally, driving the PT-symmetric qubits with a strong Rabi frequency can help sustain tripartite entanglement over time by countering losses, while strong inter-qubit coupling can benefit these entangled states in the low dissipation regime. These findings suggest that exploiting non-Hermitian systems and their associated EPs can create robust entangled states which are useful for both fundamental studies and quantum technologies.
BibTeX
@misc{feyisa2024robustness,
  author = {Chimdessa Gashu Feyisa and Chengyu Liu and Muhammad S. Hasan and J. S. You and Huan-Yu Ku and H. H. Jen},
  title = {{Robustness of tripartite entangled states in passive PT-symmetric qubits}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2411.17457},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.17457},
}

Loading related content...

Figure