Robust Planning in Uncertain Environments

Stephen G. Pimentel, Lawrence M. BremUAI 1994

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel decision-theoretic planning framework that enhances robustness in uncertain environments by explicitly modeling action failures and allowing users to tune risk-aversion. The core contribution is a "robustness factor" that parameterizes utility functions, enabling planners to compute conditional plans that balance expected utility with a guaranteed minimum outcome, a significant improvement over traditional goal-oriented planning.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional AI planning systems often operate under the assumption that actions will always succeed. This works well in deterministic environments but breaks down when faced with real-world uncertainty, where actions can fail. When failures occur, conventional planners typically resort to replanning at execution time, which can be inefficient and lead to suboptimal outcomes. The challenge is to develop planning methods that can proactively account for potential action failures and generate plans that are resilient to these uncertainties, ensuring a reasonable outcome even when things go wrong.

Methods

The authors extend the classic STRIPS planning formalism to incorporate decision theory. Key innovations include:

  • Non-deterministic Actions: Operators are modified to have multiple possible outcomes, each with an associated probability. This moves beyond the single-outcome assumption of STRIPS.
  • Utility Functions: States are assigned a value (utility), and planning aims to maximize expected utility. This allows for tradeoffs between objectives and partial satisfaction.
  • Robustness Factor (R): A novel parameter, R, is introduced to modulate the utility function. This factor allows users to specify their desired level of risk-aversion. A higher R leads to more conservative plans that prioritize avoiding low-value outcomes, while a lower R prioritizes maximizing expected value.
  • AND/OR Tree Search: The planning problem is framed as searching an AND/OR tree. A depth-limited search algorithm is employed to manage computational complexity, backing up expected utilities from terminal states.
  • Conditional Plans: The algorithm generates "conditional plans" that represent a set of contingencies for each possible outcome of an action, ensuring robustness across all scenarios.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The authors introduce a "slippery blocks world" domain for experimental evaluation, which is an extension of the classic blocks world problem to include non-deterministic actions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Quantifying Robustness: The introduction of the "robustness factor" provides a principled way to quantify and control a planner's risk-aversion, moving beyond simple success/failure assumptions.
  • Trade-off Between Expected Value and Variance: The robustness factor allows for a direct trade-off between maximizing the average outcome (expected value) and minimizing the variability of outcomes (variance). This is crucial for applications where avoiding catastrophic failures is as important as achieving high rewards.
  • Conditional Plans as a Generalization: The generated conditional plans are a powerful representation that implicitly handles contingencies, offering a more robust alternative to linear plans.
  • Utility Function as a Risk Tuner: The analytical form of the utility function, parameterized by R, elegantly integrates risk preference into the planning process.

Key Results

The experimental results in the slippery blocks world domain demonstrate the effectiveness of the robustness factor:

  • Tuning Risk: Plans generated with higher robustness factors (e.g., R=0.6) showed lower standard deviations in simulation outcomes, indicating more predictable and less risky behavior compared to plans with lower robustness factors (e.g., R=0.5).
  • Guaranteed Minimums: While lower R values led to higher average scores, higher R values provided a better guarantee of achieving at least a certain minimum score. For instance, the R=0.6 plan was less likely to result in a state with a score below 23.
  • Illustrative Examples: Figures 13 and 14 visually show how plans with different robustness factors lead to different strategies, with higher R favoring more conservative approaches that require fewer successful actions to reach a reasonable outcome.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: The paper acknowledges that the exponential growth of the AND/OR tree makes exhaustive search impractical. The use of depth-limited search is an approximation, meaning computed expected utilities are approximate, and chosen actions may not be strictly optimal.
  • Branch-and-Bound: The authors mention integrating branch-and-bound techniques to improve efficiency by pruning the search space, suggesting this as a path for future work.
  • Domain-Specific Utility Functions: While the robustness factor is domain-independent, the specific utility function used (UR(V) = V^(1-R)) is an analytical form. Future work could explore more complex or learned utility functions.
  • Execution Probability: The paper uses a fixed "execution probability" for simulations, which may differ from the actual probabilities of action outcomes. Further research could explore how to handle discrepancies between planning-time probabilities and execution-time realities.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{pimentel1994robust,
  author = {Stephen G. Pimentel and Lawrence M. Brem},
  title = {{Robust Planning in Uncertain Environments}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {1994},
}
Figure