Robust Low-Rank Tensor Recovery: Models and Algorithms

Donald Goldfarb, Zhiwei Tony QinSIAM J. Matrix Anal. Appl 2014 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces novel algorithms for robustly recovering low-rank tensors from corrupted and incomplete data. They propose both convex and nonconvex models, along with efficient optimization techniques, to handle real-world scenarios where data is often noisy and sparse, outperforming existing methods in accuracy and speed.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern data is increasingly multidimensional, existing as tensors (arrays with more than two dimensions). Analyzing these tensors is crucial for fields like computer vision, signal processing, and web data mining. However, tensor decomposition methods, analogous to Principal Component Analysis (PCA) for matrices, are highly sensitive to outliers and missing values. This means that even a few "bad" data points can completely skew the results, rendering the analysis useless. The challenge is to develop methods that can accurately recover the underlying low-rank structure of a tensor despite significant corruption and missing information.

Methods

The authors tackle this problem by proposing several new models and algorithms:

  • Convex Optimization Framework: They frame the problem as finding a low-rank tensor that, when added to a sparse error tensor, reconstructs the observed corrupted data. This is inspired by robust PCA techniques.
  • Singleton Model: This model assumes the tensor is low-rank in all its modes (dimensions). They develop efficient Alternating Direction Augmented Lagrangian (ADAL) and Accelerated Proximal Gradient (APG) algorithms to solve this.
  • Mixture Model: This is a more relaxed version, allowing the tensor to be low-rank in some modes but not necessarily all. This is useful when prior knowledge about which modes are low-rank is unavailable. They propose an inexact ADAL algorithm for this.
  • Nonconvex Optimization Model: They also introduce a model that explicitly enforces constraints on the Tucker rank (a measure of rank for each mode). While nonconvex problems are generally harder to solve, they develop an ADAL-based algorithm that finds good approximate solutions.
  • Algorithm Design: The core of their algorithmic contribution lies in adapting and extending ADAL and APG methods. These methods are known for their efficiency and ability to handle complex optimization problems by breaking them down into smaller, manageable subproblems. They also incorporate techniques like variable-splitting and continuation schemes to improve convergence speed.

Datasets

The paper evaluates their methods on a variety of datasets:

  • Synthetic Data: Generated tensors with controlled rank, size, and levels of corruption and missing observations. This allows for precise evaluation of recovery accuracy.
  • 3D MRI Data (INCISIX): Real-world medical imaging data used to test robustness to gross corruptions and partial observations.
  • Amino Acid Fluorescence Data: A dataset known to be free of outliers, used to establish a baseline for low-rank ground truth.
  • YaleB Face Database: Used for face representation tasks, demonstrating the ability to reconstruct images with reduced noise and shadows.
  • Game Data: A dynamic dataset used to test background reconstruction from a small fraction of available pixels, simulating scenarios with significant foreground objects.
  • Dorrit Fluorescence EEM Data: A dataset known to contain both scattering (a type of noise) and outliers, used to test robustness against multiple corruption types.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Convexity is Powerful but Not Always Sufficient: The convex models (Singleton and Mixture) provide strong theoretical guarantees and good performance, especially when the underlying tensor structure aligns with the model assumptions.
  • The "Phase Transition" Phenomenon: For the Singleton model, they observe a critical "phase transition" in the fraction of observations required for accurate recovery. Below this threshold, recovery is poor; above it, accuracy drastically improves. This highlights the importance of sufficient data.
  • Mixture Model for Heterogeneous Rank: When a tensor isn't low-rank in all modes, the Mixture model significantly outperforms the Singleton model, demonstrating the value of a more flexible approach.
  • Nonconvex Model for Precise Rank Information: The nonconvex model, when provided with accurate Tucker rank information (potentially revealed by the convex models), can achieve even better recovery, especially in terms of noise reduction and detail preservation.
  • ADAL Algorithms are Efficient: The proposed ADAL-based algorithms consistently outperform FISTA-based methods in terms of both speed and recovery accuracy across various datasets.

Key Results

  • Superior Accuracy: HoRPCA-S (Singleton model) consistently achieved higher recovery accuracy than other algorithms, especially in scenarios with low-rank tensors in all modes.
  • Robustness to Corruption: The methods demonstrated significant robustness to high percentages of corrupted data (up to 40% in some synthetic experiments).
  • Efficiency: ADAL-based algorithms were several times faster than FISTA-based alternatives.
  • Real-world Performance: The algorithms showed strong performance on diverse real-world datasets, including MRI, fluorescence spectroscopy, and face recognition, effectively removing noise and recovering underlying structures. For instance, in the YaleB face dataset, the nonconvex model provided the best performance in noise removal and shadow reduction.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Nonconvex Model Convergence: While the ADAL algorithm for the nonconvex model shows strong empirical convergence, a formal proof of convergence for the iterates is still lacking.
  • Parameter Tuning: While the algorithms are generally robust, some parameters (like regularization weights) still require careful tuning, especially for the adaptive versions.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest several avenues for future research:
  • Deriving theoretical conditions for exact recoverability based on observation fractions, error sparsity, and Tucker rank.
  • Developing methods for automatically learning penalty weights in adaptive models.
  • Applying these techniques to new applications where matrix-based methods are insufficient.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{goldfarb2014robust,
  author = {Donald Goldfarb and Zhiwei Tony Qin},
  title = {{Robust Low-Rank Tensor Recovery: Models and Algorithms}},
  journal = {SIAM J. Matrix Anal. Appl.},
  year = {2014},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=2uZrL1S7b_},
}
Figure