Robust Sensitivity Analysis for Stochastic Systems

Henry LamMath. Oper. Res 2016 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel worst-case sensitivity analysis framework for stochastic systems, focusing on how model misspecification impacts performance measures. The authors develop asymptotic expansions for these worst-case measures, providing a tractable way to quantify model uncertainty using simulation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In stochastic modeling, we often rely on assumptions about system behavior that may not perfectly reflect reality. Understanding how deviations from these assumptions (model misspecification) affect our predictions of system performance is crucial. This paper tackles the challenge of quantifying this sensitivity, especially when we have limited information about the true model, only a baseline model, and the misspecification can be arbitrary within a certain "distance" (measured by Kullback-Leibler divergence). Directly solving these worst-case optimization problems is often intractable, particularly for complex systems.

Methods

The core contribution is the development of infinitesimal analysis for worst-case performance measures. The authors formulate these as optimization problems where the goal is to find the extreme performance value (maximum or minimum) subject to the true model's probability distribution being close to a baseline distribution in terms of KL divergence.

The key technical innovation is deriving asymptotic expansions of the optimal worst-case values as the KL divergence shrinks to zero. This means they express the worst-case performance as a series in powers of the "closeness" parameter (e.g., $\sqrt{\eta}$, $\eta$, $\eta^{3/2}$). The coefficients of these expansions are mathematically derived and can be computed via simulation, effectively transforming intractable optimization problems into estimable quantities. This approach is particularly useful for nonparametric settings where the exact form of the true model is unknown.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and numerical examples using simulated data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Worst-case analysis with KL divergence: The paper formalizes the idea of a "robust" performance measure by considering the worst possible outcome within a neighborhood defined by KL divergence from a baseline model. This is a powerful way to quantify uncertainty when specific distributional forms are unknown.
  • Asymptotic expansions as a solution: The central idea is that for small model deviations, the worst-case performance can be approximated by a Taylor-like expansion. This provides a practical and interpretable way to understand the impact of misspecification.
  • Simulation-based estimation: The coefficients of these expansions can be estimated through simulation, making the analysis accessible even for complex systems where analytical solutions are impossible.
  • Square root scaling of KL divergence: The first-order term in the asymptotic expansion scales with the square root of the KL divergence ($\sqrt{\eta}$). This suggests that the sensitivity to model misspecification is more pronounced than a linear relationship would imply.
  • Connection to influence functions: The paper highlights that the function $g(x)$ used in the analysis is related to the influence function in statistics, a concept used to measure the impact of individual data points on statistics. This provides a link to established statistical concepts.

Key Results

The paper derives asymptotic expansions for worst-case performance measures for:

  • Single-variable cost functions (T=1): The optimal value is expressed as $E_0[h(X)] + \sqrt{2\text{Var}_0(g(X))}\sqrt{\eta} + O(\eta)$.
  • Finite horizon systems (T>1): The expansion is generalized to $E_0[h(X_T)] + \sqrt{2\text{Var}_0(g(X))}\sqrt{\eta} + O(\eta)$, where $g(X)$ is a more complex function derived from the system's conditional expectations.
  • Random time horizon systems: Similar expansions are derived for systems with a random stopping time.

The numerical examples (M/M/s and G/G/s queues) demonstrate that the first-order approximations provide reasonable bounds for worst-case performance under various parametric deviations, and the relative impact of model misspecification can be significant, especially with fewer servers.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Intractability of exact worst-case models: While the expansions provide approximations, the exact worst-case probability distributions are generally not explicitly computed.
  • Assumptions: The analysis relies on assumptions like finite exponential moments for cost functions and non-degeneracy conditions for certain derived functions.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest extending the analysis to more general uncertainty sets beyond KL divergence, exploring different types of stochastic systems, and further investigating the relationship between parametric and nonparametric sensitivity. The paper also hints at generalizing the results to situations with multiple sources of uncertainty.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study a worst-case approach to measure the sensitivity to model misspecification in the performance analysis of stochastic systems. The situation of interest is when only minimal parametric info...
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lam2016robust,
  author = {Henry Lam},
  title = {{Robust Sensitivity Analysis for Stochastic Systems}},
  booktitle = {Math. Oper. Res},
  year = {2016},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=3oNXiax5RGS},
}
Figure