Robust Finite-Time Control of a Multi-AUV Formation Based on Prescribed Performance

Juan Li, Zhenyang Tian, Honghan Zhang, Wenbo LiJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of coordinating multiple Autonomous Underwater Vehicles (AUVs) to maintain a formation, even when facing unpredictable ocean disturbances. They introduce a novel control strategy that combines "prescribed performance" to ensure smooth and fast convergence of AUVs to their desired formation, with "finite-time sliding-mode observers" to accurately estimate and counteract unknown environmental forces in real-time. This leads to more robust and efficient multi-AUV formations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coordinating multiple AUVs for tasks like marine exploration or underwater construction is crucial for efficiency and capability. However, achieving stable and synchronized formation control for these vehicles is difficult due to several factors:

  • Unknown Ocean Disturbances: AUVs operate in a dynamic environment with unpredictable currents, waves, and other forces that can easily disrupt their planned trajectories and formations.
  • Complex AUV Dynamics: The inherent nonlinear dynamics of AUVs, including their inertia and hydrodynamic forces, make precise control challenging.
  • Need for Fast and Reliable Convergence: For many applications, it's not enough for AUVs to eventually reach their formation; they need to do so quickly and reliably, without excessive overshoot or oscillations.
  • Robustness: The control system must be resilient to these disturbances and uncertainties to ensure mission success.

Traditional control methods often struggle to balance these competing requirements, leading to slow convergence, susceptibility to disturbances, or complex control designs. This paper aims to develop a control strategy that addresses these issues by ensuring both fast, precise formation control and robustness against unknown environmental factors.

Methods

The authors propose a multi-pronged approach to achieve robust finite-time formation control:

  1. Feedback Linearization: The complex nonlinear dynamics of a single AUV are first simplified into a more manageable second-order integral model. This is a standard technique to transform nonlinear systems into a linear form, making controller design easier.
  2. Prescribed Performance Control: To ensure that the AUVs converge to their desired formation quickly and smoothly, the researchers employ a "prescribed performance" framework. This involves:
  3. Performance Functions: Defining specific functions that dictate the desired bounds and convergence rate of the tracking errors. This allows for explicit control over transient behavior like overshoot and settling time.
  4. Error Conversion: A novel error-conversion function is used to transform the "constrained" tracking errors (those within the prescribed performance bounds) into "unconstrained" errors. This simplifies the subsequent controller design. The paper introduces an improved performance function that allows for setting a specific terminal convergence time.
  5. Finite-Time Sliding-Mode Disturbance Observers: To handle the unknown ocean disturbances, the paper designs specialized observers. These observers:
  6. Estimate Disturbances in Finite Time: Unlike traditional observers that might only guarantee asymptotic convergence (approaching zero over infinite time), these observers are designed to accurately estimate the unknown disturbances within a finite, predictable time. This is achieved using a finite-time sliding-mode approach.
  7. Improve Robustness: By accurately estimating and then compensating for these disturbances, the control system becomes significantly more robust.
  8. Fast Terminal Sliding-Mode Formation Controller: Finally, a controller is designed based on the unconstrained tracking errors and the estimated disturbances. This controller ensures that the entire multi-AUV formation converges to the desired configuration in finite time.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation is performed through simulation experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Combining Prescribed Performance and Finite-Time Observers: The core insight is that by synergistically combining prescribed performance for desired transient behavior and finite-time observers for disturbance rejection, one can achieve a highly robust and efficient formation control system for AUVs.
  • Finite-Time Convergence is Achievable and Beneficial: The paper demonstrates that it's possible to guarantee that the formation converges within a specific, finite time, which is crucial for time-sensitive missions. This is a significant improvement over methods that only guarantee asymptotic convergence.
  • Explicit Control Over Transient Behavior: The prescribed performance framework allows engineers to precisely define how the AUVs should behave during the convergence phase (e.g., limiting overshoot), which is often overlooked in traditional control designs.
  • Accurate Disturbance Estimation is Key to Robustness: The finite-time sliding-mode observers are shown to be highly effective in estimating and canceling out unknown external forces, a critical factor for reliable operation in the ocean.

Key Results

The paper presents simulation results that demonstrate the effectiveness of their proposed method:

  • Accurate Disturbance Estimation: The finite-time sliding-mode disturbance observers accurately estimate unknown external perturbations, with observation errors converging to near zero in finite time.
  • Improved Formation Control: The proposed prescribed-performance-based fast terminal sliding-mode controller (PP-IFTSMC) shows superior performance compared to other advanced controllers (AFTSMC, FTSMC, NTSMC) in terms of:
  • Faster Convergence: The PP-IFTSMC achieves faster convergence of trajectory and attitude tracking errors.
  • Smoother Initial State: The initial state of the error curve is smoother with less fluctuation and jitter.
  • Better Trajectory Tracking: The 3D trajectory tracking results show that the proposed controller can better follow the desired trajectory.
  • Robustness to Disturbances: Simulations with unknown disturbances (e.g., current disturbances) show that the AUV formation can maintain its configuration and track the desired trajectory effectively.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The current work focuses on a simplified AUV model (five degrees of freedom) and assumes certain conditions (e.g., no transverse rocking motion).
  • The effectiveness of the controller in real-world scenarios with more complex and dynamic ocean environments needs further validation.
  • The paper does not explicitly discuss the computational complexity of the proposed method, which could be a factor for onboard implementation.
  • Future Work:
    • Investigating formation control for more complex dynamic models of AUVs.
  • Addressing communication delays in multi-AUV systems, potentially using stochastic process modeling.
  • Exploring the application of this control strategy to other multi-agent systems.
  • Real-world experimental validation of the proposed control scheme.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper focuses on the finite-time formation-control problem of a multi-AUV formation under unknown perturbations with prescribed performance. First, the nonlinear AUV model is transformed into a second-order integral model using feedback linearization. Suitable prescribed performance functions are selected to constrain the control errors of AUVs within a preset range and convert AUV tracking errors into unconstrained tracking errors using an error-conversion function to facilitate controller design. Finite-time sliding-mode disturbance observers are designed for unknown disturbances in the ocean so that they can accurately estimate the unknown disturbances in finite time. Based on the unconstrained tracking error and the unknown disturbance observer, the fast terminal sliding-mode formation controller is designed so that the multi-AUV formation can converge in finite time. Finally, the simulation experimental results show that the finite-time formation-control method with prescribed performance proposed in this paper can better cancel the unknown disturbance in the ocean in finite time and improve the robustness of the multi-AUV formation control.
BibTeX
@article{li2023robust,
  author = {Juan Li and Zhenyang Tian and Honghan Zhang and Wenbo Li},
  title = {{Robust Finite-Time Control of a Multi-AUV Formation Based on Prescribed Performance}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse11050897},
}
Figure