Abstract
We investigate the utility and robustness of a new statistic, $ω_{\ell}\left(r_{c}\right)$, for analyzing Baryon Acoustic Oscillations (BAO). We apply $ω_{\ell}\left(r_{c}\right)$, introduced in Xu et al. (2010), to mocks and data from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS)-III Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey (BOSS) included in the SDSS Data Release Eleven (DR11). We fit the anisotropic clustering using the monopole and quadrupole of the $ω_{\ell}\left(r_{c}\right)$ statistic in a manner similar to conventional multipole fitting methods using the correlation function as detailed in (Xu et al. 2012). To test the performance of the $ω_{\ell}\left(r_{c}\right)$ statistic we compare our results to those obtained using the multipoles. The results are in agreement. We also conduct a brief investigation into some of the possible advantages of using the $ω_{\ell}\left(r_{c}\right)$ statistic for BAO analysis. The $ω_{\ell}\left(r_{c}\right)$ analysis matches the stability of the multipoles analysis in response to artificially introduced distortions in the data, without using extra nuisance parameters to improve the fit. When applied to data with systematics, the $ω_{\ell}\left(r_{c}\right)$ statistic again matches the performance of fitting the multipoles without using nuisance parameters. In all the analyzed circumstances, we find that fitting the $ω_{\ell}\left(r_{c}\right)$ statistic removes the requirement for extra nuisance parameters.
Introduction: The Challenge of Large-Scale Systematics
Cosmologists use Baryon Acoustic Oscillations (BAO)—essentially "frozen" sound waves from the early universe—as a standard ruler to measure cosmic distances and the expansion rate of the universe. Traditionally, this is achieved by analyzing the correlation function of galaxy distributions, specifically its monopole and quadrupole components.
However, real-world observational data is often plagued by large-scale systematics, such as variations in stellar density or atmospheric conditions. These effects distort the correlation function at large scales. To mitigate this, researchers typically introduce "nuisance parameters"—extra polynomial terms added to the model to absorb these errors. While effective, these parameters increase model complexity and can potentially obscure the underlying cosmological signal.
A Filtered Approach: The $\omega_\ell(r_c)$ Statistic
To address these limitations, this study explores the $\omega_\ell(r_c)$ statistic. Unlike the standard correlation function, $\omega_\ell(r_c)$ employs a specialized mathematical filter that is both "compact" and "compensated."
- Compactness: The filter focuses specifically on scales around the BAO feature (~100 $h^{-1}$ Mpc), ignoring very small and very large scales.
- Compensation: The filter is designed to be insensitive to constant offsets and smooth, large-scale fluctuations—the very regions where observational "junk" signals reside.
By convolving the correlation function with this filter, the researchers create a statistic that is naturally robust against the large-scale distortions that usually require nuisance parameters.
Methodology and Data
The performance of the $\omega_\ell(r_c)$ statistic was validated using two primary datasets:
- SDSS-III BOSS DR11: Real galaxy data from the CMASS sample at redshift $z \approx 0.57$.
- PTHalos Mocks: A suite of 600 simulated galaxy catalogs used to estimate covariance matrices and test the method's accuracy against known benchmarks.
The researchers fitted the monopole ($\ell=0$) and quadrupole ($\ell=2$) of the $\omega_\ell(r_c)$ statistic to determine the isotropic shift ($\alpha$) and anisotropic warping ($\epsilon$) parameters, comparing the results directly to standard multipole fitting methods.
Key Findings
The study demonstrates that the $\omega_\ell(r_c)$ statistic provides cosmological constraints as precise as traditional methods but with significantly enhanced robustness:
- Stability: The statistic remained stable even when artificial distortions were injected into the data. It recovered the correct cosmological parameters without the need for additional "nuisance" polynomial terms.
- Consistency: On the DR11 data, $\omega_\ell(r_c)$ yielded $\alpha = 1.029 \pm 0.020$ and $\epsilon = -0.003 \pm 0.023$, in excellent agreement with standard analyses.
- Systematic Immunity: The statistic's inherent "high-pass" filtering nature allows it to ignore problematic large-scale modes, making it less dependent on complex observational weights.
Conclusion
The $\omega_\ell(r_c)$ statistic represents a significant simplification for BAO analysis. By removing the requirement for nuisance parameters, it offers a cleaner, more direct path to measuring the expansion of the universe. This robustness makes it a promising tool for next-generation surveys like DESI and Euclid, where managing observational systematics will be paramount.
Summary updated