Robust H-Infinity Tracking Control for a Valve-Controlled Hydraulic Motor System with Uncertain Parameters in the Complex Load Environment

Kunwei Lu, Guodong Feng, Beichen DingSensors 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of maintaining stable speed in valve-controlled hydraulic motor systems operating under unpredictable and fluctuating load conditions. The authors propose a novel robust H-infinity tracking control strategy that treats load torque as an internal disturbance, leading to improved performance and robustness compared to traditional PID control, as demonstrated through simulations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Valve-controlled hydraulic motor systems are widely used in various industries due to their precision and power. However, their performance, particularly speed stability, is significantly impacted by complex and often unpredictable load changes. These load variations can be so severe that they act as disturbance signals with complex frequencies and strong amplitude fluctuations. This instability reduces operating efficiency and can lead to system malfunctions, such as a drill getting stuck. Existing control methods often struggle to effectively handle these dynamic and uncertain load disturbances, especially when system parameters themselves are not precisely known. The paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a control strategy that robustly handles both parameter uncertainties and internal load disturbances.

Methods

The core of this paper lies in the development and application of a robust H-infinity tracking control strategy. Here's a breakdown of their approach:

  • System Modeling with Uncertainties: The authors first analyze the structure of a valve-controlled hydraulic motor system and develop a dynamic model. Crucially, they account for uncertainties in system parameters (like motor displacement, system volume, and inertia) and model linearization errors. These uncertainties are represented using upper linear fractional transformations (LFTs).
  • Internal Disturbance Handling: A key innovation is how they treat the load torque. Unlike common H-infinity approaches that consider load as an external disturbance, this paper models it as an internal disturbance within the system. This is a more accurate representation for hydraulic systems where load directly affects the motor's dynamics.
  • Robust H-Infinity Control: They then design an H-infinity controller. This control methodology is known for its ability to minimize the influence of disturbances on the system output while ensuring stability. The controller is designed to minimize the H-infinity norm of the closed-loop transfer function from the load disturbance to the system error.
  • Controller Design: The H-infinity controller is designed using the hinf'syn function in MATLAB's robust control toolbox, leveraging the derived state-space model of the uncertain system.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulation results based on a derived model and parameter values from specific hydraulic components (MOOG G7613005B servo proportional valve and STANLEY GR29 fixed displacement motor).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Load Torque as an Internal Disturbance is Crucial: Treating load torque as an internal disturbance, rather than an external one, significantly improves the robustness of the control system. This is because it avoids the need for load observation, which can introduce additional errors due to uncertain factors.
  • H-Infinity Control Excels in Uncertainty: The H-infinity framework is inherently well-suited for systems with parameter uncertainties, providing a systematic way to design controllers that guarantee performance and stability across a range of possible parameter variations.
  • Balancing Tracking and Disturbance Rejection: The H-infinity controller design allows for a trade-off between tracking performance (following the desired speed) and disturbance rejection (mitigating the impact of load torque). Weighting functions play a critical role in shaping this balance.
  • Simulation Demonstrates Superiority: The simulation results clearly indicate that the proposed H-infinity controller outperforms traditional PID control in handling various load conditions, especially those with abrupt changes and complex frequency components.

Key Results

The paper presents simulation results comparing the proposed H-infinity controller with a traditional PID controller under various load conditions:

  • No-Load Torque: The H-infinity controller achieved a faster rise time (0.036 s vs. 0.1 s) with a slightly lower steady-state error (0.0068 rad/s vs. 0.0078 rad/s).
  • Abrupt Load Torque Change: Both controllers recovered quickly, but the H-infinity controller exhibited a significantly smaller steady-state error (0.02 rad/s vs. 0.052 rad/s), demonstrating better resistance to load disturbances.
  • Single-Frequency Load Torque: The H-infinity controller again showed a faster rise time (0.059 s vs. 0.12 s) and a smaller peak-to-peak value (0.012 rad/s vs. 0.035 rad/s) and steady-state error (0.012 rad/s vs. 0.02 rad/s), indicating better suppression of sinusoidal load disturbances.
  • Complex-Frequency Load Torque: While both controllers showed some fluctuation, the H-infinity controller avoided the oscillations seen with the PID controller, maintaining better tracking stability and a good overall tracking effect.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Verification: The authors acknowledge that the study is based on kinetic equations and simulations. They state that physical experimental verification has yet to be completed, which is a significant limitation.
  • Modeling Simplifications: While uncertainties are considered, the modeling might still involve simplifications. The paper mentions that more detailed modeling and physical experimental verification are needed for a more complete discussion.
  • Parameter Uncertainty Range: The study uses a specific percentage (25%) for parameter uncertainty. Future work could explore the controller's performance with a wider range of uncertainties.
  • Controller Tuning: The paper mentions that the weight factor p influences reaction time. Further research could focus on optimal tuning of these weighting functions for different operational requirements.

Summary updated

Abstract

A valve-controlled hydraulic motor system operating in a complex environment is subject to complex load changes. In extreme cases, the load can be regarded as a disturbance signal with complex frequency and strong amplitude fluctuations, which greatly affects the speed stability of the hydraulic motor and reduces the operating efficiency. In this paper, the structure of valve-controlled hydraulic motor systems is analyzed, and a valve-controlled hydraulic motor system model with uncertain parameters is established after considering the actual target parameter error and model linearization error. Different from the common H-infinity control, which regards the load disturbance as external disturbance, this paper presents a robust H-infinity tracking control strategy, which considers uncertain parameters and the load torque of the valve-controlled hydraulic motor system as internal disturbances. The simulation results show that the proposed control scheme has better control characteristics and robustness than the traditional PID control.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lu2023robust,
  author = {Kunwei Lu and Guodong Feng and Beichen Ding},
  title = {{Robust H-Infinity Tracking Control for a Valve-Controlled Hydraulic Motor System with Uncertain Parameters in the Complex Load Environment}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/s23229092},
}
Figure