Robust Linear Regression: Phase-Transitions and Precise Tradeoffs for General Norms

Elvis Dohmatob, Meyer ScetbonarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper provides a theoretical framework for understanding the trade-off between adversarial robustness and predictive accuracy in linear regression models. The authors derive precise analytical results that reveal distinct "regimes" where robustness can be achieved without sacrificing accuracy, and others where a compromise is unavoidable, depending on the nature of the data and the adversarial attack.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Adversarial examples, small perturbations to input data that can drastically alter a machine learning model's prediction, are a well-known vulnerability. While much research has focused on classification, the problem of adversarial robustness in regression, particularly linear regression, has been less understood. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a theoretical characterization of the optimal level of robustness achievable for linear regression models under various attack norms and data distributions. Specifically, they ask: "If a linear regression model has a small standard error (accuracy), how much adversarial error can it tolerate, and is it possible to be robust while remaining accurate?"

Methods

The authors employ a combination of theoretical analysis and mathematical tools. Key techniques include:

  • Adversarial Risk Formulation: They define and analyze the adversarial risk, which measures the worst-case prediction error under an attack of a given strength and norm.
  • Analytic Formulas for Optimal Robustness: They derive closed-form expressions for the optimal adversarial risk and the corresponding robust model parameters. This involves analyzing the structure of the optimal robust model, which is shown to be a regularized version of the generative model.
  • Phase-Transition Diagrams: By analyzing their analytical results, they identify critical thresholds in the data's spectral properties and attack strength that dictate whether a "free lunch" (robustness without accuracy loss) is possible or if a tradeoff is necessary.
  • Generalization to Arbitrary Norms and Covariance Matrices: Unlike previous works that were often limited to specific norms (e.g., Euclidean) or isotropic data, this paper's analysis applies to general attack norms and arbitrary feature covariance matrices.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments are conducted on simulated data generated according to specific distributions defined in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Regimes of Robustness: The paper reveals that the relationship between accuracy and robustness is not monolithic. There exist distinct "regimes" determined by the data's properties (e.g., spectral decay of the covariance matrix) and the attack's nature (e.g., norm used).
  • "Free Lunch" Threshold: For certain data and attack configurations, there's a "free lunch" where models can be made robust without any loss in standard predictive accuracy. This occurs when the model's inherent accuracy is sufficiently high.
  • Critical Role of Spectral Properties: The spectral properties of the feature covariance matrix and the generative model's coefficients play a crucial role in determining the trade-offs. For instance, a "smooth" generative model (related to the decay rate of its coefficients) can lead to better robustness.
  • Generalization Beyond Euclidean Norms: The framework extends beyond the commonly studied Euclidean-norm attacks, offering insights into robustness under more general threat models.

Key Results

  • Analytic Characterization: The paper provides precise analytical formulas for the optimal adversarial risk and the optimal robust model, which is a regularized version of the generative model.
  • Phase Transitions: They identify critical values for parameters (like the spectral decay exponent $\delta$) that mark phase transitions in robustness behavior. For example, a critical value of $\delta=1$ is identified where the generative model switches from being non-robust to robust.
  • Trade-off Quantification: The results precisely quantify the trade-off between standard risk (accuracy) and adversarial risk. For instance, in certain regimes, they show that the adversarial risk of accurate models scales as $(1-\epsilon)^2$, where $\epsilon$ is the excess standard risk.
  • Empirical Validation: The theoretical predictions are validated through experiments on simulated data, demonstrating strong agreement between the derived formulas and empirical observations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on Linear Models: The current work is focused on linear regression. Extending these findings to non-linear models, such as neural networks, is a natural and important future direction.
  • Noisy Signals and Finite Data: The analysis primarily considers noiseless signals and infinite data regimes. Investigating the impact of noise and finite sample sizes on these trade-offs would be valuable.
  • Overfitting: The paper acknowledges that the analysis is agnostic to how the model is learned (e.g., gradient descent, adversarial training) and does not explicitly study the effects of overfitting, which could lead to different accuracy-robustness trade-offs.
  • Random Matrix Theory: The authors suggest that applying random matrix theory could help reduce more complex scenarios (like neural networks in linearized regimes) to the linear case, offering a path for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we investigate the impact of test-time adversarial attacks on linear regression models and determine the optimal level of robustness that any model can reach while maintaining a given level of standard predictive performance (accuracy). Through quantitative estimates, we uncover fundamental tradeoffs between adversarial robustness and accuracy in different regimes. We obtain a precise characterization which distinguishes between regimes where robustness is achievable without hurting standard accuracy and regimes where a tradeoff might be unavoidable. Our findings are empirically confirmed with simple experiments that represent a variety of settings. This work applies to feature covariance matrices and attack norms of any nature, and extends beyond previous works in this area.
BibTeX
@misc{dohmatob2023robust,
  author = {Elvis Dohmatob and Meyer Scetbon},
  title = {{Robust Linear Regression: Phase-Transitions and Precise Tradeoffs for General Norms}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2308.00556},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2308.00556},
}
Figure