Robust Quantum Griffiths Singularity at above 1.5 Kelvin in Nitride Thin Films

Xiaoni Wang, Lijie Wang, Yixin Liu, Fan Chen, Wanpeng Gao, Yu Wu, Zulei Xu, Wei Peng, Zhen Wang, Zengfeng Di, Wei Li, Gang Mu, Zhirong LinarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have observed a "Robust Quantum Griffiths Singularity" (QGS) in Niobium Nitride (NbN) thin films at temperatures as high as 4.0 Kelvin—significantly higher than the millikelvin range where this quantum phenomenon is typically found. The study suggests that strong coupling between the magnetic field and electron spin (the Pauli paramagnetic effect) stabilizes superconducting "puddles," allowing quantum phase transition signatures to survive thermal fluctuations that would normally smear them out.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the world of condensed matter physics, phase transitions are usually driven by heat. However, at absolute zero, "quantum phase transitions" (QPTs) occur, driven by quantum fluctuations. A classic example is the transition from a superconductor to a metal induced by a magnetic field.

In perfectly clean systems, these transitions follow predictable power-law scaling. But real-world materials have "quenched disorder"—random impurities and structural defects. In two-dimensional systems, this disorder can lead to a Quantum Griffiths Singularity (QGS). Here, the system doesn't transition all at once; instead, "rare regions" or superconducting "puddles" persist in a sea of metal.

The challenge is that QGS is notoriously fragile. Because it relies on delicate quantum effects in these rare regions, it is usually only visible at extremely low temperatures (often below 100 mK). This paper investigates why NbN thin films exhibit QGS at much higher temperatures and what physical mechanisms make it so robust.

Methods

The researchers synthesized two specific Niobium Nitride (NbN) thin films (labeled W11 and W6) using DC reactive magnetron sputtering. These films were roughly 20–25 nm thick.

To probe the quantum behavior, they:

  1. Transport Measurements: Measured the sheet resistance ($R_s$) as a function of temperature ($T$) and magnetic field ($B$) up to 12 Tesla.
  2. Scaling Analysis: They applied two mathematical frameworks to the data:
  3. Conventional Power-Law Scaling: Used to extract the "dynamical critical exponent" ($z\nu$). A hallmark of QGS is that this exponent diverges (heads toward infinity) as the temperature approaches zero.
  4. Activated Scaling Analysis: A more complex model specifically designed for the "infinite-randomness" limit of a Griffiths singularity. If the data from different temperatures and fields "collapse" onto a single curve when plotted using this scaling, it confirms the presence of QGS.

Datasets

As an experimental physics paper, the "datasets" consist of the high-precision transport measurements taken from the two NbN samples. These samples were chosen because they had different normal-state resistances ($R_N$) and superconducting transition temperatures ($T_c = 2.5\text{ K}$ and $3.9\text{ K}$), allowing the team to see how the QGS behavior changed with the degree of disorder.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Temperature Robustness: The most striking finding is that the QGS signatures—specifically the activated scaling behavior—remained valid up to 4.0 K. This is an order of magnitude higher than many previous observations in other 2D superconductors.
  • The Role of Spin: The authors argue that the robustness comes from the Pauli paramagnetic effect. In most superconductors, a magnetic field destroys superconductivity by affecting the orbital motion of electrons. In NbN, the field couples strongly to the electron spin (Zeeman coupling).
  • Stabilizing the "Puddles": Theoretical models suggest that spin-related pair-breaking leads to a higher energy barrier for forming superconducting puddles. This higher energy scale makes the puddles more "stiff" against thermal noise, allowing the Griffiths phase to survive at higher temperatures.
  • Disorder Tuning: By comparing the two samples, they found that as the normal-state resistance decreases (less disorder), the QGS features begin to fade, confirming that quenched disorder is the "fuel" for this singularity.

Key Results

  • Divergent Exponents: For both samples, the effective critical exponent $z\nu$ showed a clear divergent trend as temperature decreased, which is the "smoking gun" for a Quantum Griffiths Singularity.
  • Data Collapse: Using the activated scaling variable $\delta[\ln(T_0/T)]^{1/\nu\psi}$, the researchers achieved an excellent data collapse for all transport data in the range of 1.6 K to 4.0 K.
  • Critical Parameters: They identified the critical magnetic fields ($B_c$) as 7.50 T for sample W11 and 9.60 T for sample W6.
  • Comparison with Other Materials: The critical exponent product $\nu\psi$ was found to be $\sim 0.60$, which is consistent with observations in other materials like $InO_x$, but the temperature range for NbN is uniquely broad.

Limitations and Future Work

While the paper establishes that the QGS is robust in NbN, it doesn't precisely define the "cutoff" point. The authors note that in other materials (like $PdTe_2$), the QGS disappears when the normal-state resistance drops below a certain threshold.

Future Work will likely involve:

  • Systematically thinning or doping the NbN films to find the exact resistance boundary where the QGS vanishes.
  • Investigating other nitride-based superconductors to see if the Pauli paramagnetic effect is a universal "booster" for quantum singularities.
  • Exploring how these robust superconducting puddles might be harnessed for quantum sensing or topological quantum computing components that don't require dilution refrigerators.

Summary updated

Abstract

Quantum Griffiths singularity (QGS), which is closely correlated with the quenched disorder, is characterized by the divergence of the dynamical critical exponent and the presence of activated scaling behavior. Typically such a quantum phenomenon is rather rare and only observed in extremely low temperatures. Here we report the experimental observation of a robust QGS in nitride thin films, NbN, which survives in a rather high temperature range. The electrical transport propertied were measured under the magnetic field up to 12 T. The field induced superconductor-metal transitions were observed with the continuously changed transition points with the decrease of temperature. The dynamical critical exponent based on the conventional power-law scaling reveals a divergent trend when approaching the the low temperature limit. Moreover, the temperature and field dependence of sheet resistance can be described by the activated scaling analysis in the temperature region up to 1.6 K $\leq T \leq$ 4.0 K. We argue that the robustness of QGS in the present system originates from the Pauli paramagnetic effect due to the strong coupling between the magnetic field and the spin degree of freedom.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2022robust,
  author = {Xiaoni Wang and Lijie Wang and Yixin Liu and Fan Chen and Wanpeng Gao and Yu Wu and Zulei Xu and Wei Peng and Zhen Wang and Zengfeng Di and Wei Li and Gang Mu and Zhirong Lin},
  title = {{Robust Quantum Griffiths Singularity at above 1.5 Kelvin in Nitride Thin Films}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2211.05393},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2211.05393},
}

Loading related content...

Figure